6 ms·
Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families spend their money?
- CurtHagenlocher 6y agoFascinating research! I wonder where it was conducted and whether or not the result would vary between countries. I think in the United States there's a pervasive belief that the wealthy deserve their wealth because they earned it through hard work and/or personal merit. The counterpoint to this must be that poor people are undeserving because they don't work hard or because they lack merit.
- zo1 6y agoOdd, I've seen a pervasive belief that the wealthy did not gain their wealth through hard work/merit and either somehow stole it or inherited it. And I've also seen pervasive beliefs that the poor are only poor because of things such as: lack of education, evil capitalism, lack of opportunities, hunger, systemic issues, racism, etc. Perhaps each group has some level of both and we shouldn't generalize to entire strata and population groups too much. Instead maybe we shouldn't be so quick to measure outcomes and just fix the problems. Instead we're using outcomes as a (I would argue) poor measure of how well we're fixing the problems we should be agreeing are problems on their own worth fixing. That's where a lot of the argument/debate gets lost, quibbling over correlations instead of just solving bad things.
- sjtindell 6y agoMainstream opinions are shifting more towards the narratives you’re describing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alistairSH 6y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted for sharing an opinion/observaton, but in my experience, opinions are changing slowly from the parent comment to your comment. Obviously, all of the following is a generalization, but I think it's fairly accurate... There is/was a pervasive belief in the US that the wealthy pulled themselves up by their bootstraps and that they provide more value to the world. 1980s Wall St boom, Yuppies, etc. Up until perhaps 30 years ago, this might have even been accurate. It's only recently that economic mobility in the US has started to noticeably lag behind similar western nations. However, starting with Gen-X and perhaps accelerating with Millenials, public opinion has started to shift. Three decades of failed Neo-liberal government (and GOP and Democratic leadership both largely fall into that category) has left the average person disgruntled and seemingly unable to find any bootstraps at all.
- gshdg 6y agoI think it depends on how wealthy we’re talking about. People who make 6 figures are assumed to have earned it. People who make 8 figures or have 9 figures of wealth are assumed to have inherited it or worked the system without having put in the effort to earn it.
- MintelIE 6y agoNobody would mind how they spent it if it was actually theirs to start with. When you give out free money it becomes everybody's business.
- JaimeThompson 6y agoSpaceX gets lots of money from governments as incentives to expand their production facilities so should all their spending be subject to such scrutiny as well?
- daenz 6y agoYes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brown 6y agoYes?
- zo1 6y agoMaybe they just shouldn't be given free money from government without anything in return.
- xupybd 6y agoFar more so. Government corporate welfare is a terrible idea. Yes the government can and should contract to private businesses but at that point they are the customer and there should be huge amounts of scrutiny on how the money is spent. This should also apply to infrastructure if the government is spending too much on a contract but keeps using that business that is clear and present corruption.
- WalterBright 6y agoIf SpaceX gets a contract to provide X in exchange for $Y from the government, and delivers on their contract, the government has no further business scrutinizing SpaceX's spending. If the government gives SpaceX money with no strings attached, just a vague "expand production facilities", then the government would be right to be upset if SpaceX spent it on keggers.
- radicalbyte 6y agoKeep the poor focussed on each other and they won't see the excesses of the rich. It's why the Tories are so focussed on people who claim benefits: if the public are angry about "scroungers" grabbing the crumbs then they won't be paying attention to the hands which are taking all of the cookies out of the jar.
- wildrhythms 6y agoWorking class people have been ingrained with a crabs-in-a-bucket mentality. Meanwhile, we've allowed 1% of Americans to sit on over 50% of the wealth, and people still ask "but how do we pay for it?" when it comes to actually improving the material conditions of the working class.
- jonfw 6y agoIt seems like you're using one metric to shit on the 1% (net worth) while you're using a different metric to discuss impact on the middle class (material conditions) It's important to be consistent here. The 1% may have a lot of the wealth financially, but they don't have anywhere near 50% of the things that matter to Americans. Homes, cars, food, healthcare, etc. is much much more evenly distributed. 'Material conditions' and wealth aren't directly correlated.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoThe point is that would be more and better houses and other things that would benefit more people if some of that net worth were redirected toward building them.
- jonfw 6y agoWe are already getting more and better houses, and at a very rapid pace, under our current economic climate (the one where the 1% has so much of the financial wealth) - https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/new-us-homes-today-are-1000-square-feet-larger-than-in-1973-and-living-space-per-person-has-nearly-doubled/ https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/new-us-homes-today-are-1000-s...
- WalterBright 6y agoA couple reasons come to mind: 1. Whoever pays the bill calls the tune. Meaning if someone wants charity, the giver is going to want to know that the recipient is going to spend it wisely, otherwise would be disinclined to give. 2. People in financial difficulty often consult with a planner to see how they can adjust their spending habits so they are more effective.
- elliekelly 6y agoSeveral scenarios described in the article made no mention of someone else paying the bill or providing funding to the person but the results showed the same scrutiny of their purchasing decisions. And I would have thought this goes without saying but a person generally cannot financial-plan their way out of poverty. Poverty isn’t from lacking financial discipline it’s from lacking financial resources and opportunities. It’s impossible to fund a savings account when your income is just barely enough to keep a roof over your head and food on the table.
- zozbot234 6y ago> Poverty isn’t from lacking financial discipline it’s from lacking financial resources and opportunities. ¿Por qué no los dos?
- cgriswald 6y agoFor starters, discipline is about choices and if you have no choices you can’t have discipline. Secondly, in the rare instance you do have a chance to make a choice, you lack both the requisite knowledge and the practical skill. Thirdly, in that rare instance that your physical needs are met, you’re still struggling with a lot of unmet mental needs which either make rational financial discipline difficult or in which the rational choice is to “splurge” to maintain your sanity. Fourth, even if you do make the “correct” choice and say, open a savings account, there’s a fair chance you’ll be raiding that savings account the following month to meet your needs anyway, which not only defeats the purpose but makes financial discipline seem pointless; which it would be.
- 6y ago
- pickdenis 6y ago> And when deciding whether to gift a low-income individual either a $100 grocery voucher or a $200 electronics voucher, only a quarter of participants went for the latter, even though it was worth twice as much. More than half said they would give a high-income individual the electronics voucher, however. “Paradoxically, the result was that participants effectively allocated more money to higher-income people than lower-income people,” the authors note. This is a ridiculous contrived situation. $100 for a lower Maslow-level need or $200 for a higher level need? Why was giving $200 for the lower level need not an option? Maybe I'm missing the point here, but all this proves is that people are aware of Maslow's hierarchy. When you create such strange scenarios, expect strange results. If a person struggling financially is servicing their higher level needs before their lower level needs are met, they deserve scrutiny.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoIt just says the person has a low paying job, it doesn't say they are struggling financially. People know that food is more important, but if you already have enough for food the $100 grocery gift card just becomes a $100 you can spend on "luxury" goods.
- ardit33 6y agoInteresting article. If a country has some kind is social net for low income folks, (most developed countries do, even the US) then the assumption is that the whole society is helping them, and some of your own money is going towards that help via taxes. If a low income person is spending money on things that are not necessities it might feel like their are miss-using the help they get. I think it is almost a tribal/low level human reaction to that. It might make you feel like you are being taken advantage of, and the feeling of unfairness might come out. It that person is low income, but not receiving any support, then another feeling is just sheer jealousy or inadequacy, where this person is dressing better/and has better phone/car than you.
- rizzom5000 6y agoI've heard that this is one of the reasons that obesity is a much bigger problem in the US vs. Europe. The way it read was that European countries have much more homogenized cultures where people are more openly shamed for having an unhealthy lifestyle; due to the fact that the healthcare costs are more visibly distributed to everyone.
- nicbou 6y agoWhat would that say about obesity in Canada? In my limited experience, there is no such shaming going on in Germany. Perhaps people move around more, and drive around less? Perhaps it's related to how food is regulated?
- dogma1138 6y agoThe U.K. has one of the most socialized healthcare systems in the world if not the most and it has a huge obesity problem.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoThereis probably some of this butthis would not be the first thing which comes to mind. At least in France, children are faced with healthy food since primary shool. Sodas distributors are forbidden up to and including high school. They are also given the opportuinty to do sports (my children, 14 and 16, routinely go to play football with their friends in an open field - in the subrbs of Paris) Then there is not much tolerence for fat people. Surprisingly, this equals fatness to having a disease. The company restaurants are very affordable and usually healthy. One of the things which also help a lot that it is traditional to drink water at meals. This is also what you get at school (and nothing else), and at the office (some would buy something else but this is unusual.
- foogazi 6y ago> Now a new study in PNAS provides some clues as to the origins of this bias. Across a series of 11 studies involving more than 4,000 participants, Serena Hagerty and Kate Barasz from Harvard Business School find that we tend to believe lower-income people need less than those on higher incomes, This phrasing of “need” does not seem accurate here, it’s more about priorities If you don’t have enough to buy food, pay the rent or emergency savings then securing these are the top priorities, doesn’t matter if you are rich or poor
- minikites 6y agoIf poor people can't be trusted to make rational market decisions, what does that imply about capitalism as a system?
- programmarchy 6y ago...that it's a utopian ideology, a false idea which can ultimately never be fulfilled, but which develops a "false consciousness in people about the world, how it works, and their place in it". > As an example, in Medieval Europe, religion was used as an ideology to support the structure of society. Serfs were told that the people in charge were put there by God and that the way the world worked was the only divinely ordained way it could work. No wonder people who were essentially slaves didn't rise up; they were told God wanted them at the bottom. > According to Marx, other ideologies like capitalism or liberalism work the same way. They are created, work to help sustain a particular social structure, and ultimately fall out of favor when a new idea comes to force. When this happens, the whole structure of society can change in a hurry as a new ideology fills the void. Source: https://bigthink.com/culture-religion/slavoj-zizek-ideology https://bigthink.com/culture-religion/slavoj-zizek-ideology
- viburnum 6y agoRelated, social dominance orientation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_dominance_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_dominance_orientation
- xupybd 6y ago>In the first couple of studies, participants read about Joe, who was described as having either a low- or high-paying job. They learned that Joe had won a $200 gift card which he spent on a flat screen TV. They then rated five statements which measured how “permissible” they thought his purchase was (e.g. “He made a responsible purchasing decision” and “He deserves to buy what he did”). Those who read that Joe had a low income rated his purchase as less permissible than those who read that he had a high income, or who were given no information about his income. I have no right to make a value judgement on how Joe spends his money in this example. However that is what the study asked participants to do. claiming that people scrutinized low income families based on that part of the study is incorrect. They simply tended to look differently on a spending decision to buy a luxury item based on income. Something the study required them to do. That said if a friend asked me for on advice on how to spend $200 my answer would depend on their financial position. If they had plenty to spend it doesn't really matter how they spend it. If they have very little I might recommend they spend it on a necessity rather than a luxury. That is not a judgement. It is simply the wiser choice. I suspect this could have been why people answered the way they did.
- rbecker 6y agoI got the impression the researchers already had a conclusion in mind, and structured their experiments around it. That's why they forced the "necessary" phrasing as the only way to express purchasing priorities, and then were shocked, shocked, to find the study participants rated what they would have saved money on as less necessary.
- DougN7 6y agoI think people judge because there is an implicit assumption that the poor in the question is poor enough that they might be getting some sort of assistance. If that’s the case, a luxury purchase is essentially being subsidized by tax payers. And THAT now brings a lot of expectations in (i.e. don’t waste what others sacrificed to give you).
- Rotten194 6y agoIf you read the original study, participants were only asked about one version of Joe, not asked to compare. In another version of the study where an additional third framing, where Joe's income was not mentioned, rich Joe and neutral Joe were rated the same, and poor Joe more harshly. They also did another version of the study where the thing being bought was a backup camera for a used car, and the study was 2x2: along with the income framing, there was also a framing of convenience vs safety (backup cameras are now required on all new cars since 2018 because they significantly increase safety, especially for pedestrians). Participants still rated the permissibility of a safety feature higher for a rich person than for a poor person, and rated the "convenient" camera for a rich person just as permissible as a safety camera for a poor person. https://sci-hub.tw/downloads-ii/2020-06-09/9a/10.1073@pnas.2005475117.pdf https://sci-hub.tw/downloads-ii/2020-06-09/9a/10.1073@pnas.2...
- arthurjj 6y agoI'm disappointed that the article doesn't take into account opportunity cost. One of the questions was "He made a responsible purchasing decision" when buying expensive or luxury goods. That's clearly going to have a different answer for low or high income people
- gshdg 6y agoBingo!
- MattGaiser 6y agoIn most countries with a welfare state, "low income" means using government money. Joe spending $200 on a TV means the state kicked in an extra $200 for rent/food that he didn't truly need.
- simonh 6y agoI have been on a low income, had a wife and child when my wife was unable to work and we saved as much money as possible. We had a cheap phone and internet package, made do with a second hand a TV set and microwave. When we had enough money to get a car, we bought a low end car seat and I got my first iPod when I won it in a competition. Now we have a lot more money, so we can afford better goods. When we were less well of, a better internet package, child car seat, electronic goods were less necessary COMPARED TO OTHER FINANCIAL PRIORITIES. We had other things to use that money for, like saving up for a deposit on our first house. if you’re not saying necessary compared to what, you’re not evaluating necessity.
- RickJWagner 6y agoI think it's often appropriate. People need to understand-- financial skills are acquired skills, and they have everything to do with your own fiscal fitness. It's not how much money you earn-- it's the delta between what you have coming in and what you spend. There are countless stories of low-to-middle income savers who grow to be wealthy through the power of safe, slow investing and compound interest. There are likewise countless stories of high-income individuals who spend all they make and more, ending up broke. The world needs more clarity. More education. These are bedrock, basic skills, but they are woefully underpresented.
- aklemm 6y agoSurely the just-world fallacy is at play at here. We tend to attribute fault to those unfortunate in order to preserve a belief that the world is just; we get what we deserve. Of course that’s ridiculous, but we think it anyway. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis
- thiht 6y agoI judge low income families in my circles for two reasons: - they complain - they tend to be jealous of others and judge them. Even sometimes of people who don't even spend as much as themselves Honestly, most low income families I know of make poor money choices (cigarettes and alcohol being the poorest). I actually believe a big part of poor people are poor because they make bad choices, even though it's a somewhat unpopular opinion.
- david38 6y agoUh, because there is endless discuss by do gooders on how to help the poor and endless comments by the poor that they’re poor and can’t make ends meet.