3 ms·
I think the GP's post should be read as "He's not a romantic hero. He was just stupid, and he died because of it." That is, it's not addressed to McCandless him
by jfengel 6y ago
I think the GP's post should be read as "He's not a romantic hero. He was just stupid, and he died because of it." That is, it's not addressed to McCandless himself, but to Jon Krakauer for painting him as having some kind of life lesson to teach. And to fans of the book who romanticize it.
McCandless didn't ask for any of that, and I concur that he was welcome to commit suicide his own way. But it was suicidal, and everybody knew it, so it is necessary to add the cautionary tale whenever he's brought up. It would be best, as you say, if we all just ignored him.
- sinker 6y agoThe romanticization is in the portrayal not the reality of it. Without Jon Krakauer, no one would know McCandless' name or story, because McCandless wasn't out to glorify himself or bring fame, money, etc. to himself. He really was just some kid looking to escape what he saw as a life of oppression. He wasn't asking to be looked upon as an model, and he most likely would have acted differently if he knew his life would be scrutinized by strangers decades after.
- bilegeek 6y agoI agree that it would be best to ignore him, because I concur that the story of McCandless is seen too often as romantic instead of cautionary. However, it didn't seem to me that Krakauer painted McCandless as too rosy. He seemed to integrate both the accomplishments and the stupidity that led to those accomplishments pretty well. He seemed to show McCandless as a very capable and nice person, who in stubborn hubris abandoned and hurt his family and ended up dying. Not holding him up as a flawed hero like many fans of the book, and not sneering at him like many (rightly) do. A self-condemning tragedy, not an exultation or condemnation.