3 ms·
There was a recent discussion on HN that branches into this idea about the importance of UX. I agree with you, with a twist. What you want is that the happy pa
by tialaramex 6y ago
There was a recent discussion on HN that branches into this idea about the importance of UX. I agree with you, with a twist.
What you want is that the happy path for security is zero hassle, but the unhappy paths should also drop dead with zero hassle.
This is the UX I really like for WebAuthn / U2F.
All the interactions on the happy path are very smooth. Need a second factor, tap, go. Almost frictionless. On my phone for example you tap the same fingerprint sensor that would ordinarily unlock the phone. Short of not having a second factor at all it couldn't be smoother.
But if this is actually a phishing site or you're a crook who doesn't have the hardware token, it just doesn't work. Still low friction in a sense, but low friction failure. There is no way forward, no override, no "I'm sure", nothing - it just won't work.
- kohtatsu 6y agoAside: it'd be cool to have a tool that could find the discussion you referenced in your first sentence. I wonder if Algolia is working on something in the space of topical search.
- nine_k 6y agoAnother unhappy path is very difficult. Your phone got stolen or smashed. Your 2FA is just not available. Welcome to the sea of hassle proving your identity. But a little bit of hassle beforehand, in the form of printing one-time codes and storing them even in your wallet would help dramatically.
- monadic2 6y agoProving identity is inherently not something you can solve technically, particularly without support from government.
- DarthGhandi 6y agoI have Authy on my phone, a laptop and a desktop. There's also a backup stored away with all my other encrypted secrets. I'm far more likely to lose my keys or wallet than 2fa.
- davchana 6y agoKeep the 2fa code sequences safe in a separate keepass or any password database; & you can move 2fa anytime. Even Google updated its Auth app to export all keys.
- LadyCailin 6y agoWait, when? For iPhone? I just checked and don’t see it.
- davchana 6y agoOh Sorry, I should had been clear; I use Android.
- ddrt 6y agoJust has to abandon a Trello account because of this. They state if you lose your device for TFA you have just lost your account. Okay, bank level security for a PM tool...