3 ms·
I think the history of Blood Libel is instructive here. The story of Simon of Trent was spread both maliciously and foolishly and led directly to the murders of
by UncleMeat 6y ago
I think the history of Blood Libel is instructive here. The story of Simon of Trent was spread both maliciously and foolishly and led directly to the murders of a large number of jewish people and played a role in centuries long persecution of european jews.
The example you mention is interesting because I think it is a good example of a statement that is both spread maliciously and foolishly. There has been both deep study and serious activism surrounding "black on black crime" yet this phrase persists because it is powerful ammunition from people who seek to persist white supremacy to convince people that people that activism is just whining and should be ignored. If you stood up in a Q&A session at a sociology conference on criminology and asked this you'd be outing yourself as truly ignorant of the field - the same as if you stood up in a Q&A session at an atmospheric science conference and asked "what about milankovitch cycles".
The heterodox academy tips their hand when they bring up examples of thoroughly discredited ideas as things that they should be able to force people to take seriously.
- ping_pong 6y agoSorry, are you saying black-on-black crime is thoroughly discredited? I'm not saying that blacks haven't suffered immeasurably due to white racism, but if a journalist retweets a link to an interview of a black activist that asks the question about black-on-black crime, and then the journalist gets attacked as racist, that's too many levels of indirection. It sounds like people aren't even allowed to ask the question unless they wish to be fearful about their careers and livelihood. That is the definition of censorship of ideas. And if someone were to ask a question that is ridiculous, is the answer to cancel them or to engage in a discussion and educate them? That is the essence of free speech.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Sorry, are you saying black-on-black crime is thoroughly discredited? No. The specific discussion of black-on-black crime is about the idea that nobody is discussing it, which is just false on its face. This is distinct from questioning whether black people are often the victims of crimes committed by other black people. People are allowed to ask questions. I just ask two things. 1. That when somebody provides you with an answer, you stop asking the question. 2. That you recognize when a question has been weaponized as a means to dismiss activism and analysis rather than as a means to expand activism and expand analysis. This is the same as my point about Milankovich cycles. They are real things. But "what about Milankovich cycles" is a weaponized idea among climate deniers designed to convince people that the experts haven't considered this, when they really have. Similarly, "what about black on black crime" is a weaponized idea designed to convince people that experts haven't considered this, when they really have. Experts have concluded clearly that the existence and even high frequency of black-on-black crime absolutely does not dismantle claims about white supremacy and systemic racism. Similarly, experts have concluded clearly that the existence of Milankovich cycles does not dismantle claims about climate change and the role of carbon emissions.
- DuskStar 6y ago> No. The specific discussion of black-on-black crime is about the idea that nobody is discussing it, which is just false on its face. This is distinct from questioning whether black people are often the victims of crimes committed by other black people. So now we're taking the literal definition of "nobody", and using it to say that this is false. Personally, I'd feel comfortable saying "nobody is talking about cause X", if related cause Y was being talked about 100x more. Otherwise "nobody is talking about X" is always trivially false - by saying that, you are talking about it. But by the 100x standard... Yeah, nobody (right now) is talking about black-on-black crime, in comparison to white-on-black crime. > Similarly, "what about black on black crime" is a weaponized idea designed to convince people that experts haven't considered this, when they really have. > Experts have concluded clearly that the existence and even high frequency of black-on-black crime absolutely does not dismantle claims about white supremacy and systemic racism. The problem with this argument - that this is a bad-faith question and it's been sufficiently addressed so shutup and stop asking - is twofold. First, many people will ask this due to not being familiar with those answers. Second, some people might think those answers are insufficient. Why not just link to the experts addressing it?
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Personally, I'd feel comfortable saying "nobody is talking about cause X", if related cause Y was being talked about 100x more. I'd truly encourage you to go engage with the literature and experts on this subject. You might find that your "100x" expectation is wildly inaccurate. > Why not just link to the experts addressing it? Because they are easy to find for people who are interested and spending time navigating the literature for people engaged in an intellectual denial of service attack is a waste of time. Same reason I stopped engaging with quacks causing trouble in my field of expertise.
- DuskStar 6y ago> I'd truly encourage you to go engage with the literature and experts on this subject. You might find that your "100x" expectation is wildly inaccurate. Funny thing is, for the people asking that question (and IIRC literally the case that led to this discussion, which was an on-the-street-interview) they aren't looking at the academic literature - they're reading Vox, or watching CNN, or Fox, or reading the NYTimes. And I think that 100x is pretty accurate there. > Because they are easy to find for people who are interested and spending time navigating the literature for people engaged in an intellectual denial of service attack is a waste of time. Same reason I stopped engaging with quacks causing trouble in my field of expertise. "This is easy, and people ask me to do it often, but instead of doing it once and saving the results I just say 'educate thyself' and walk away" Things that are easy for you - a person evidently up-to-date with the literature here - might be extremely difficult/impossible for someone who's not familiar, or who doesn't have free journal access.