4 ms·
mindfulness and meditation seems to be all the rage in recent years but looking at the physical state of many students these days and the stated goal: >"The go
by Barrin92 6y ago
mindfulness and meditation seems to be all the rage in recent years but looking at the physical state of many students these days and the stated goal:
>"The goal is to help them develop resilience, improve their attention and self-regulation, and prevent everyday stress spiralling into major psychological problems. "
I'd maybe recommend greatly expanding physical exercise and team sports because not only does it address many of the points above it also will reduce obesity and balance out general inactivity. Physical education seems to be severely neglected. Both quality and quantity.
- kingkongjaffa 6y agoHaving to take part in team sports were a negative part of schooling for me. Activities that can be done together but with the goal of self improvement / competing with yourself being the main goal always felt better. Like track and field / some kind of cardio / anything in the gym.
- huffmsa 6y agoI'm going to argue that it wasn't team sports, it was the infrequency with which you played them that caused the negativity. Working as a team is part of the human experience. Some people are more inclined to it than others, but given enough time and frequency working with the same unit, almost everyone becomes a comrade, a brother-in-arms, bonded through shared experiences. Team sports help develop social bonds and trust between peers, and those relationships help quite a few people deal with personal issues they would otherwise get stuck in their own heads trying to fight. Teamwork and working towards goals bigger than oneself are important to the psyche.
- fiblye 6y agoI’ve always hated sports. No matter how much I tried, I was horrible. All my school stress stemmed from PE and sports, and with how much of a focus “coolness” in school stems from sports performance, pressure simply grew and grew until I finally graduated. After graduating, I actively rejected sports and fitness because I associated it with the people who were good and I hated to be around, and it was nothing but negative connections in my mind. It wasn’t until a friend introduced me to weightlifting that I learned that I can not only enjoy exercise, but I can do it completely alone without anybody looking at me. A weight set and a bench to sit on are as close to meditation as exercise can get for me. I’m stronger than the average person. Visibly fit to the point that people comment on it. But every time someone has expected me to catch something or throw something to them, it’s a disaster. People can’t believe it because there’s the association of fitness level == sports ability, but there’s as connected as math and programming. It’s definitely good to be good at both and they definitely benefit each other, but you can also be incompetent at one and good at the other. I’ve definitely known some people who’ve never cared about basketball and don’t really exercise but almost never miss a shot if someone asks them to try.
- huffmsa 6y agoSome people are naturally good throwers and catchers, some need practice (myself). I've said it in other comments, but PE class is skewed towards those who can do well in random, infrequent "games". That's not the same as playing the same sport, with a team, every morning or afternoon.
- a-nikolaev 6y agoThis is a great story. On my part, I enjoyed playing soccer with my friends when I was a kid: We didn't have to perform or run fast, but we just did our best, and it was fun and fulfilling. On the other hand, our PE classes were often bland and not very fun: running, pull ups, push ups, occasionally basketball, which I struggled with a lot. (It was not in the US, so no one was getting much social benefits from being good at sports. But I see why your experience with school PE and sports feels so devastating.)
- watwut 6y ago> I'm going to argue that it wasn't team sports, it was the infrequency with which you played them that caused the negativity I am not the one you responded to, but I very much disliked team sports. I liked individual sports, including the ones I was bad at. Other kids did not became comrades in team sport, kids that did same individual sport became friends. I was the kid that had trouble to be assertive and had trouble to fight over ball with teammates. Because other kids in same team wont give the ball to someone else when they have fun with it. They want it for themselves, even when you are at good position. Team sports just sucked from social standpoint. The only shared experience always ended up being feeling that I don't belong here. The only thing I learned was to avoid the experience. It did worked for some other kids, but don't tell us it works for everyone. It does not.
- kingkongjaffa 6y ago>it was the infrequency with which you played them that >caused the negativity. At UK highschool we were forced to play football once / twice a week. All the kids who wanted to do this also played more through the week so they were good at it. The once/twice a week-ers were rubbish and it was just not fun. >but given enough time and frequency working with the same >unit, almost everyone becomes a comrade, a brother-in-arms, >bonded through shared experiences. This is complete bullshit, you've obviously never had players on the team screaming at you to do something with the ball and then messing it up. These kids are not your 'comrades' they play with you once or twice a week then go back to class. >Team sports help develop social bonds and trust between >peers, and those relationships help quite a few people deal >with personal issues they would otherwise get stuck in >their own heads trying to fight. Teamwork and working >towards goals bigger than oneself are important to the >psyche. You can do all of this without team sports.
- huffmsa 6y agoYeah my first thought before and after reading the article is that these kids don't need "mindfulness" to connect with their bodies and feelings, they need an extra 60-90 minutes of exercise. Particularly the boys. Preferably at the beginning of the day.
- watwut 6y agoIt funny, because at least in our local playground and in class my kids go to, girls are outside more then boys. Which applies especially when weather is not good, despite boys clothes being typically more suited to bad weather and easier to find. Maybe it is just anomaly, but I found it odd. Especially when everyone here is like "boys are so different and more wild". And I always think "why don't you take them outside then and why don't limit their sit-on-couch-with-tablet-game the way girls have it limited". It is kind of absurd.
- laingc 6y agoInteresting counterexample, and a good exemplar of the phenomenon that the nature of distributions is that occasionally one finds outliers such as this. I don't think it can reasonably be disputed though that in the average case it is true that boys are more physically active and spend more time outside than girls.
- watwut 6y agoI am not saying that boys are not physically active more. Whether kids are outside depends way more on parents then on kids. And for whatever reasons, boys parents around here take them outside less. I think that very related is that parents are more content with boys spending a lot of time with videogames. Which cuts to physical activity and makes kid content sitting for hours. And maybe parents are also more conscious with girls not getting enough of physical movement. Or it is also about friends. I personally think that boys would be better off if they were outside and moving more.
- laingc 6y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI stayed away from PE, for a couple of reasons: 1) The teachers were invariably bullies. They would belittle students that they did not feel “performed well.” Also, because of the nature of the class, this bullying could manifest in physical (not just verbal) form. PE was my “horror” class. I was terrified of it. 2) In the US, there is tremendous pressure to compete. Scoring is everywhere. I have never been a competitive person; always preferring consensus and cooperation. This attitude was highly discouraged in PE (often by nasty remarks from the teacher, and their “pets”). 3) I’m “on the spectrum,” and one of the manifestations of that, is rather poor coordination. I have never been able to perform well in any sport; no matter how hard I tried. I could get fit, but not good. Sour grapes? Maybe. But I do feel that bullying is a big problem in every society, and it is often done by the “winners,” so there’s no will to address it. No one wants to “hobble” their “stars.” I don’t see how deep breathing exercises will address that.
- lemonberry 6y agoI believe that at some point in our nation's history PE lost it's bearing and no longer became about "physical education" per se and became more about sports and game type classes. Games like dodgeball allowed the bullies – teachers included – to flourish. Physical education should be just that, an education on the body. How it moves, how to retain mobility, how to get stronger, etc. There are books on this, I don't have any references at the moment sorry. I used to be a personal trainer. I stopped being amazed at how little people knew about their bodies and how to move them pretty quickly. It's a sad state of affairs. While I don't think physical fitness will "cure" people with clinical depression and anxiety I believe it's an important tool in the toolkit.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> While I don't think physical fitness will "cure" people with clinical depression and anxiety I believe it's an important tool in the toolkit. I completely agree. Physical fitness, when taught without a focus on competition, is extremely valuable. I'm sure that a big reason for my non-competitive stance, is because I learned, quite early on, that I would never be able to do particularly well in any physically competitive arena, and it wasn't even worth trying. I am also of Irish/Scottish/English heritage. Pretty much the Platonic Ideal of "white." I live in NY, with a significant percentage of folks of Mediterranean descent. I don't tan. I stroke. I get sick of people telling "You can tan, just take sun in fifteen minute increments." For me, it is: Fifteen minutes -Ghost white Fifteen minutes -Ghost white Fifteen minutes -Ghost white Fifteen minutes -Bright red, peeling, and screaming No in-between. The same goes for my friends (and not-friends) that have normal coordination. I took six years of tennis lessons, and never got beyond "suck." I took a year of Kung-Fu, and never got beyond white belt. "Quitters never win, winners never quit, but those who never win, and never quit are idiots." -From a Despair, Inc. Demotivator https://despair.com/collections/retired/products/stupidity https://despair.com/collections/retired/products/stupidity (That's me, at tennis)
- silveroriole 6y agoWere you one of the kids who was good at sports? I remember school PE as being horrible for mental health. Anyone awkward, uncoordinated, unpopular, unhappy with their body, or just totally uninterested in competitive sports spent those lessons being ignored at best, shouted at at worst. Funny how in primary school we all happily ran about and played together at lunchtime, but enforced sports days and team sports made it very clear who was “good” and who was “bad”, and that those of us who were bad should just stay out of the way and not inconvenience our teammates. COMPETITIVE sports are obviously going to make those at the bottom miserable and foster resentment towards them: that’s kind of the point. e: oh, and let’s not forget the horrifying combinations of changing rooms, showers and puberty... and for those of us with glasses there was a whole extra dimension of being forced to swim or dodge flying balls in the rain while literally semi-blind...!
- huffmsa 6y agoPE is a bad example case. Infrequent, with random team assignments, playing random new sports and activities each class is obviously and definitely skewed towards those who are predisposed to coordination and teamwork traits. What the parent, and I in another comment are talking about is team sports with the same team, playing the same sport on a regular basis. Not many people are good at "red scooter dodge chicken" after 5 minutes of it. But playing the same thing day in, day out for a while (practice) makes you better at it. You start noticing you're improving, your teammates may not out you in the starting rotation, but they're going to start bonding with you because of proximity and the shared feeling of progress. You don't need to have the same competitive zeal as the top performers, but you need to want to be part of the group. I never saw anyone get ostracized in a team unless they continually refused to be part of it.
- silveroriole 6y agoSo, what are you going to do with the kids who don’t want to be a part of it and will simply never enjoy the experience of whiffing a ball every time? (Yes, it really is possible not to improve - see the other commenter who is on the spectrum, or anyone with dyspraxia, etc). Will you just say they deserve what they get? We’re presumably still talking about a situation where they’re forced to take part.
- elric 6y agoYup, and there's this assinine insistence on sitting still in class. Combined with playgrounds getting more boring and less active..
- raverbashing 6y agoOh yeah, the "make kids do more exercise! more PE classes!" is the second fiddle to the "stop being sad!" depression cure PE classes are mostly disgrace and a reason why I wasn't very fond of sports (ok not all sports). - Focus on "collective/team sports" - Absolutely no catering for different levels of skills - Bullies usually enjoy this classes because it's the one activity where they are good - Limited choices.
- sukilot 6y agoYou are saying that missing PE isn't the problem because PE classes are poorly run. Think on that. Physical exercise is an extremely well documented treatment for many cases of depression.
- raverbashing 6y ago> You are saying that missing PE isn't the problem This is nowhere to be found in my comment > Physical exercise is an extremely well documented treatment for many cases of depression. Sure let me know how that works out when you're being heckled or generally feeling embarrassed or uncomfortable while exercising I like exercise, but PE is a joke