3 ms·
So you increase the price of your app by 30 to make up for Apple's cut%. It's called business. It happens all the time in every single industry. If a busines
by reaperducer 6y ago
So you increase the price of your app by 30 to make up for Apple's cut%. It's called business. It happens all the time in every single industry.
If a business' property taxes go up, that cost is passed on to its customers. Why do people think that because something is on a phone that it should be any different?
- twicetwice 6y agoThat's also not allowed. I think Hey would be fine charging $142 a year for a subscription in their app, with a little note below saying "you can get this for $99 on our website, the difference is Apple's cut." In fact, if I understand it correctly, the price in-app has to be the same as the price anywhere else. They're literally not allowed to do what you're suggesting and pass the cost of Apple's fee on to consumers.
- reaperducer 6y agoYou just Charge everyone the same and don't tell the customers that they're paying Apple's cut. Just like Hey doesn't tell its customers what percentage of its fee goes to the water company, or the electric company, or to company travel. This is how business works.
- twicetwice 6y agoSo Hey should boost their prices everywhere, even on their own site, to $142, so that they can make up Apple's cut? Which is what Apple demands. I don't think that's reasonable. I think that you and I are broadly in agreement. If Hey were allowed to charge $142 in their iPhone app, and $99 on their website, I'd think that was much less ridiculous than the situation as it stands today.
- acituan 6y ago> It's called business. It happens all the time in every single industry And we call those situations market failures. Besides, in this case the market failure is due to a monopolistic mechanism, which doesn't happen "all the time in every industry". If we are going to do markets, let's do it properly. Increasing price %30 causes a corresponding decrease in the demand, and in aggregate this can cause a decrease in the total profit. The fact that the developer is forced to set a new price point this way is a source of inefficiency for the entire app economy. Besides forced price increase is not the only harm done by the monopoly of the App Store. As this website exemplifies, it has monopoly over ontological decisions (whether a certain type of app can exist or not), over design decisions (signups, in app purchases etc) and whatnot. These are further points of inefficiency or outright failure. Apple might or might not be doing a good enough job making the best out of these decisions, but the bottom line is we don't have a choice of another player emerging with potentially better choice-making and therefore a better app store.
- pdonis 6y ago> we call those situations market failures. To the extent that this situation is a "market failure", it's not one that's fixable except by users changing their preferences. > in this case the market failure is due to a monopolistic mechanism Apple only has a "monopoly" on their own app store because they built it. Users are not being forced to use iPhones; they choose to because they believe iPhones give them better value overall than the alternatives. That's called free market competition, not monopoly.
- acituan 6y ago> it's not one that's fixable except by users changing their preferences. By definition market failures can't be fixed by market dynamics. That is why state does tons of interventions/regulations to make it work. > That's called free market competition, not monopoly. No. Vertical integration means there is no free market at the integration point to begin with, which integration of a software application store with a physical phone is. We are talking about a $50bil/year market that is not free.
- pdonis 6y ago> By definition market failures can't be fixed by market dynamics. That's why I put "market failure" in quotes. If you think anything fixable by users changing their preferences isn't a "market failure" by your definition, fine, then the Apple situation is not a market failure by your definition. > That is why state does tons of interventions/regulations to make it work. No, the government does tons of interventions/regulations to favor particular market players, under the guise of "fixing market failures". In almost all cases, these interventions/regulations actually make things worse overall, but of course they make things better for the particular market players that were favored. > Vertical integration means there is no free market at the integration point to begin with Throwing around buzzwords proves nothing. Apple created the iPhone and its app store. It can do whatever it wants with them because it owns them. It has the market share it has because users have freely chosen to use its products instead of those of its competitors. That's the essence of a free market. The fact that you don't like doesn't make it not a free market.