3 ms·
The FSF brought up some real concerns about Google having a lockhold on the intellectual property rights of all these materials (though they never convinced me
by ghshephard 16y ago
The FSF brought up some real concerns about Google having a lockhold on the intellectual property rights of all these materials (though they never convinced me why a Company like Microsoft, or Yahoo couldn't just negotiate the same deal with the Authors Guild and AAP).
The idea of this being okay under an "Opt-In" basis is idiotic. The entire rationale behind the "Opt-Out" approach was _the only people who cared_ would be the ones most capable and likely to opt out. The 99% of abandoned or orphaned works that have nobody to speak to, or nobody to find - would automatically return to the public domain where they belong.
For those Naysayers - how do you propose we prevent losing all those orphaned works to decay, and, just as importantly, make them accessible to the entire world - that's what Google was offering. In an ideal world, we'd have a sane copyright system which would terminate author's copyrights after some reasonable period of time unless they (or their estate) renewed their copy rights. That way, give an author, say, 20 years of exclusive rights, renewable for up to 40 more years (in 20 year increments) or 20 after their death, whichever is longer.
In that world - You could copy all the books, and, when the ISBN indicated it's copyright was expired - it would become searchable.
That _certainly_ will inspire authors to create new works - An author creating a material would be guaranteed income for them and their estate for a minimum of 60 years (presuming they die the very next day), or potentially more than 100 years - but, at the same time, means that works return to the public domain once nobody cares, creating a richer creative commons.
The problem with _this_ world is that copyrights continue for insane periods of time because a few content owners (of the hundreds of thousands who have created content) - have successfully lobbied for stretching out the copyright windows on ALL WORKS - not just the ones that people care about and are extracting economic value from, without thinking of the negative impacts on the creative commons. Thanks Disney. (Ironically one who very effectively mines the creative commons for their own works)
Remember, the purpose of copyrights and patents is not to create some monopolistic/locked-in intellectual property blackhole, rather, in the United States at least, it is "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries."
Emphasis on "promote the progress" and "securing for limited time"
Hopefully today's decision was a not big step backwards - in an ideal world, this settlement is modified such that it's available to all content archivers/searchers, such that they will have access to the same terms as Google, and we'll be able to truly "Promote the Progress of Science and Useful Arts."