4 ms·
Not impossible but what's the mechanism? Humans haven't changed too much but societally we now have a much better understanding of systematically understanding
by mhh__ 6y ago
Not impossible but what's the mechanism?
Humans haven't changed too much but societally we now have a much better understanding of systematically understanding new phenomenon. If there was something like Lead Poisoning going around, information spreads so quickly we'd know about it.
That doesn't mean there isn't anything, but there have been people living and working around extremely strong sources of electromagnetic radiation ever since the 1930s and no one has been able to demonstrate risk on any macroscopic scale (There are some papers that do demonstrate a "statistically significant" detectable link between something an EM exposure, but - even when the levels are anywhere near safety limits let alone what is actually outside - these papers can never find any measurable risk to the body). The fact that nothing has been formally observed as of today establishes a fairly firm upper bound on the risk due to electromagnetic radiation.
That upper bound means that if there is any actual risk it is sufficiently subtle as to either be outpaced by the body or other issues (Even if 5G harmed people, based on the mentioned upper bound, it would still be better to telecommute than have cars polluting everywhere)
- freeflight 6y ago> If there was something like Lead Poisoning going around, information spreads so quickly we'd know about it. If said lead poisoning was profitable, then we'd mostly be busy belittling the negative effects for decades, until they couldn't be denied/ignored anymore, at which point most of the damage will already have been done, as it happened with tetraethyllead [0]. Another example would be the massive money in tobacco and how for decades this allowed certain profit-interests to dictate the public-health discourse around smoking it or how oil companies knew about their impact on climate change for decades before it became a widely-recognized problem [1]. There is no telling what other things that we consider "harmless" now will later turn out as having absolutely disastrous effects. Very similar to how people living in Victorian times filled their homes with all kinds of deadly things because they were considered convenient at the time [2]. With the luxury of hindsight, it's easy for us to go "Wow, people back then were kinda stupid", but I have no doubt that 100-200 years from now people will look at our current ways of living and come to very similar conclusions about us. To keep this on-topic: Maybe us blasting the environment with EM radiation is also a contributing factor bee colonies collapsing, as it might make it more difficult for bees to find their source of nutrition? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead#History [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExxonMobil_climate_change_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExxonMobil_climate_change_cont... [2] https://youtu.be/K3Jef7i7v1U https://youtu.be/K3Jef7i7v1U
- filoeleven 6y agoJust to add another example, PFOA / PFAS / GenX, a chemical family used by DuPont to create non-stick surfaces, is an insidious endocrine disrupters at very low levels. And it’s basically everywhere. https://theintercept.com/series/the-teflon-toxin/ https://theintercept.com/series/the-teflon-toxin/
- forgotmypw17 6y agoLook no further than chemical "cleaning" products
- est31 6y ago> If there was something like Lead Poisoning going around, information spreads so quickly we'd know about it. The first infection with HIV-1 subgroup M is presumed to have happened in the 1920s yet it took decades until the 1981 Pneumocystis Pneumonia article in MMWR. Only then people really started looking and discovered that the virus had been circulating for decades. HIV has an extremely long period where it slowly destroys your immune system but you personally feel mostly fine. Only years later you develop AIDS and then die from an opportunistic infection. Diseases with such long incubation periods are extremely hard to identify and it's even harder to identify their cause. We still don't know the cause for Alzheimer's disease for example. It's entirely possible that some aspects of a technology we use today causes such a disease but we'll only discover it 20 years down the line. Admittedly it's hard to test for such effects.
- macawfish 6y agoThere are plenty of published, peer reviewed papers out there about this stuff, it's just that you aren't looking at them. For example: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-22271-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-22271-3 Frankly, I'm tired of reductionist, rationalist attitudes that all but ignore the vast scope of nonlinear sciences that have emerged over the last 75 years. It's not much better than climate denial. Just less blatant.
- mhh__ 6y ago"There are some papers that do demonstrate a "statistically significant" detectable link between something an EM exposure, but - even when the levels are anywhere near safety limits let alone what is actually outside - these papers can never find any measurable risk to the body"
- bildung 6y agoWe have the phenomenon that we now have very sensible measurement instruments usable to detect trace amounts of materials, or miniscule changes in metabolisms. This enables much new research, but also leads to essentially irrelevant news like cocaine in tap water everywhere, or results like this one you linked: Of course the insects absorbed the microwave radiation, as almost every living tissue does. The interesting research question, though, is: Does the radiation influence actual behaviour, or do actual illnesses emerge due to exposure? We also have a lot of this in research about humans. One thing that often pops up here on HN is blue light and sleep: We can reliably show that blue light exposure before sleep affects serotonine levels in humans, but we mostly have a hard time showing effects on actual sleep. (I'm not interested in derailing the thread here, just an example)