4 ms·
The problem with campaign finance isn't that there's nothing there, it's that everything is there. "Money is speech" isn't a law of the United States, it's a la
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
The problem with campaign finance isn't that there's nothing there, it's that everything is there. "Money is speech" isn't a law of the United States, it's a law of physics. Money buys staff and billboards and newspapers and TV stations. Fox News works for the Republicans and CNN works for the Democrats even if neither of them donate a dollar to anybody's campaign. Google can put a banner on google.com that will be seen by the whole world.
Counting influence only when it's in cash and not in kind only makes the asymmetry worse. It transfers influence from millionaires who can "only" afford advertising to billionaires who own the media outlets themselves and gain airtime for themselves by not selling it to someone else. But counting third party speech as a political donation because it benefits a political campaign is intractable.
The easier problem to solve is to fix the voting system, because there is an uncontroversial and straight forward solution. Switch to range voting or approval voting, which dismantles the two party system. Then, when there are twelve parties in Congress, it's much harder to buy elections with money or airtime because the election winner's original chance of winning was 8% instead of 50%, which makes it much easier to waste your money on a loser and thereby reduces the payoff from spending it that way.
- r3trohack3r 6y agoThis is really insightful and powerful feedback. I'm going to spend time, a lot of time, reflecting on this. If you'd like to keep an ongoing dialogue on this, or help in any way, drop a line to staff@everytwoyears.org <3