5 ms·
To whatever extent this disincentivizes Google from scanning, it also incentivizes others, who now can make the argument such scanning-for-indexing-and-preserva
by gojomo 16y ago
To whatever extent this disincentivizes Google from scanning, it also incentivizes others, who now can make the argument such scanning-for-indexing-and-preservation is legal without Author's Guild approval, and can try models other than the Google-financed rights-clearinghouse.
Disclosure: I work the Internet Archive, a key part of the 'Open Content Alliance' that opposed the Google Books Settlement, but I don't work on any of the book-related projects and I only speak for myself here.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- gojomo 16y agoWell, the settlement would have given Google a bonanza, but made things harder for others (by conceding both a key fair use point, and a budget for more litigation, to the Author's Guild). Whether that bonanza for Google would have been a net win for total books scanned is hard to tell. It doesn't have to be a company; you mentioned the government, and the nonprofit I work for (Internet Archive/archive.org) has a large book-scanning effort. It's also not that hard to do in a distributed, at-home fashion; see the following on DIY efforts and how to upload scans to archive.org: http://onthecommons.org/diy-book-scanning-takes http://onthecommons.org/diy-book-scanning-takes http://blog.archive.org/2011/03/14/book-scan-wizard-software-now-supports-internet-archive-uploads/ http://blog.archive.org/2011/03/14/book-scan-wizard-software... Further, the total number of books that need scanning (as opposed to being born digital) is pretty close to capped, given the rise of born-digital versions and ebooks. Google itself estimated the total number of unique "printed and bound" materials recently as only 146 million: http://booksearch.blogspot.com/2010/08/books-of-world-stand-up-and-be-counted.html http://booksearch.blogspot.com/2010/08/books-of-world-stand-... Google's scanned over 15 million with no guarantee of the ability to sell them or legal victory. Other libraries have scanned hundreds of thousands more. Scanning is definitely happening faster than new print-only books are being created. Clearing up the situation with 'orphan works' would help. A victory for Google and others on the matter of fair-use scanning for indexing and excerpting (without sales) would help, too. As you note, the scanning is still "cheap compared to the rest of the operations". So it was never the case that Google needed a big economic incentive, or nothing would get done by Google or anyone else. That everything will be scanned is now a lock; it's just how fast and whether one company will dominate that's an open issue.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- itswindy 16y agoSure it is expensive, but once you make Google the 'owner' it's over for a lot of things. That's too high of a price. And it wouldn't hurt Larry and Sergey to give a bit of money back to the society to scan these books without Google holding the copyright ;)