7 ms·
Making password entry difficult is like attempting weight loss by eating bland food. It's not the flavour that makes you fat. Nonetheless, there's this percep
by jiggawatts 6y ago
Making password entry difficult is like attempting weight loss by eating bland food.
It's not the flavour that makes you fat.
Nonetheless, there's this perception that something delicious can't be good for a diet. People have this notion that to lose weight, there must be penance. An element of punishing oneself for past transgressions seems essential.
Security people have the same mindset. Security must be a hassle. It must be in your face. It has to be onerous. A challenge. A hurdle to get past.
I've tried, over and over, to explain to my customers that often the slickest, most hassle-free approach is the most secure. But this almost never sells.
Meanwhile, I see vendor after vendor successfully selling products that exist only to irritate users.
- buu700 6y agoSounds like Calvinism: https://redd.it/232qqq https://redd.it/232qqq
- tialaramex 6y agoThere was a recent discussion on HN that branches into this idea about the importance of UX. I agree with you, with a twist. What you want is that the happy path for security is zero hassle, but the unhappy paths should also drop dead with zero hassle. This is the UX I really like for WebAuthn / U2F. All the interactions on the happy path are very smooth. Need a second factor, tap, go. Almost frictionless. On my phone for example you tap the same fingerprint sensor that would ordinarily unlock the phone. Short of not having a second factor at all it couldn't be smoother. But if this is actually a phishing site or you're a crook who doesn't have the hardware token, it just doesn't work. Still low friction in a sense, but low friction failure. There is no way forward, no override, no "I'm sure", nothing - it just won't work.
- kohtatsu 6y agoAside: it'd be cool to have a tool that could find the discussion you referenced in your first sentence. I wonder if Algolia is working on something in the space of topical search.
- nine_k 6y agoAnother unhappy path is very difficult. Your phone got stolen or smashed. Your 2FA is just not available. Welcome to the sea of hassle proving your identity. But a little bit of hassle beforehand, in the form of printing one-time codes and storing them even in your wallet would help dramatically.
- monadic2 6y agoProving identity is inherently not something you can solve technically, particularly without support from government.
- DarthGhandi 6y agoI have Authy on my phone, a laptop and a desktop. There's also a backup stored away with all my other encrypted secrets. I'm far more likely to lose my keys or wallet than 2fa.
- davchana 6y agoKeep the 2fa code sequences safe in a separate keepass or any password database; & you can move 2fa anytime. Even Google updated its Auth app to export all keys.
- LadyCailin 6y agoWait, when? For iPhone? I just checked and don’t see it.
- davchana 6y agoOh Sorry, I should had been clear; I use Android.
- ddrt 6y agoJust has to abandon a Trello account because of this. They state if you lose your device for TFA you have just lost your account. Okay, bank level security for a PM tool...
- duxup 6y agoYears ago I believe it was Microsoft that found via some method that the higher the rate of required password changes + difficult password rules...the more likely they found larger / more obvious security issues.
- viraptor 6y ago> Security people have the same mindset. Security must be a hassle. It's an unhelpful generalisation. There are many jobs that could come under "Security people" and they work under different requirements. Many will agree with you on the hassle-free experience. There's no need for the us-vs-them.
- monadic2 6y agoSure, but this isn’t engaging in the above poster in good faith.
- viraptor 6y agoI don't have the data on sales, so I can't comment on that. Without seeing the marketing, it's hard to tell why OP's solutions are not chosen. (I don't expect it to be as easy as "it's not difficult enough")
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- monadic2 6y agoYea, but you could have chosen not to comment at all without detracting from the conversation. If folks around here don’t know what security folks do you have much, much, much larger concerns. Why not engage in good faith? If you can’t do that why comment at all?
- viraptor 6y agoBecause "security people want to make your life harder" is as meme that needs to die. People actually believe that and if we don't call out that it's wrong and harmful, it will continue to be repeated.
- monadic2 6y agoWell, it’s also true in many senses. You’re not going to get much of anywhere without recognizing that.
- dheera 6y agoapt-get install xclip xdotool, then put this in ~/bin/paste #!/bin/bash sleep 2.0 xdotool type "$(xclip -o -selection clipboard)" If a website prevents you from pasting stuff just type "paste" and then click the field and wait 2 seconds.
- virgilp 6y agoYou underestimate the ingenuity of some sites. Take this one: https://systemschimb.telekombanking.ro/login https://systemschimb.telekombanking.ro/login - enter a random user id, and behold the password input field: - all characters are separated (not one password field, but 10-15 ones) - some characters are randomly grayed-out (you're not supposed to enter all the characters of your password)
- namdnay 6y agoI like the system where you only enter parts of your password. It means that even with a key logger or hacked site, you’d need several logins to be able to scrape the password
- iso1631 6y agoThat means the password is held in plain text or reversable encryption. They should only have a salted hash of your password. Using a shared secret in addition to a salted password is probably acceptable, although how much extra security it gives is debatable.
- ithkuil 6y agoPossibly or they could store N salted hashes, one for one of the N permutations of a mask over the password character positions. This basically splits the end user password into N passwords with smaller entropy but this can be mitigated by requiring high entropy for the original password.
- 6y ago
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThe security industry is a high paid specialization in an already highly paid industry, and it attracts an enormous number of complete charlatans. It’s incredibly easy to be a security charlatan, most of the people you work with won’t understand what it is you’re supposed to be doing, so they won’t know any better when you tell them to do literally anything at all. You can create an endless stream of busywork for yourself, by making an endless stream of nonsensical risk assessments, and anytime you don’t know what to do you can just say no. Anytime you’re questioned you can just say it’s best practice, and chances are some authority at some point in time said it was. Other risk-related fields typically have at least some of the same issues. Risk avoidance is always a no-effort strategy, and the industry is full of people who rely on it entirely, because they don’t have the skills to implement actual mitigation strategies.
- ownagefool 6y agoYeah I'm a contractor that basically works on modernising the SDLC and target platforms. Nothing fancy. Pretty much in all circumstances the outright adversary is Enterprise Architecture or Security using governance and security to push complex standards that don't work and result making changes harder and unpatched systems. Some of them are receptive if you communicate the issues in terms of risk, but many most in my experience are only receptive if put it in writing and you copy in their boss.
- m463 6y agoI think there should be a special, maybe one-time-use password paste buffer It can use a different key combo, or automatically be chosen when pasting into secure fields
- NewEntryHN 6y agoAllowing password pasting has been a standard recommendation from the security community for years.
- bad_user 6y agoThere's actually a lot of scientific evidence that hyperpalatable food contributes significantly to obesity and that bland food does lead to an instantaneous drop in appetite. It's not about any penance, you got it all wrong, this is about our brain going haywire for food high in calories.
- SaltyBackendGuy 6y agoThis reminds me of a Jack LaLanne quote. "If it tastes good, spit it out!" It's not an absolute rule obviously. Generally products masquerading as health food that taste "good" are loaded with sugar.
- derefr 6y ago> Making password entry difficult is like attempting weight loss by eating bland food. It's not the flavour that makes you fat. Big side-tangent, but amusingly enough, one modern view on the etiology of metabolic syndrome is that your brain tracks satiety for different nutrient classes separately; so foods that are "tasty" in the sense of containing many different nutrient-signals (sugar, salt, fat, acid, etc.) take larger quantities of food to signal fullness (something something liver metabolism is a rate-limited queue); so if you start off hungry and eat such foods until you "feel full", you will have eaten more of them than you "should have", to the point of eventually doing excitotoxic things to your leptin receptors, inducing leptin resistance and making you feel hungry more often. Which is to say, it's not flavor that makes you fat, but rather flavors, plural. ;) The advice of the scientists who subscribe to this hypothesis is that you don't have to eat bland food; you just have to eat monotonous food (food only containing one primary nutrient-signal), and you'll feel full with less of it. When you sit down for a meal, eat all meat, or all bread, or all green leafy vegetables. Balance your diet by having something different each meal, not by combining foods in a single meal. Avoid foods that are themselves "combinations", like pizza. Avoid adding a secondary nutrient-signal to something to "amp up" the taste, like adding sugary+oily dressing to a mineral-y salad. Just choose foods that already taste good to you without any "amping up", and eat those, by themseleves. This is, after all, the real "paleo diet": when animals kill prey, they eat just meat for a meal. When they find fruit, they eat just fruit for a meal. They don't bring them together to eat them all at once. (Whatever you think of the hypothesis, studies have been done which confirm the advice: eating monotonously per meal, makes you feel full after less food intake. You hit a wall with a kind of "tired/bored of eating this, disgusted by the idea of eating more" feeling, which makes you lose the rest of your appetite. That's your body's nutrient-satiety mechanism kicking in correctly.)
- sukilot 6y agoBread (a refined food) will make you sick and fat before it makes you full. Maybe a very whole wheat would work OK in this system. Fruits are also a highly refined food (genetically engineering/ artificially selected for extremely high sugar.)
- 6y ago