4 ms·
As a Google search user (just like everyone else) stories like this make me wonder about the accuracy of all the data Google displays. Loads of people claim Goo
by onion2k 6y ago
As a Google search user (just like everyone else) stories like this make me wonder about the accuracy of all the data Google displays. Loads of people claim Google search is terrible. Is Google actually still good at understanding the information on the web these days, or are they just riding the reputation they build a decade ago?
- the_pwner224 6y agoLately in the results page it displays boxes with what it thinks is the answer to your question (e.g. if you search for 'maximum temperature of Intel CPU' it'll give you a number, with a link to the page it got it from). Those are very often extremely wrong for even slightly complex queries. Would be funny if I didn't see so many people blindly trusting those results.
- bagacrap 6y agoit's called a knowledge card and yes, I've witnessed many people for whom the search process stops after reading it. The knowledge card definitely adds legitimacy in many folks' minds, nevermind that Google scraped it off some kook anti vax website or whatever.
- jschwartzi 6y agoI stopped using Google 2 or 3 years ago because the search quality is really bad and it “helpfully” corrected many search terms to be not what I was searching for at all. It’s not really a good search engine anymore.
- input_sh 6y agoMy favourite case of this was when I searched for how to accomplish something specific in nginx and Google decided that the word apache is a synonym to nginx, giving me results for apache instead (even after I've put nginx within quotes). Would've preferred if it showed me "no results" instead.
- atoav 6y agofoobar "nginx" -apache Should do the trick
- ljm 6y agoSadly even DDG does this for me now. The other day I searched for 'gradle get environment variable'. DDG 'helpfully' corrected it, saying "showing results for gradle set environment variable", with a smaller text link below essentially saying "search what I actually asked for". It took me a while to spot that while wondering why most of the results are not relevant. Internet search just doesn't feel very good in general these days. I mean, that's not really an appropriate place to be second guessed by a computer.
- wpietri 6y agoUnfortunately, we software developers are unusually precise with language. I'm sure that Google (and now DDG) get better results on average. But yes, I spend an awful lot of times strategically adding quote marks to Google searches that at one point would have just worked.
- cgriswald 6y agoI think that’s the core of the problem. With strong googlefu you used to be able to find what you wanted if it existed. Google have made search far easier; for imprecise searches the top few hits are probably going to be what I want. But if I need something precise, Google can’t help me anymore, no matter what arcane set of search terms, symbols, and flags I use. I also wish Google would detect when one page and another page are just the same content with different wrappers. You see this a lot with multiple sites that re post mailing list conversations. Google will not only return all the different sites, but will return replies, etc. as if they are unique results. So your entire first page can be a single conversation that just happens to be plastered all over the internet.
- pessimizer 6y agoThis began the day google decided that quotes were no longer an instruction to ignore pages without the exact sequence of characters that were between those quotes, but instead a tag indicating that the part of the search in quotes couldn't be silently discarded as if you hadn't typed it. I've always suspected that this was actually a way to reduce their database size and simplify calculations (i.e. reduce costs and response time) rather than a way to make non-expert searches more forgiving. Non-experts weren't using quotes, and when they were, they meant them to be literal. > I also wish Google would detect when one page and another page are just the same content with different wrappers. I've never quite understood this. I consider it an abdication from even the attempt to be a useful, complete search engine, and the indication of a change in company direction. Incidentally, DDG (my SE of choice) isn't much better at this stuff. Lots of repetitive listings of the same copy as top listings, and I think it stems quoted stuff. I'm forgiving because I think most of its results are derived from the results of larger indexes that adopted google's style.
- vbezhenar 6y agoI don't like Google domination and regularly trying to use other engines. So far Google just miles ahead of everyone else. I don't know whether Google is good at understanding or not, but it's much better than other alternatives. At least for my queries.
- detritus 6y agoI had a run in with a client who kept sending me packages that I didn't receive. Turns out she was using the address listed in the automated Google info box for my business - something I had no hand in, and which was incorrect. It looked ostensibly like my address, but was fundamentally not. Obviously it would have been better had she used the address listed on my website, or indeed the signature of every email I've sent her for the past few years, but she's a human, so allowed to make her own mistakes. I'm not sure I'm comfortable with Google making mistakes on my behalf however...
- ViViDboarder 6y agoExactly. As a search engine, directing to primary sources they are still doing ok (though I’ve switched mostly to DDG). The Knowledge stuff they surface now above flaunts often inaccurate or sub-par information as truth above organic results containing the primary sources.