7 ms·
You can always construct a credible argument for how any statement is "encouraging sentiment that does lead to real world violence and other harms". So with th
by BurningFrog 6y ago
You can always construct a credible argument for how any statement is "encouraging sentiment that does lead to real world violence and other harms".
So with that "exception", you can ban absolutely anything.
- krapp 6y ago>You can always construct a credible argument for how any statement is "encouraging sentiment that does lead to real world violence and other harms". No, you can't. Human beings don't process language at such a low level that any statement which parses as grammatically valid is considered equally valid to all others in all possible dimensions, interpretations and contexts. While It may technically be possible to make an argument that any arbitrary statement causes real world harm and violence, not all such statements would be considered equally credible. The slippery slope you're describing here doesn't exist.
- lefrenchy 6y agoAgreed, that slippery slope argument is so fallacious. I'm a free speech advocate, but let's not pretend that banning Nazi imagery in Germany is some sort of dangerous precedent, it encompasses so much historical context that it's asinine to use it as justification for a slippery slope argument.
- at_a_remove 6y agoOne would think so, but then the continual accusations of someone being an "actual Nazi" get thrown about almost constantly these days.
- BurningFrog 6y agoI routinely see arguments of the type "Argument X is likely to increase prejudice against Trans/BIPOC/Undocumented people, which will lead to more of them being murdered" used against completely mainstream conservative arguments. Just a few weeks ago a NYT op ed by senator Tom Cotton caused a staff revolt at the paper which got the editorial page editor fired, and a main argument was that publishing it threatened the lives of NYT employees.
- baddox 6y ago> I routinely see arguments of the type "Argument X is likely to increase prejudice against Trans/BIPOC/Undocumented people, which will lead to more of them being murdered" used against completely mainstream conservative arguments. So what? Are you saying those arguments aren't true? If so, of course you should make that counter-argument. Or are you saying that even if they are true, it's more important to protect "mainstream conservative arguments" than to protect those people from prejudice?
- BurningFrog 6y agoTo recap, I claimed: > You can always construct a credible argument for how any statement is "encouraging sentiment that does lead to real world violence and other harms" People disagreed, so I gave these examples.
- baddox 6y agoAnd I’m wondering what your response to those examples would be.
- BurningFrog 6y agoI think that an counterargument that can be made against any argument obviously proves too much and has to be ignored. The alternative is that we accept that all arguments cause murder and must be banned. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proving_too_much https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proving_too_much
- thephyber 6y ago> which got the editorial page editor fired, and a main argument was that publishing it threatened the lives of NYT employees The official editorial note makes no mention of this: > An editors’ note posted late Friday noted factual inaccuracies and a “needlessly harsh” tone. “The essay fell short of our standards and should not have been published,” the note said. In the end, criticisms of one for-profit newspaper aren't all that compelling to "free speech". In the same way we don't force a Christian church to allow any atheist to debate evidence against the existence of a god _in_ _a_ _church_, we don't force private companies to publish that which the company doesn't want to publish. So long as the discussion is happening somewhere in society, I don't know that we must insist that _all_ conversations are happening _everywhere_.
- throwawaygh 6y agoSo, two things: 1. Your assertion has empirical counter-examples. My favorite example is Tinker. The dissent in that case already foreshadows exactly your concern, that the "substantial disruption" test was quite arbitrary. But, in fact, lower courts were by-and-large extraordinarily friendly toward student speech when applying the Tinker test. So much so that SCOTUS has had to limit the scope of Tinker at least a few times in the intervening years (e.g., Hazelwood and Morse). It's not perfect, but no reasonable person looking at the historical record can say that the "substantial disruption" exception to free speech was used to ban "absolutely anything". And "substantial disruption" is probably the most mild form of harm. 2. Remember that TulliusCicero isn't arguing against free speech. They're only pointing out that DanielBMarkham's particular defense of free speech isn't compelling. I think that's fair. DanielBMarkham's approach toward defending free speech, which has at its roots in some enlightenment-era ideas about what man is, really doesn't provide us with a good conceptual framework for addressing TulliusCicero's critique. So, although I'm pro-free speech, but I don't think the argument that either you or DanielBMarkham put forward are particularly compelling. If you want to defend free speech, you have to honestly deal with the valid concern that speech really can harm. Insisting that man is a rational animal, or even that the search for truth will always lead to good outcomes, is... just not historically compelling.
- DanielBMarkham 6y agoYou're certainly not using SCOTUS arguments for Enlightenment ideals. I sure hope not. My argument was mean in the generic and at an abstract level. I understand that for some people this is not compelling. Conversely, if were to dive down into specifics, we would need a somewhat lengthy conversation about where the guardrails were and where the (hopefully unmovable) goalposts were. Of course at some level of analysis free speech can cause harm, otherwise there would be no point in defending it. My admittedly-oversimplified point, which I have yet to see refuted, is that in the main, we really suck at predicting the difference between harm and progress. Many times it takes decades or centuries to sort it out. From there we can end up with the law being an ass[1] or some finer definition of legitimate public policy choices. But unless we can all admit that we suck at determining who should speak or not, we really don't have a basis to continue the conversation, legally or philosophically.[2] It's fine to say "Let's start here, and given the current tech, governmental structures, and laws we live under, where do we go?" It's also fine to say "What is the purpose of letting people say things that can hurt others, anyway?" Pick one. I chose the second one. If you'd like to talk about the first one, that's a completely different conversation. However if you don't grok the conversation on root principles, it's unlikely any sort of more complex or nuanced conversation is going to lead you anywhere useful. That has to be where we all start. Also, insisting man is a rational animal is yet another can of worms which I didn't open up. I don't think man is a rational animal at all, and that doesn't change my opinion or where I think the conversation has to begin. [1] https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/the-law-is-an-ass.html https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/the-law-is-an-ass.html [2] When I say that we suck at determining who should speak or not, I mean in a moral, ethical, and public policy sense. I do not mean in a legal sense. Obviously there's a ton of case law around most all of our amendments. I'm surveying a landscape, not preparing a legal brief.
- nine_k 6y agoUnfortunately, you have to account for humans not being entirely (or even chiefly, every so often) driven by reason. This is why crying "Fire!!" in a crowded theater is not considered free speech. Unfortunately again, there's no easy and decisive test to show what kind of utterance leads to direct harm, and what does not; this space is unavoidably nebulous. This is why it's often left for courts to decide on a case by case basis. The US constitution guarantees that the government will not suppress free speech. But the US society needs to find mechanisms to channel speech on uncomfortable subjects so that it is not entirely suppressed and so the voices against the majority opinion can be heard, but also so that it's not leading to imminent violence and the loss of the rule of law. Without the rule off law, all free speech protections would be lost anyway.
- thephyber 6y ago> This is why crying "Fire!!" in a crowded theater is not considered free speech. To be precise, it _is_ considered protected free speech. For it to not be protected, the speaker has to _knowingly_ say it _falsely_.[1] Also, this was only a hypothetical example from a SCOTUS case where an American was petitioning WW1 draftees to ignore/avoid the draft, which is far less of a black and white situation (a fire is an eminent danger to the people in the room, a war across the ocean is not), which reinforces your point. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...
- baddox 6y agoA similar argument is "You could always claim that anyone is a murderer, and thus you could imprison anyone. Therefore there should be no legal consequences for murder." I disagree with this mode of argument that you should not support some action A because someone might perform action A incorrectly or mistakenly.
- atomi 6y agoA similar argument I've heard before used states rights as a defense. You might have said if states were forbidden from holding slaves then that "exception" could be used to ban absolutely anything.