7 ms·
WHAT EXACTLY IS FREEDOM OF SPEECH? My view on freedom of speech is different from most I found, but I think it’s the one that is consistent and stays true to a
by EGreg 6y ago
WHAT EXACTLY IS FREEDOM OF SPEECH?
My view on freedom of speech is different from most I found, but I think it’s the one that is consistent and stays true to actual definitions of words.
Human freedoms are about what the human can do. Right to bear arms. Right to speak. Right to assemble. And so on. That is how the Bill of Rights seems to intend it.
Note that the freedom to physically say anything and not get carted away is different than that of an organization.
Corporations may be “persons” for the purpose of suing and being sued in court etc. But when it comes to freedom of speech, it is quite another level of indirection!
When Sinclair TV buys a bunch of local stations, and makes them say something, they are not really free. They are saying whatever they are being told to say:
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/04/02/598794433/video-reveals-power-of-sinclair-as-local-news-anchors-recite-script-in-unison https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/04/02/598794433...
But here is the proper description: freedom of speech is different than access to a megaphone that an organization with a large audience gives you.
And I prefer that our news and announcements would be run more like Wikipedia than FOX, CNN or even Twitter. Because the latter tear apart our society. News outlets were disrutped by the Internet so they adjusted by locking in an audience by choosing a side and publishing clickbait. And social media in their race to the bottom for advertising dollars herded us into echo chanbers around this content. The current political fever pitch is NOT an accident or a plan by any one person. What can we do instead? Run it like Wikipedia.
Think of concentric circles. The smallest circle is what certain groups of mutually distrusting / disagreeing experts / pundits discussing things. They are the ones to go and publish dissenting opinions. This is analogous to the Talk page on Wikipedia.
This circle of people get a notification every time that one of them posts, so they can add their 2 cents.
Then once enough of them have weighed in, the next level is opened up — which is either the public or an intermediate circle of fact-checkers or news organizations.
I do not think the public should get stuff unfiltered from the megaphone of anyone with a Twitter audience of 50,000 or a podcas audience of 40,000. Sure, we are not used to this kind of society, but it is NOT a FREEDOM of speech issue. It is an issue of access to megaphones.
The current understanding of “freedom of speech” leads to contradictions and idiosynchrasies where one side claims that Facebook, Twitter are private platforms and aren’t covered under the Bill of Rights, while another side says that they are larger than many countries and are directly distributing speech on their platform. Whether these are “online countries” or not and whether they are subject to the US Bill of Rights because they are located here or operate here is up for debate. But under my definition the forced restructuring of how information is disseminated to wider and wider audiences wouldn’t be a Freedom of Speech issue.
PS: By the way, what I described is how news desks used to be run, with various editors being involved before things went to press.
- hirundo 6y ago1A: "Congress shall make no law ... prohibiting the freedom of speech, or of the press;" EGreg: "it is NOT a FREEDOM of speech issue. It is an issue of access to megaphones." Are you saying that the "freedom of speech" part is a good idea, but "freedom of the press", phrased as a "access to megaphones", is the problem?
- intopieces 6y agoThe freedom of the press is the right of like minded people to print what they want (barring slander and libel). It is not a requirement that those like minded people print content they object to.
- EGreg 6y agoYou make a good point. Freedom of the Press in the Bill of Rights can easily be the basis for the kind of thing I am criticizing. People should say all this is a “Freedom of the Press issue” not a “Freedom of Speech” issue.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> but it is NOT a FREEDOM of speech issue. It is an issue of access to megaphones. Let them speak freely, but in a room with nobody else.
- intopieces 6y agoFor what it’s worth, this is the best in-depth summary of a phrase I’ve also been using: The right to speak to is not the right to sponsorship. The freedom from censorship is not the freedom from social consequences inflicted by other free people. Overall I think the Internet works well for free speech in the US. It’s still cheap and easy to start your own website, so even if what you have to say is abhorrent to the majority you can still say it and have access to billions of people on earth. Just make sure you avoid CloudFlare.
- ksdale 6y agoHow do you distinguish between censorship and social consequences inflicted by other free people?