3 ms·

I'm very skeptical. We can't even get police to properly investigate many crimes in the US, let alone without "making a mess". The idea that we're going to magi

I'm very skeptical. We can't even get police to properly investigate many crimes in the US, let alone without "making a mess". The idea that we're going to magically invent AI that "detects crime" and carries out lethal summary judgment seems completely detached from reality. By the time we have general AI that can do that, we won't even be in charge anymore and whatever happens from there will be up to the AIs.

searchableguy 6y ago
I don't think you need a general AI for something like this. You can detect what the other person is carrying and that works good as a filter. A person carrying knife in a crowd or school outside of canteen doesn't make any sense by general norms. Second would be to detect the intent - now that's a much harder problem but you can whitelist few situations where the person has already stabbed someone or shown sufficient physical evidence of criminal intent.
dafoex 6y ago
Not sure we need general AI, we can already detect undesirables and shadowban them on Twitter, all you need is to throw some facial recognition into the mix and you can link a person to an account that has a "wrong" ideology.
- lostmsu 6y ago
  Love that idea! In this society many people will be severely discouraged from crimes under threat of being banned from social platforms. You can even think up a dystopia where Facebook does the policing.
  - searchableguy 6y ago
    Year 2030: "Linkedin implements a system to identify to-be criminals by personal history and behaviour it tracks", in a report on Friday from the executives, Linkedin has decided to label offenders on its platform to reduce their reach and stop them from getting a job before it's too late. The CEO explained that this is just one of the policies that linkedin has implemented to serve justice to our society. Mark Zuckerberg says "justice shall be served. Social media platforms have the duty to govern society". Facebook has decided replace profiles of people breaking its policy with support social justice banners and links to donation box of variation NGOs. Additionally, they have decided that this policy will effectively block all offenders accounts on any platform they control including instagram, whatsapp, and integration which uses Facebook sign in functionality. They will share this data publically and encourage others such as partnered advertisers to block those offenders. After years of toxicity on Twitter, jack Dorsey says they are finally taking steps to serve justice to our society. New twitter update will make it mandatory to attach your credit card at all times and social security number as well as sensitive personal information. Offenders will be charged and fined on the platform and their accounts will be handed out to the victims for exposure therapy. Sundar Pichai thinks google must fix people's wrong perception and biases. Google representative told us that they would soon manipulate search and ad results of people it deems problematic in an attempt to "fix" them. Racist people will start seeing more anti-racist content in the coming days.

searchableguy 6y ago

I don't think you need a general AI for something like this. You can detect what the other person is carrying and that works good as a filter. A person carrying knife in a crowd or school outside of canteen doesn't make any sense by general norms. Second would be to detect the intent - now that's a much harder problem but you can whitelist few situations where the person has already stabbed someone or shown sufficient physical evidence of criminal intent.

dafoex 6y ago

Not sure we need general AI, we can already detect undesirables and shadowban them on Twitter, all you need is to throw some facial recognition into the mix and you can link a person to an account that has a "wrong" ideology.

lostmsu 6y ago
Love that idea! In this society many people will be severely discouraged from crimes under threat of being banned from social platforms. You can even think up a dystopia where Facebook does the policing.
- searchableguy 6y ago
  Year 2030: "Linkedin implements a system to identify to-be criminals by personal history and behaviour it tracks", in a report on Friday from the executives, Linkedin has decided to label offenders on its platform to reduce their reach and stop them from getting a job before it's too late. The CEO explained that this is just one of the policies that linkedin has implemented to serve justice to our society. Mark Zuckerberg says "justice shall be served. Social media platforms have the duty to govern society". Facebook has decided replace profiles of people breaking its policy with support social justice banners and links to donation box of variation NGOs. Additionally, they have decided that this policy will effectively block all offenders accounts on any platform they control including instagram, whatsapp, and integration which uses Facebook sign in functionality. They will share this data publically and encourage others such as partnered advertisers to block those offenders. After years of toxicity on Twitter, jack Dorsey says they are finally taking steps to serve justice to our society. New twitter update will make it mandatory to attach your credit card at all times and social security number as well as sensitive personal information. Offenders will be charged and fined on the platform and their accounts will be handed out to the victims for exposure therapy. Sundar Pichai thinks google must fix people's wrong perception and biases. Google representative told us that they would soon manipulate search and ad results of people it deems problematic in an attempt to "fix" them. Racist people will start seeing more anti-racist content in the coming days.