8 ms·
Apple’s App Store fees are ‘highway robbery’ – House antitrust committee chair
- Apocryphon 6y agoPerhaps this is apophenia, but it appears that societal tensions are boiling over from all corners, against all kinds of established authorities, no?
- loopz 6y agoThis is the expected outcome from introspection (Corona period).
- nunodonato 6y agoastrologers will have a different interpretation ;)
- agustif 6y agoEclipse + Solstice in 48h
- 3131s 6y agoRich people are introspecting, poor people are about to revolt.
- gear54rus 6y agoYeah and I wish it happened more often.
- Larrikin 6y agoAs much as I agree with the stance against I hate the coverage and the press this is getting with people evangelicizing the CEO. He's regularly referenced on this site by his initials (which even as a regular reader of tech news I had to look up) which comes across as cult of personality at best and astroturfing at worse.
- drukenemo 6y agoHe’s not the CEO though.
- Hamuko 6y ago>He's regularly referenced on this site by his initials Yeah, it's his Twitter handle. Do you think people are evangelizing rms just because he refers to himself as that and that people are following his example?
- deltron3030 6y agoHe actually is a kind of cult personality in the tech world because he wrote Ruby on Rails (which itself was kind of contrarian to most other things in that space), and it's the foundation lots of web software startups are build on. There would be no Twitter or Github without him.
- stunt 6y agoI believe Apple just don't see any reason to be nice. And probably that's what many companies would do if they were in that position. We know that we can't stay dominant forever, We know someone will force us to reduce Apple-tax later, So we have to get as much as we can, for as long as we can.
- t0ughcritic 6y ago#mafiatax
- sooheon 6y agoThis is a ridiculous meme. If you enjoy the mafia's services, don't be surprised if they ask you to pay. But it's your choice to go to them (ask to be put on their platform and sell to their customers). You can make your own internet corner shop, set up payments and distribution, ignore the Apple platform, and never worry about their #mafiatax.
- altacc 6y agoThat choice isn't a real choice though, as it's the consumers' choice to buy an iPhone not the businesses. Businesses only have a real choice about who their customers are when there is free access to the market. The issue here is precisely that you cannot set up your own internet corner shop and ignore Apple, as that means you have no access to consumers who use Apple. Internet distribution channels are inherently open and borderless, until companies like Apple artificially restrict the market.
- sooheon 6y ago> The issue here is precisely that you cannot set up your own internet corner shop and ignore Apple, as that means you have no access to consumers who use Apple I don't understand why businesses are entitled to have access to consumers who use Apple. If you don't want to pay to play on their platform, imagine a world where Apple doesn't exist, and position your business accordingly. Nothing is actually forcing you to deal with Apple except your own expectation that being on Apple's platform is valuable. Then why not pay for that privilege?
- matheusmoreira 6y agoApple wants to own iPhone consumers so that anyone who wants access to that demographic must pay the toll and follow their rules. It's far too much power for one corporation. Nice to see authorities are starting to take the matter seriously.
- LatteLazy 6y agoDon't count your chickens... Politicians love to grill CEOs in front of cameras and then do nothing about the issuea they find so they can grill them all again next year.
- sjwright 6y agoThat's fine, but how are you going to construct legislation that specifically targets Apple's walled garden without breaching the Fourteenth Amendment?
- saagarjha 6y ago> the Fourteenth Amendment Citizenship rights?
- sjwright 6y agoEqual Protection Clause.
- mirchibajji 6y agoGenuinely curious. I was under the impression that Constitution applies to people, and the govt. I'd appreciate if you point to any references for Constitution being applied to corporations.
- tomatotomato37 6y agoCorporations have had personhood for a while, it's why they also have free speech protection and stuff. 14th amendment protection specifically was decided in 1886 (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Clara_County_v._Southern_Pacific_Railroad_Co. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Clara_County_v._Southe...)
- t0ughcritic 6y agoGenerally only gaming companies can afford to pay or money losing vc companies. Let me just state generally again, most other companies just don’t sell via IAP as it’s too expensive. I’ve been saying this here for months and Google is guilty too 100%. These two control discoverability (search and ads), hosting (all data to copy your app), and monetization (charge tax on any profit you make). Why? Because they can and are evil. Doesn’t leave room for new consumer startups anymore and increases prices for consumers.
- 0xy 6y agoIf you could choose between a fee decrease to 15% or the ability to sideload apps bypassing the store, which is more important? To me, the only reason I avoid iOS is specifically because I cannot install my own apps without using the store.
- Hamuko 6y agoI don't really see how Apple would be able to justify the 30% cut if sideloading was possible.
- Aissen 6y agoHmm, like Google does ? Even that isn't a panacea, see Epic giving up on distributing Fortnite by itself.
- jamil7 6y agoSideloading makes the other point moot I'd say since competing third party stores would appear?
- 0xy 6y agoI don't think it does. F-Droid exists but is essentially totally unknown on Android.
- perryizgr8 6y agoOnly because Google is relatively freer than Apple. Android users and devs don't feel too constrained by Play store rules. If play store were to start behaving like app store, you can bet money f-droid, amazon store and others will rise in popularity.
- millstone 6y agoThe high order bit is the inconsistent, capricious nature of the app review process. Hey attempted to participate in the established detente of "paid service, can't buy it here, wink wink" and Apple somehow decided this was the time to squeeze. Clear, consistently enforced App Store rules, from a perspective of Apple desiring the best apps possible.
- sooheon 6y agoApple may be robbers, but they're not trolling a public highway, they're demanding fees if you want to drive on the highway that they built. Build a better ecosystem around better devices, better software, better marketing, and better services, and you can also charge whatever you want, or make it free. That is competition. Wanting to drive on someone else's walled highway (which leads directly to eyeballs and open wallets) and also refusing to pay their fee is not competition.
- Hamuko 6y agoSo are we establishing that if you want to create a paid email service with a custom app without wanting to pay 30% of your revenue to Apple, you need to create a competing mobile ecosystem that can rival that of Apple's ($260 billion yearly revenue) and Google's ($162 billion yearly revenue)? How is this beneficial for innovation and for consumers?
- sooheon 6y agoWhat's beneficial for consumers is the fact that the Apple ecosystem exists at all. People pay because it's a good experience. Everyone is welcome to create good end-user experiences with open technologies like PWA, and distribute however they wish. It's strange to me to say on the one hand "we could not survive without the iOS customer pool, we need to make a native app because it's the greatest experience, but we don't want to pay the platform that makes it all possible".
- Hamuko 6y ago>Everyone is welcome to create good end-user experiences with open technologies like PWA Everyone who isn't targetting Apple devices that is. I'd also like to take this opportunity to remind everyone that it is not possible to publish an application on the Apple App Store without paying. Period end. I also don't see why there's an expectation that Hey has to pay Apple for providing the app. They are trying to bring out an app to allow their customers on Apple devices to be able to use their service. It's not like they're just putting their app there for marketing because the App Store is absolutely horrible at any kind of marketing. This is a bit like expecting Netflix to pay Comcast, AT&T and every other ISP for the priviledge of using their networks. Netflix's customers are already paying those companies just like how Hey's customers are paying for their Apple devices.
- sjwright 6y agoIf the US Government wants to place limits on certain fees, they should pass a law limiting such fees. Meanwhile, it's a bit hypocritical for the US Government to accuse private corporations of ‘highway robbery’ when they themselves are committing (or failing to outlaw) literal highway robbery in the form of civil forfeiture.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Meanwhile, it's a bit hypocritical for the US Government to accuse private corporations of ‘highway robbery’ when they themselves are committing (or failing to outlaw) literal highway robbery in the form of civil forfeiture. Indeed it is. So they should address both, not use the current existence of one to excuse the other.
- sjwright 6y agoTo be clear, I wasn't saying that one excused the other. I was only commenting on the congressperson's poor choice of words.
- mirekrusin 6y agoThat's what they want to do, it will probably end up like that - Apple and others will be capped to how much fees they can charge. EU did this for roaming charges already.
- natch 6y ago>It’s crushing small developers who simply can’t survive with those kinds of payments. Oh I don't know. The "small developers who can't survive" he's talking to here have multiple hypercars and I don't think they are small or facing survival challenges. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pagani_Zonda#HH https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pagani_Zonda#HH https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koenigsegg_Agera https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koenigsegg_Agera Sure there are smaller developers. But the sense of entitlement is a bit much. Once you've written some software, that does not mean you are entitled to have people pay for your life from here on out. I mean you have developers who have written software once, do not maintain it, and would charge subscription fees if they could, for software they don't update. There is a spectrum of behaviors, and there is a cost for running a store to corral all those behaviors into some order that average consumers can deal with. And then there are even legal bills to pay, for fighting off people who own hypercars and feel wronged. There could be some room for the fees to come down now that the App Store is well established. But it's not quite how it's being portrayed… highway robbery? Way too dramatic.
- ageitgey 6y agoI don't think the pressure on Apple is going to let up. Smart phones are no longer a tech toy and have become a literal part of government and commercial infrastructure. Apple's arbitrary power over the platform is pissing off and embarrassing governments in the COVID era. During COVID, governments around the world have been making major decisions based on mobility data from Apple and Google which shows trends of where people are visiting and what mode of transit they are using. The real-time mobility data from Apple and Google is far better than anything the government has itself. This is a big wake-up call to the governments that they have been basically supplanted by private companies. I'm sure no president or prime minister likes having to give a press conference where they have to say "According to Apple, we see good compliance with government regulations...." Yesterday, the UK announced it was abandoning its own COVID contract tracing app and moving to the Apple model because they couldn't figure out how to make iPhones wake up via bluetooth (because that's a private API only available to Apple). A major western government is facing huge public embarrassment in a public health crisis over what comes down to not having permission from Apple to use a specific API in an app. That's the kind of thing that pisses off politicians, regardless of whether or not you think the UK followed the best technical path. Combine all that with Apple now forcing companies to adopt their sign-in systems and payment methods in order to reach what is now part of the public infrastructure and Apple has created a situation where they've managed to piss off everyone across the political spectrum, from the hard-core free market people to the leftist public good people.
- treebornfrog 6y agoI don't agree that Apple should bend over backwards. IMO contact tracing opens up a new can of worms and is a doorway to more draconian measures that will erode privacy for private citizens.
- rydre 6y agoThe leaders elected by the citizens or a different way of governance of other sovereign countries have the right to decide what is best for their citizens. American companies should not try to impose their moral values on others. Many eastern cultures do not value privacy as much as you guys do, and it's fine.
- Nasrudith 6y agoPerhaps it is a matter of my preestablished cynicisms but this seems like a campaign contribution shakedown/stupid election year publicity stunt where they rail against a big bad company for complete bullshit reasons. I don't get why people go with the Apple locked down system personally but they aren't even a majority of the market nor a plurality. There is absolutely no reason to believe that the House gives a shit about interoperability given the DMCA and lack of right to repair laws.
- koheripbal 6y agoGoogle isn't much better. I suspect the government is going to force both of them to open their app store with anti-trust suits.
- rydre 6y agoAnyone who cares about this issue, just upvote, don't comment. HN's algorithm downranks posts where the comment to upvote ratio is too high.
- bluesign 6y agoYeah and there is a reason for that and it’s working well to be honest. Gaming the system is never good option.
- rydre 6y agoMaybe they should change the algorithm then. There is an important discussion going on and the dumb algorithm thinks its better to just brush it away and kick the can down the road.
- Razengan 6y agoI think HN looks down on gaming their system. Comments like the above should be flagged.
- newbie578 6y agoApple has over 50% marketshare in the U.S. in the mobile market, so by marketshare they have a case for a monopoly. So for 150 million people Apple are the Gatekeepers, you have to pay the Troll it's fee or it won't let you past. And people here are saying if you don't like Apple, don't make apps for iOS? Please try to do a business project in a market where you ignore 50% of the market and let me know how you fair out :) Jason Freid of BaseCamp gave a good argument: If you are handling the search, marketing and production of the app by yourself, why do you STILL need to pay the 30% tax? Imagine paying AWS 30% of your revenue just for hosting privileges :) And don't forget that even IF you try to make the argument for hosting, they are hosting the app on Apple Store because Apple doesn't allow ANOTHER way of downloading an app. This is a really important fact. Imagine if you used Windows and you couldn't download programs except over Windows Store. Just try to imagine Windows not allowing Steam to distribute over the web...
- kmlx 6y agohelp me understand. why such big fuss for such a small platform? isn't google's android much much bigger? if apple's app store is still the place to be due to profits made on the platform then apple is doing something right, no? if they stopped would the app store still be the place for apps? p.s. haven't installed an app in over a year. i have no interest in mobile apps whatsoever.
- lm28469 6y agoThe market share of the iPhone in the US is around 50%
- greggman3 6y agoYes, and the next largest phone maker's market share is Samsung at 20-25%. Android doesn't make phones. Google makes some phones but their market share is tiny.
- kmlx 6y agoah, this is an interesting point. thanks.
- kmlx 6y agothe world is a much bigger place than just the US.
- lm28469 6y agoYes, but "Congressman David Cicilline" is American as far as I can tell
- hyko 6y agoWhy should I pay $99 per year for a hey.com email address? Robbery! I demand the courts lower this to 9¢ immediately, which I deem to be the true value of an email address. Hey are abusing their monopoly power over the hey.com domain...this will not stand! Burn it to the ground! Write to your congressman! I’ll spend my millions fighting this! Over my dead body! I’ll chase them round the moons of Nibea and round Antares Maelstrom and round perdition's flames before I pay $99 for a fucking email address! * I’m available for podcast interviews to promote my wares for a very reasonable fee. Hating hey.com is optional. No purchase necessary. Other email providers are available.
- koheripbal 6y agoThe rules change when a company has a near-monopoly and practices anti-competitive tactics to nerf their competition. That's why we have anti-trust laws.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoImagine if Credit card processing companies took 30%. I mean it's a little more than that being a marketplace too, so maybe since Stripe takes 2-3%, apple could take 5-8% that would seem more 'reasonable'. IMHO.
- routerhash 6y agoThat would work if apple force eCommerce companies that has an app in app store to sell through apple payment system and give a cut of 2-3% to apple
- makecheck 6y agoOne of the things I never understood is why Apple doesn’t have tiers of pricing and support. Why not “5% for app-upload capability and a plain store page with nothing else”, up to “30% for lots of nice bells and whistles” or even “50% for regular featuring to potential customers”? People would not complain about 30% nearly as much if there were any alternative. (And they are right to complain about how little 30% gets them currently.)