5 ms·
I find the fact talks fell through particularly concerning as right now we should all be presenting a united front against China. I also think they should call
by LatteLazy 6y ago
I find the fact talks fell through particularly concerning as right now we should all be presenting a united front against China.
I also think they should call this a digital tax or apply it only to digital services. I understand that’s where the biggest impact will be felt but a minimum corporation tax rate shouldn’t depend on business type and I dislike the idea people are free to target companies for being “too successful”.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoYou are missing the point. Because of Trump, US allies have to guard more corners than before. It's a serious problem and I think Trump is actually giving Russia/China an unfair advantage. He has already destroyed the Asian partnerships against China that Obama started, he also got out of numerous Western partnerships because it wasn't his signature on it. I would say that the problem is not Europe, it's 100% Trump. Allies won't back him since they can't trust him. Everyone knows he's trying to have as much as personal gain as possible. Even meddling in European affairs,. Eg. Ukraine for the clear sake of money). Every time Trump suggests to help countries handle their affairs, you know he's going for the "pay Trump, get US military assistance" card, it's nuts. The Western alliance since WO II can't survive in it's current form if Trump would get another term, they are all waiting till someone sane comes back. If it doesn't happen, it will become a serious problem :( TLDR; If you wouldn't trust Trump as a business partner, how can other countries trust him. You can't unite/partner with a person like that. Edit: if down vote. Please share something that Trump seems trustworthy without personal gain. I haven't seen any situation during his entire term, trying to redirect US-money to his pockets.
- paulsutter 6y agoRussia’s economy is smaller than Canada, they’re just not terribly relevant globally. China on the other hand will eclipse the US significantly both economically and militarily, reshaping the world.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoI didn't say that Russia is relevant. But they do have a "more deep" ( one-sided) partnership with China to influence Western democracy. They were a lot stronger during the USSR and even then the call for democracy broke it up. Europe has never been closer to Moscow. Important: Without firing even a single gunshot.
- mamon 6y agoRussian economy is weak, agreed, but militarily they are still the only significant threat to US global dominance. China's military is much weaker in comparison.
- paulsutter 6y agoChina is a vastly bigger consideration. If China decides to invade Taiwan the US could lose access to most semiconductors. China’s military is developing rapidly. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-06-18/how-prevent-war-asia https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-0...
- catalogia 6y agoIf Russia were so inclined (I don't think they are and don't see why they would be) they could turn the Island of Taiwan into a pile of gravel on the floor of the China Sea. They have several thousand nuclear warheads with the means to deliver them; more than enough to overwhelm any extant ABM system. For that reason if for no other, I think an American conflict with China is more likely than a conflict with Russia. China still has hundreds of nukes too, which is hundreds too many, but that's many times less than what Russia has. To be clear, a direct war between any three of these countries would be a stupid, horrible idea.
- paulsutter 6y agoThere no motive for Russia to do that. This Russia obsession is bizarre
- redis_mlc 6y agoThis is not well-understood by the general public, but Trump's power as a statesman is his unpredictability. If you don't know what or where he will be next, how do you counter him? Reagan kept the Soviet Union off balance to the point of dissolving it. He's considered one of America's greatest statesman today, but called a clown by the elites at the time. The CCP should be concerned about the same fate if they trifle with Trump. They have given every reason for him to isolate that country.
- NicoJuicy 6y ago> Trump's power as a statesman is his unpredictability. Please don't mistake unpredictability to untrustworthy, ego-centrism and self gain driven behaviour. The guy clearly lacks any social decency that toddlers even know. Reagan did this only as a strategy to USSR, but Trump is clearly influenced by self-gain and ego-centric. He is very predictable, if you use that as a variable. Reagan also supported anti-communism countries and saw the strength in allies. Trump stands alone, every where he goes and doesn't have the brain capacity to lead a country. I think you haven't been paying attention the last months. The US has never been this divided, Trump resembles a con-man/lunatic a lot more. Ps. A divided nation is a weak one.
- NicoJuicy 6y ago> My book doesn't come out until later in the summer, but I'm going to tell you now one thing that you'll find in it: all of the reporting indicates that Barr is involved in the dubious funding of the Trump 2020 campaign by foreign sources. This is all a lot worse than you realize. Didn't surprise me > Trump's power as a statesman is his unpredictability As said earlier > Please don't mistake unpredictability to untrustworthy, ego-centrism and self gain driven behaviour.
- fxtentacle 6y agoMerkel did an excellent job at countering him. Or at least, she earned a lot of respect with voters and other European politicians for it. Basically, she was just presenting it as if she's babysitting a naughty kid. So the way to counter Trump is to make obvious the irrelevance of what he's saying or tweeting at any given moment, because he might change his opinion an hour later.
- Youden 6y ago> I find the fact talks fell through particularly concerning as right now we should all be presenting a united front against China. Honest question: why? Why should Europe unite with the US against China? I don't mean this as a challenge, I'm not trying to argue either way¸ I'm just curious about the reasoning behind your statement.
- boudin 6y agoI'm with you, i don't get this neither.
- noir-york 6y agoBecause China is threatening the global order on which peace and prosperity lies, starting with the freedom of the seas. China is already harassing and sinking fishing vessels and trying to close the South China Sea. It may soon try to enforce an ADIZ over the SC Sea as well. Not great. China is a growing aggressive power with cyber attacks across a multitude of countries and is running, like Russia, disinformation campaigns to undermine democracy. It is in the interest of EU and the US, and indeed many countries, to have a rules-based international order. It is increasingly in the interests of the US as its power is in relative decline.
- fxtentacle 6y agoFor me, it reads like they wanted to discuss the rules for the new order, but then the US suspended talks over what might be called greed.
- noir-york 6y agoI was replying to the point about why EU and the US should form an alliance against China - and the reason being the wider geostrategic context.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoBut he is correct. US withdrew current alliances, so the trust to create new ones is partially gone. There is a reason that the next president will have to restore trust to the US as world leader and will have a tougher job than normal.
- boudin 6y agoThere is already different tax regimes based on business type, it's not something new. I personally think it's a good idea. Our current tax regime has not been thought for this kind of business. Businesses like Google are something totally new, trying to apply the current tax system on it just doesn't work. I find it perfectly logical to create a new tax system that is a better fit, will stop this cat and mouse game of optimisation and finally have those companies contributing to the country they operate into the same way other conpanies does. After, i'm not an expert so I can't say that the system pushed by EU is the best idea or not.
- Mirioron 6y agoBut they already do contribute to those countries. This is simply protectionism plus at work. Squeeze more money out of foreign companies operating locally, because you can. It'll just lead to the world becoming clustered again like before. We're already seeing it happening with the internet - China is already apart from the rest of the world. Russia has been testing the same thing. Europe is essentially trying to isolate itself from the rest of the world by making rules nobody else has. The trend is moving towards separation, which also means that everyone will have to figure out their own technology.
- boudin 6y agoThis is just not true. Google for example routes the profit it makes in France to other countries to avoid paying taxes. That's where the current tax systen doesn't work and a new one is needed.
- Mirioron 6y agoYes, they avoid paying some French corporate taxes. The French have been fully aware of this for decades. Even if they somehow missed everything else, the Lisbon Treaty was rejected by the Irish until they got assurances from the EU that it won't affect taxation. Part of the reason the EU exists in the form it does is due to this taxation.
- fxtentacle 6y agoI don't get your point. The talks are mainly about an additional 5% in taxes on the European profits of Facebook, Google, Apple, Netflix, or Amazon. How does a small tax increase for highly profitable companies get into the way of standing together against China?
- LatteLazy 6y agoI'm just lamenting that we have huge mutual interests and can't get over a 5% tax difference.
- jka 6y agoTo follow on from your mention of China, it seems like TikTok could provide instructive discussion questions here. Does the U.S. and silicon valley want to continue to manoeuvre and lobby to exempt tech companies from tax dues on revenues generated from digital attention and data gathered from users overseas? And if so, does TikTok have to pay tax dues in return for similar revenues generated from U.S. user data? The short-term balance sheet benefit to tech companies from avoiding overseas taxes seems understandable, but the longer-term implications of setting a precedent like that on an international stage seem less clear to me.