4 ms·
When is it finally going to trickle into common sense that needlessly hooking an embedded device up to the Internet is a bad idea? An ethernet jack is an attrac
by mindslight 6y ago
When is it finally going to trickle into common sense that needlessly hooking an embedded device up to the Internet is a bad idea? An ethernet jack is an attractive nuisance, not a feature.
- jentist_retol 6y ago>needlessly hooking an embedded device up to the Internet is a bad idea It's a video player, some of the common uses of a device like this would be Netflix, Amazon Prime, Youtube, and DIAL.
- Bud 6y agoUsing a 5-year-old Blu-ray player as a streaming device is incredibly stupid, though. Just like "smart" TVs are universally incredibly stupid.
- aeyes 6y agoWhy is it stupid if it works? Is my 6 year old smartphone stupid to use on the internet? Is my 20 year old keyboard which works excellent obsolete? Is my 25 year old microwave a hazard? Money doesn't grow on trees, why would I stop using a device only because it is 5 years old?
- adamhearn 6y agoThat’s obviously a straw man argument. It’s the same reason you don’t connect a windows XP embedded system to the internet. The embedded system may function excellently at its task, but most hardware manufacturers are not up to the task to providing long term support.
- dehrmann 6y agoHaving one device to rule them all is the dream.
- mike_d 6y agoIt does play Netflix and other streaming services, which is hard to do without connectivity.
- mindslight 6y agoIt's better to separate devices. Use a Bluray player just to play Blurays, and use a TV just to display video. To play network content use a RPi+Kodi or at least a dedicated mass-market streaming device that will be highly incentivized to maintain first-class support rather than its firmware being an afterthought.
- mike_d 6y agoDon't tell me that, tell the people who bought the thing.
- mindslight 6y agoThat's kind of my point though, word needs to get around that most "smart" features are actually anti-features only there for marketing. I'm even getting some downvotes here, as if this outcome was inevitable. It's not inevitable with a bit of forethought. People as a group need to develop the wisdom to know best practices when buying A/V gear, especially expensive A/V gear, rather than getting suckered into nonsensical anti-features that manufacturers are pushing. I've got a decade+ old Blu-ray player with an ethernet jack. A network switch is a standard part of my entertainment center. Every time I've moved things around, I've resisted the call to add an extra cable and find out what network services are available. With my network setup I can easily block it from having Internet access, and it's still a hard no. There is just no upside, and a huge downside of it being more likely to break, and then having to buy a new player for the rare times I want to play a legacy disc. My receiver is hooked to the network, but with no Internet access. It has an embedded webserver that can control it. But now that it's out of the warranty period I would never let it update itself, as that's a good way for a manufacturer to break a device with no recourse. Firmware used to be shipped with no updates, and that worked well. Weighing the chance of it being bricked from a manufacturer's update versus an attacker with vulnerability also getting past my router, the latter seems much less likely. I know I'm bailing out a leaking boat here (cheap embedded cell modems are around the corner, which will necessitate doing surgery). But the market has to catch on some time...
- stallmanite 6y agoWon’t it be great if/when device manufacturers have cheap cellular modems to sprinkle in products? Selling cute Faraday cages on Etsy here I come.
- m463 6y agoI just wonder when they're going to make arrangements with isps to automatically connect to xfinitiwifi or attwifi for telemetry. Telsa kind of does this with their cars. If you drive near a tesla service center your car will automatically connect to the the tesla wifi. You cannot disable this (although you can turn off wifi one-time until the next time the car is turned on, and maybe that works)
- exikyut 6y agoIIRC Blu-Ray players needed Internet connections to validate discs... I think?
- Bud 6y agoNope! Noooope nope nope nope nope.
- jdofaz 6y agoNo, and some early models didn't even have network connections.
- ipython 6y agoNo internet needed for the Blu-ray Discs I’m aware of. I have my Sony player disconnected and have no problem playing movies.
- m463 6y agoNot that some movies don't have an unskippable "please update your player firmware for the best viewing experience(tm)"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- syntheticnature 6y agoNot validate discs, but one of the issues is Blu-ray discs have Java apps on them, and some of the Java apps on the discs are, uh... buggy. So pushing out updates to compensate for said discs is often necessary.
- syntheticnature 6y agoPart of the problem here is the very nature of Blu-ray, where you have Java running on a disc and updates needed for that.
- lookdangerous 6y agoBlu-ray has java?
- shakna 6y agoAll Bluray video players are required to support BD-J to pass. [0] And BD-J is Java (Supposedly to make better bonus content). Support for BD-J in hardware has been required since '07. Things like internet access are part of the spec. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/BD-J https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/BD-J
- syntheticnature 6y agoI'll add that most discs are authored as BD-J.
- Volundr 6y agoI does indeed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BD-J https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BD-J That's one of the big complications with ripping Blu-Ray discs. Even once you've broken the copy protection it's a guessing game what's played when. Also why VLC still doesn't have menu support.
- distances 6y agoWhy would it need updates? I've never updated my Blu-ray player.
- syntheticnature 6y agoTo support new media formats, fix bugs in discs' Java implementations (or their own JVM), etc.