4 ms·
In relation to this, I've relatively recently discovered statistical process control (SPC) and the common process behaviour charts (also known as control charts
by kqr 6y ago
In relation to this, I've relatively recently discovered statistical process control (SPC) and the common process behaviour charts (also known as control charts). Donald Wheeler has shown that by taking the detection limits of these charts and turning them into compensation thresholds, they can turn into very powerful process controllers, too! (And maybe even better than the standard PID controller -- without the hunt for parameters.)
Took me a while to find the article, but here it is: http://web.archive.org/web/20160828042756/https://www.qualitydigest.com/inside/operations-column/071116-process-monitor-charts.html http://web.archive.org/web/20160828042756/https://www.qualit...
The general idea is that PID controllers make unnecessary adjustments in response to regular, small, expected fluctuations in the input. These adjustments frequently increase variation beyond what a more tempered approach would have.
- michaericalribo 6y agoIn my experience in manufacturing, SPC control charts are used to assess / analyze / monitor control, ie, quantify the degree to which a process is in control...but not often to actually manage / maintain that control. As another commenter alluded to, the vast majority of control systems are managed by PID loops, and SPC is a complement to those systems, not a replacement per se.
- kqr 6y agoThat is indeed how things are traditionally done. I (along with Wheeler) am suggesting that division does not necessarily have to exist, and the control charts themselves can serve as useful feedback mechanisms. In many cases they may even be more effective than a PID controller, with zero tuning required. As Wheeler notes in his article, PID controllers are based on the assumption that calibration/adjustments are free. As any practitioner of SPC knows, adjustments are never actually free in the face of natural variation in the process.