3 ms·
It seems every thread there is a comment on console. They are not the same. Console is a loss leader, or sold at cost. No one on planet Earth could make an exa
by ksec 6y ago
It seems every thread there is a comment on console. They are not the same.
Console is a loss leader, or sold at cost. No one on planet Earth could make an exact replica of Playstation 5 or Xbox 5 for discount. And that is excluding all the IP, R&D and Software / OS Development involved. The 30% is where they make the money. And personally that is a fair share.
Microsoft also make their profits via selling OS to OEM and Business. The current App Store model are there to help distribution of Software. And the 5% are essentially zero considering you will have to paid ~3% for credit processing any way. i.e Linking to the App Store frees you the burden and duty of hosting yourself for free.
Edit: And if you dont mind share why you downvote.
- pico303 6y agoI disagree. It doesn’t matter if the company makes money on the device or not. A device with a walled off App Store, be it a PS4, Xbox, Switch, or an iPhone, operates in the exact same murky legal waters. MS better be careful, or they could wind up breaking their own console’s ability to limit access to their store. Why shouldn’t Steam or Epic be allowed to sell games to an Xbox customer?
- ksec 6y agoSo you are suggesting console maker to sell at a loss while others come in and paid nothing for using their platform? Even EPIC have no problem with the console business model.
- baddox 6y agoOr, maybe don’t sell at a loss?
- ksec 6y agoYou then end up with no body buying the console. It would cost $999, and everyone would have problem justify that price tag. And the total market would shrink, which means for Game developers their Games would also have to be priced higher in order to make a return of investment. Normally that wouldn't work because pricing it higher also means less people are willing to buy, so the solution would be to lower the cost of making games. And less ridiculously expensive AAA titles.
- baddox 6y agoApple sure sells a lot of iPhones at around the $1000 price point, and they’re not selling those at a loss. I don’t see any reason to think that the laws of the physics are such that it’s simply impossible to sell a gaming console the same way that, you know, almost every product in the world is sold: for more money than it costs to make.
- inawarminister 6y agoI'd assume your typical gaming studio needs to sell a LOT more copies to break even than most shops producing iPhone apps. Also, a smartphone is an essential hardware for modern living. A gaming console... Not really.
- baddox 6y agoSure, but then the argument is nothing more than “because our product isn’t good enough to just sell it like every other normal product in the world, we have to sell it at a loss and then extract as much value as we can from developers by exerting total control over software distribution.”
- chongli 6y agoOr maybe the product is great but consumer expectations have been set by years of loss-leading prices on consoles?
- Talanes 6y agoAre you just arguing because you can't stand the idea of a world where everything isn't black and white? If the system as it has settled were so much of a problem for the developers, they would not have time and time again put their weight behind the companies pricing their consoles low. Prices are all ephemeral anyway. How many of those "normal products" are only able to be sold for more than they are made for because we value the labor of the person making it less than we would the same labor from the person buying it?
- Navarr 6y agoNo, I think they're suggesting that console makers need to open up their app stores and that may result in them no longer being able to sell at a loss.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gdhbcc 6y agoSelling at a loss is also called "dumping" and Is generally considered as a illegal anticompetitive practice. Why should video game consoles have an exception?
- take_a_breath 6y agoDoesn't Walmart do this with groceries section?
- will4274 6y ago> Selling at a loss is also called "dumping" and Is generally considered as a illegal anticompetitive practice No, this is wrong. Dumping is selling at a loss unsustainably in the short term to drive out competitors. If you do it sustainably, it basically can't be dumping. Thousands of business have loss leaders, from supermarkets to rasers. Video game consoles are not an exception.
- jonny_eh 6y agoConsoles are usually not sold at a loss. Maybe for the first year after launch, but they quickly get costs lowered to the point that they're profitable.
- danShumway 6y agoI'm also not sure that the "but consoles are closed" argument would be a slam dunk anyway, even if they were exactly the same, because I would absolutely support either requiring Microsoft to open up the XBox or allowing game developers to bypass Microsoft's controls. It's not clear to me why loss-leading consoles are a good thing for consumers. It just means that: A) games will be more expensive, because Microsoft needs to make more money on them, and B) a smaller number of games will be made, because the barrier of entry to profitability on any single game will be increased by forcing developers to subsidize Microsoft's costs. Microsoft is still going to make the same amount of money regardless. They'll either charge upfront, or that cost will be passed on to consumers in the form of more expensive, less experimental games. So, I dunno. People who make the comparison between Apple and XBox should maybe be careful what they wish for, because I'm more than happy to go after XBox, Playstation, and Switch with the exact same criticisms. I am skeptical that there are many indie game developers who are happy that they need to jump through hoops to get development consoles, or sign NDAs just to target a platform.
- pjmlp 6y agoXBox is kind of open, via UWP based games. The game development communities are exactly the opposite of HN culture, there no one cares about FOSS ideals and stuff, it is all about IP and getting their ideas into the gamer's hands no matter how. In fact, nowadays I see as a mistake having spent so much time around FOSS during the university back in the 90's, which caused a bit of schizophrenic considerations when going across communities.
- notSupplied 6y agoThe subsidized console increases the total user base by lowering the up front price hurdle. So you’re comparing a world with a small TAM, expensive consoles, cheaper games, vs a world with a large a TAM, artificially cheap consoles, and more expensive games. I think both game devs and console makers prefer the big-TAM world.
- 013a 6y ago"Xbox" is more than just the console; the Microsoft Store is a unified platform used to distribute both their console and PC games.
- tialaramex 6y ago> Console is a loss leader, or sold at cost Not loss leaders. Maybe close to "cost" but not loss leaders. The reason is the length of the lifecycle. Say you spend $100M developing a video game console. That seems outrageous. You ship 100 000 units to stores for the early adopters, and some goof says $100M/ 100 000 = $1000 per console just for the R&D costs. These must be a loss leader! But by the end of the cycle you've sold over 100 million units, so the R&D cost was under $1 per unit. You also get to do relentless cost engineering. When you spot a way to reduce the BOM by 4¢ on a product you're going to sell another hundred million of, that is Four million dollars you just added to the company's profits. Moore's law is on your side over that period of time too.
- btilly 6y agoI was going to say something similar to you, but then I read https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/080515/economics-gaming-consoles.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/080515/econo... and found that consoles are loss leaders. With the plan of making it up in subscriptions, licensing, and games produced by the manufacturer. In other words it is a "sell the razors at a loss and make it up on razor blades" strategy.
- tialaramex 6y agoRead carefully: > In 2006, at the time of PS3’s launch, each console was sold at a loss of around US $240 per console That would be a loss leader if the plan was you sell those launch consoles and then exit or move on to a new product having lost $240 per console. But that was never the plan, the plan was you sell millions more consoles over many years and so overall they're profitable. It's not razors and razor blades, Gillette sent me a free razor when I was a teenager because that's a razors and razor blades model. Sony doesn't give away consoles because they make money selling the console. They didn't make money on the first few million, which doesn't matter because they sold over a hundred million after that. The reason they don't do razors and razor blades is because the attachment rate is much lower than most owners imagine unlike for razor blades. It's typically going to be 5-6 games per console. PS4 actually hit 8 games per console but that's a fantastically successful machine nearing the end of its life. So, if you're losing $240 per console but you hope you can shift six games per console that is $40 per game you need to recoup to break even. If you go out to a third party developer and you say "We want $40 per sale" they are going to laugh in your face. This isn't Apple strong-arming independent developers, the big games publishers (most obviously Take Two and Activision) absolutely are powerful enough to walk away from such a deal knowing that their competitors will do the same and then the console is dead.
- robertoandred 6y agoApple also has IP, R&D and Software / OS Development costs. And no one is forcing console makers to adopt the margins they do.
- pjc50 6y agoQuite a lot of competition regimes regard loss leaders as inherently anti-competitive as well ...
- folmar 6y ago3% is the going rate for mom-and-pop, not large business, those run in the 1% ballpark.
- coffeeling 6y agoOne interesting thing about the Wii/PS3/XB360 generation was that Wii was sold at a profit. Knowing that, it was pretty funny to see Sony/MS fanboys lambast the Wii's low attach rates as an impending failure when the model was totally different. Sony would need a customer to buy multiple games to turn a profit on a PS3, Nintendo could sell someone a Wii and Mario Kart and not have them buy anything else, and that'd likely be a happy and profitable customer.