3 ms·
> EMP attacks... For an EMP attack to be effective on modern electronics, you need to blow up a multimegaton nuclear bomb close enough for it to take out whome
by baybal2 6y ago
> EMP attacks...
For an EMP attack to be effective on modern electronics, you need to blow up a multimegaton nuclear bomb close enough for it to take out whomever is using that piece of electronics...
- eppp 6y agoAn EMP attack would destroy the power grid, your modern electronics may survive but without anything to power them.
- iso1210 6y agoIf it's just the grid that's gone, generators are available - hell I have a mobile one sat in my driveway.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoThat doesn't help you if you can't get the fuel for it. Most industrial facilities can't just run on generators. Data centers can in theory, but I somehow doubt those diesel delivery contracts would be fulfilled, and good luck calling around asking for alternatives when the phone networks go down.
- 01100011 6y agoSource? I don't think the MOV in your power strip, or the typical ESD protections are going to save you. There are also conventional EMPs to worry about. Also, you could probably just take out key points with carbon dust bombs like we did in Iraq War #1.
- aaron695 6y agoPretty much, but there's no point explaining it to people. Not believing in nuclear weapons destroying everything with god like power is right wing. It doesn't even make sense, EMP's are nukes, someone just stared nuking you and you're worried about the EMP.
- nabla9 6y ago>It doesn't even make sense, It starts to make sense once you know how nuclear EMP attack works. The detonation would happen high in the space (400 km) and would not cause direct effects or radiation on the earth. EMP pulse in a continent wide nuclear EMP attack is not coming from the nuclear detonation directly. It comes from synchrotron radiation when free electrons in upper atmosphere interact with earths magnetic field
- jnurmine 6y agoAn EMP attack is of course a plausible and realistic, but a rather costly, dare I say, somewhat of a science fiction formulation of an attack. Any attacker is unlikely to choose the most costliest and fanciful form of attack. Wouldn't it be much more cost efficient to send multiple groups of people to drive around and snipe or blow up equipment of transformer stations at key places?
- T-A 6y agoNo. Optimal altitude for an EMP attack is actually a few hundred kilometers up. The "base case" usually considered in these scenarios is a nuke going off about 400 km over Omaha. At that altitude, the ionosphere helps you create a "slow" E3 pulse which induces a field in the tens of volts per kilometer at ground level; and since you can see most of the continental US, you have plenty of kilometers to work with.
- baybal2 6y agoThat long wave EMP was only a threat to early unprotected powerlines, not electronics. What is a threat to electronics are VHF pulses from initial xray burst from the bomb.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoWhat's the range of that pulse, and how does it relate to the field strength map seen on Wikipedia (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:EMP_mechanism.png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:EMP_mechanism.png)? Naively, this map makes me think that a single such EMP means enough electronics break that every major power plant or industrial plant is down and not recoverable for weeks.
- T-A 6y agoThe protection is provided by Digital Protection Relays (DPRs) which can be fried by the E1 pulse; then the E3 pulse arrives.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agohttps://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:EMP_mechanism.png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:EMP_mechanism.png shows a field strength of 25 kV/m for most of the US. My understanding could be wrong, but wouldn't this mean exposing a 1 cm wide component (and/or components that have one cm long traces attached) to at least 250 V? Wouldn't this be expected to destroy not every single component, but enough components to make enough hardware inoperable to collapse all industrial and power generation capabilities? (If you destroy 10% of ICs on only 10% of control boards in a power plant or factory, I'd assume that plant goes down hard and isn't coming up any time soon.)