6 ms·
I'm surprised how one sided the conversation is here. This isn't "mob rule," this is the reasoned opinions of skilled scientists saying that Hsu's political op
by epistasis 6y ago
I'm surprised how one sided the conversation is here.
This isn't "mob rule," this is the reasoned opinions of skilled scientists saying that Hsu's political opinions are 1) not backed by the science, and 2) establish strong ground to believe that he will not use his position of power fairly.
People have a right to be judged fairly in their careers, and those in leadership positions should not be unfairly prejudiced by bad beliefs. It might be fine for a tenured physics professor, but it's not OK for somebody making hiring and promotion decisions.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- natalyarostova 6y ago1. The idea that someone’s political views are not backed by science is a pretty bold claim. Who decides what political views are acceptably scientific? 2. Strong grounds? Is it possible to quickly present strong grounds in a twitter thread? Up until today he has done well in his job, and no one seemed to have a problem with him for 8 years. His boss or colleagues. Now, suddenly, we have deep concerns about how he hires people... why exactly? Because his political views aren’t scientific? This is tribal mob rule under the guise of a sophisticated intellectual rationalization.
- skosuri 6y agoUp until today? You have no idea what you are talking about. I have colleagues at the university that have been trying to have him removed for years; several have left in part because of him.
- threatofrain 6y agoCan you elaborate on the details that your colleagues conveyed to you?
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoThat doesn’t mean much, other than they are probably part of the problem mob.
- blondin 6y agothings are different nowadays, that's all. a few things have happened -- pandemic, injustices, etc... -- that is making people take stand and speak up. i don't know much about the situation but your comment about people not calling out others for years doesn't mean things worth calling out someone for didn't happen...
- rallison 6y agoIt's also possible many of these colleagues had concerns, but weren't previously airing them publicly. Just searching academics I follow, the one thread that popped up from a year ago was this https://twitter.com/Graham_Coop/status/1132105378668326912 https://twitter.com/Graham_Coop/status/1132105378668326912 In which it seems many of these criticisms were well known at least a year ago. I hadn't previously followed this, but it seems like this was probably a case of the dam finally bursting.
- skosuri 6y agoThis is definitely the case of the dam finally bursting. For example, a famous geneticist who left said this: https://twitter.com/ctitusbrown/status/1271082397656735746?s=21 https://twitter.com/ctitusbrown/status/1271082397656735746?s... I also have friends on the faculty. This is the dam bursting and should have happened a long time ago.
- amznthrowaway5 6y agoIs there an actual example of what was said? Otherwise this is just another empty accusation.
- nyczomg 6y agoThe person with #shutdownSTEM in their twitter profile pic?
- epistasis 6y ago#shutdownSTEM was a wildly popular strike day recently, I think they can be excused from not changing it back yet.
- rlanday 6y agoOn what planet should “shutdown STEM” be a reasonable position to hold in the middle of a global pandemic where hundreds of thousands or millions of people’s lives depend on quality STEM research being done in a timely manner?
- giantDinosaur 6y agoI have no idea about Hsu's research, but if you think that 'skilled scientists' in academia are not often as ruthlessly political as anyone else then gosh, do I have some research bridge projects to sell to you.
- oliverx0 6y agoVideos from years ago are being taken out of context in order to make him seem racist and sexist. It is ridiculous. We have gotten to the point where no matter what you say or do, there is always a victim ready to complain. And now it’s even worse, if science doesn’t back our political beliefs or feelings , let’s just shut down science!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- esyir 6y agoThese are people who are not arguing on any scientific basis, but rather against any evidence that we've collected and against further collection that might prove for or otherwise. Those in leadership positions for a scientific position should not forge their beliefs on the political zeitgeist, but on sound methods and the data stemming thereof.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- monkeypizza 6y agoThere is a petition in support of him which also has some big names. That should be sufficient to warrant further investigation rather than immediately forcing him to resign. https://sites.google.com/view/petition-letter-stephen-hsu/home?authuser=0 https://sites.google.com/view/petition-letter-stephen-hsu/ho... Signatures include: Scott Aaronson Scott Alexander Sam Altman Linda S. Gottfredson, Professor Emeritus, University of Delaware, Past President of the International Society for Intelligence Research Jonathan Haidt, Professor, New York University Stern School of Business, USA Geoffrey Miller Steven Pinker, Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology, Harvard University Robert Plomin, Professor, Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience, King’s College London
- throwaway4666 6y agoNotice how none of them are actual geneticists. Prominent figures in the actual genetics community (e.g. Graham Coop or Ewan Birney) have dismissed most of his stuff.
- threatofrain 6y agoIn terms of a battle of signatures, I'm not sure how meaningful that is, given that there's a <huge> list of reputationally prestigious names backing Stephen Hsu. https://sites.google.com/view/petition-letter-stephen-hsu/home https://sites.google.com/view/petition-letter-stephen-hsu/ho... Here's a letter from a professor at the university: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1bNPOlcphtKfqoDThfdsYTL65t2rs7pRzVhJe2xPlM7Y/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/1bNPOlcphtKfqoDThfdsYTL65...