3 ms·
I have a paid Chrome extension and recently implemented an uninstall survey to see why people are leaving. For people who indicate that cost is an issue, we exp
by gnicholas 6y ago
I have a paid Chrome extension and recently implemented an uninstall survey to see why people are leaving. For people who indicate that cost is an issue, we explain that many "free" products are either supported by advertisements or by selling user data. We then ask people if we offered such a "free" option if they would choose that over our paid option (which costs less than $2/mo).
Almost all of the respondents indicate that they would choose the "free" version. I was surprised that the feedback was this one-sided, especially after making the tradeoff salient (and especially for a browser plugin that sees every page you visit). Apparently most people just don't care about their privacy.
- mywittyname 6y agoI think a lot of this comes down to the fact that so many people are tracking where you go online that there's not much point in trying to stop it.
- user5994461 6y agoPrivacy has no "cost" whereas paying $2 right now is a very understandable cost. Also, it's not $2 but $50, for users wary of automatically extending monthly subscriptions.
- tomComb 6y agoThere are some very important distinctions there. Maybe you said your free version would use targeted ads - which I'm fine with personally. It's selling data or being dishonest about how the data is used that I have a problem with, so maybe the problem is that your users trust you so they are comfortable with you having and using their data.
- gnicholas 6y agoIn my survey, I didn't say anything about the type of ads or how we would use the data. We are very trustworthy, and part of that is that we don't monetize user data in any way. But of course if we created a free tier that was funded by monetizing user data, this would no longer be the case!
- biggestdummy 6y agoHow, exactly, are the ads supposed to be targeted if data isn't being sold? How is Fiat supposed to learn that you are interested in buying a car, if there's no tracking and sale of your browsing history? Not saying that being tracked is good. Just that saying "I'm ok with targeted ads, but not ok with tracking" doesn't make a lot of sense.
- jefftk 6y agoAd personalization can be handled by the ad network. The network contract they are interested in buying a car, and Fiat can request their ads be shown to people interested in buying a car. Fiat only learns that you are in the "people interested in buying a car" category if they win the bidding to show you an ad. Not great, since showing an ad, especially well out of the viewport, is pretty cheap. We can take this one step further with the proposed TURTLEDOV browser API (https://github.com/michaelkleber/turtledove https://github.com/michaelkleber/turtledove), at which point the ad network doesn't learn your interests and Fiat only learns you were interested in buying a car if you click on an ad. Or with the proposed FLoC browser API (https://github.com/jkarlin/floc https://github.com/jkarlin/floc) where your browser uses on-device clustering to present an interest category instead of the ad network learning interests server-side. (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google, and am friends with the folks behind these proposals)
- m463 6y agoalso, your respondents might be a self-selecting population.
- aleppe7766 6y agoThis is a small eco chamber after all. The billions willingly share all their “private” stuff on FB and Google, which are concentrating orders of magnitute more data than any legit or fraudulent data company on the planet, and putting them out of business in the process.