5 ms·
School choice (http://www.edchoice.org/School-Choice/What-is-School-Choice.aspx http://www.edchoice.org/School-Choice/What-is-School-Choice....) via vouchers ad
by mhb 16y ago
School choice (http://www.edchoice.org/School-Choice/What-is-School-Choice.aspx http://www.edchoice.org/School-Choice/What-is-School-Choice....) via vouchers addresses the needs of students. Presumably he should support that since it will keep "malicious administrators" in check the same way supermarket choice keeps malicious supermarket managers in check.
- r00fus 16y agoSome disadvantages to vouchers: With additional choice, now schools will be forced to spend your tax dollars to market themselves... this is an additional overhead to the already underfunded system. Plus what happens when a local school "goes under"? If some folks are forced to drive their kids for 30-40m to another school because no local schools can be funded, is that in their best interests?
- mhb 16y agoConsider whether your arguments apply to any other good in the economy and what makes education unique. It isn't. You have no way of knowing whether education is underfunded because you don't know what distortions exist in the education system. In any case, it is likely that choice would produce a better outcome than the existing system for the same cost.
- anigbrowl 16y agoIreland, where I grew up, has public education but also a pretty free school choice system. I think it's better than the US approach, but it's not a magic bullet. Retail competition works well because there isn't a huge cost involved with trying out or switching to a competing supplier. Switching schools is a big disruption for everyone involved, and a market that can't clear in the normal economic way, same as healthcare/insurance. So while I'm supportive of your idea, it's only part of a broader approach to reform.
- warrenwilkinson 16y agoIt seems a lot of money goes into massive school complexes. In a more free education market, I think you'd see smaller neighborhood schools, which would make school switching much less costly. A teacher needs a single room, which can be in a community center, a small office, or their home. If the licensing requirements for teachers and schools were removed it would be easy to setup. Parents could decide who qualified to teach, instead of bureaucrats.
- anigbrowl 16y agoParents could decide who qualified to teach, instead of bureaucrats. This already happens via elected school boards. And you get people teaching intelligent design instead of evolution. I see the point you're trying to make, but think you're being wildly optimistic and over-simplifying the problem to boot.