4 ms·
Biochemist Nick Lane espouses the 'alkalkine thermal vent' theory of abiogenesis and believes that single celled prokaryotic type life is almost inevitable on a
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
Biochemist Nick Lane espouses the 'alkalkine thermal vent' theory of abiogenesis and believes that single celled prokaryotic type life is almost inevitable on any planet that has or has had a mildly acidic ocean and active plate tectonics with aklaline thermal vents. It's a pretty convincing theory.
_Complex_ cellular life (eukaryotic) is another story entirely. There's no reason to believe they progress inevitably from bacteria. Bacteria have been happily doing their thing without much change for the last 3.5 billion (or more) years. The development of eukaryotes seems like mostly a fluke, and they are very young in evolutionary history. And weird. Very weird.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLcWfecmZhE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLcWfecmZhE
- perl4ever 6y agoIt's one thing to say that a particular evolutionary step is a zillion-to-one fluke and another to say that the possibility of any fluke leading to more complex life is of similar probability. Maybe there are or will be found to be more weird hybrids in nature? I vaguely recall reading something about how someone found a hint that brain cell communication may have mechanisms that resemble viruses (and/or prions). If you don't see eukaryotes as inevitable, then what about brains? Social insects? What about human civilization? Biotechnology? I don't think it contributes a lot to declare they are inevitable, but I don't see why eukaryotes would be a singular example of increasing organization that's different from all the others. Zooming out, it seems like a lot of random events merge into an exponential curve.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThe argument is basically from the fact that it occurred once and never again. Eukaryotes are the result of a symobiosis between archaea and bacteria, and we have yet to find any intermediary steps nor anything else that looks like a similar occurrence in nature. And yet there's nothing stopping that fact from happening again and it hasn't. Though apparently there is one tantalyzing find that may or may not amount to something. And also it seems to have taken 2 billion or more years for it to happen. And bacteria and archaea are pretty much "happy" the way they are. The development of eukaryotes broke an energy and complexity limit because of the symbiosis between mitochondria (which were once free roaming bacteria) and the host cell. It freed up the host cell to create genetic complexity orders of magnitudes higher than what a prokaryote can produce. Complex life cannot develop from prokaryotes because they simply can't produce enough energy to make it happen. Nor do they need to, they are extremely successful.
- gbrown 6y ago> And yet there's nothing stopping that fact from happening again and it hasn't. This doesn't quite ring true, since the environment which a new Eukaryotalike would have to compete in is a lot different now, since there are lots of Eukaryotes around to eat its lunch.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoNick Lane has a rebuttal to that, but I don't recall what it is off the top of my head. His books are worth a read.
- gnulinux 6y agoIf it's inevitable (i.e. it's not a low probability event) how come all life on earth today comes from a single ancestor? Did all other life started on earth die? Maybe we didn't find them? Maybe it started only once because earth is a very unlucky planet, and other planets had multiple abiogenesis events? Maybe it's not inevitable and it' low probability but still not it's not out of question most planets with the given properties have life?
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoactually not the case that all came from a single ancestor. there's two separate prokaryote lines, archaea and bacteria. they share some things in common so might have had some primitive pre-cell RNA-world thing in common... but their chemistry is different from each other. also we'd never know, since prokaryotes swap genes freely.. they don't have sex, they just laterally transfer genes all over... even between bacteria and archaea ... so you can't draw a family tree... and they also (early in life's history) modified the environment such that the exact chemistry that might taken place in the alkaline vents can't happen anymore... the ocean has become less acidic as a result of oxygen production