3 ms·
I've read Veblen's "The Theory of the Leisure Class", and I don't see that it applies here. The author writes: "This rapidly growing industry has transformed t
by Animats 6y ago
I've read Veblen's "The Theory of the Leisure Class", and I don't see that it applies here. The author writes:
"This rapidly growing industry has transformed the nature of entrepreneurship and encouraged a particular form of low-quality entrepreneurship. It has done so by leveraging the Ideology of Entrepreneurialism to mass-produce and mass-market products that make possible what we term Veblenian Entrepreneurship."
I'd agree with the first sentence, but not the second.
We really do have "entrepreneurship as a service" now. Or did, pre-epidemic. Wannabe writes a pitch deck or a white paper, and convinces VCs, Kickstarter users, or ICO investors to put in money. Get space from WeWork, technology infrastructure from AWS, and turn traffic into revenue with Google Ads. Show the traffic climbing and you're a success, even if not profitable. Some such businesses even succeed in the end.
The question is, is this diverting people from doing hard, useful things? Like refurbishing buildings in bad neighborhoods. Installing solar panels and inverters. Tree trimming near power lines as a service. Automating meat-cutting plants. Don't know. We don't have enough of the latter, though. Those things have no low-probability big upside, which is what VCs want.
- dnautics 6y agoIs it possible that veblenian means in the context of a veblen good?
- petra 6y agoMany hard useful things, which once we're more accessible to small-scale entrepreneurs, have became scalable industries by using technology and free money. Solar installations certainly seems that way - it probably runs by big companies/platforms, hiring freelance salesman and installers and offering better financing, web marketing, QA, brand, etc. And of course this ties to "freelancers on demand" platforms, replacing many entrepreneurs. Same could go for tree trimmings, maybe by using sat images to find opportunities, and automating the legal, marketing processes. As for automating plants, there's robots-as-a-service, so this probably creates an opportunity for proven robotic service companies to grow and less for new entrepreneurs. It may just be that the world just needs far fewer entrepreneurs.
- notahacker 6y agoI'm not sure why you disagree with the second sentence, especially given your followup paragraph. It doesn't need to divert people from doing 'hard, useful' things to be a form of conspicuous consumption, it just needs people who are willing to accept less than they might otherwise earn in salary to have the social cachet of being a Founder CEO and investors [and sometimes even acquirers] willing to accept lower risk adjusted return to be associated with people and ideas they see as innovative or play golf with other investors in. If Veblen was born a century he'd be dripping with snark - justified and otherwise - about everything to do with the Valley, probably including a lot of the successful exits.