3 ms·
>but I think it's wrong to say what you have is free speech, if you think that people who say the wrong things get what they deserve. Then having laws prohibit
by krapp 6y ago
>but I think it's wrong to say what you have is free speech, if you think that people who say the wrong things get what they deserve.
Then having laws prohibiting slander, libel, fraud, harassment and incitement to violence also means we don't have free speech, since that is the state saying "people who say the wrong things get what they deserve."
I think all but the most hard-core an anarchist free speech advocates would agree with those limits to speech. Even Benjamin Franklin had limits to what he was willing to publish, as recounted in a comment here[0].
Freedom of speech does not mean all platforms must be forced to host your speech, nor that all people must be forced to consider it. The line between social consequence and censorship only tends to be drawn between agreement and disagreement with the speech being rejected - it's social consequence when you agree with it, and censorship when you don't.
If that means we don't have free speech, then I guess we don't have free speech and, more to the point, have never had free speech.
[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23065586 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23065586
- ksdale 6y agoAs I said, I think it's perfectly fair to place other values above free speech, but I think the examples you give can more fairly be summed up as "the right to free speech doesn't extend to these types of speech" rather than "you're free to libel as long as you're willing to live with the consequences." The second framing is technically true, but only technically... For what it's worth, I agree with you about not forcing platforms to host speech and with your point about the line being drawn arbitrarily. I think that free speech can be both a legal right and a value that is shared by the members of a society. Edit: The Ben Franklin quote shows that he wouldn't publish anything he thought unworthy, but he would still print it for people, so he didn't refuse to do business with the people whose writing he found abhorrent.