2 ms·
Part of the reason is the insistence of not using international help to greatly advance projects, and favoring making the most minimum impact on car traffic pos
by asdff 6y ago
Part of the reason is the insistence of not using international help to greatly advance projects, and favoring making the most minimum impact on car traffic possible. When newer nations are able to rapidly and cheaply build infrastructure, chances are they are using outside help and have no qualms about de-prioritizing car traffic. We lack experience building infrastructure since we largely gave up on mass transit projects for decades; NYC and Boston are reliant on vestigial rail infrastructure that hasn't had a serious expansion for decades, D.C. metro almost didn't happen, and LA managed to build 1.5 subway lines in the 90s before metro was banned from digging new lines until the 2010s, under the unfounded idea that the city might explode into a methane fueled fireball if the tunnel boring machine made its way under Beverly hills high school. That half line they started in the 90s won't be completed until 2030, and will be 3.5 miles shorter than originally planned.
Our ignorance and unwillingness to take off the shelf solutions is what has driven up our costs. The patriotic label of 'american made' is regularly used to hide greed and waste. This LA times article (original la times link was dead, this is a mirror) talks about how an established french company offered to construct the project under budget, but officials dismissed them and opted to reinvent the wheel for massive costs along a political route, not an optimal one (1).
The contractor consultant model that we rely on for public works is designed to loot the public purse first, and improvements to public welfare take the back seat to maintaining the status quo of a car dominated way of life. If we were serious, calhsr would have been spooled up into an actual agency with its own labor and engineering pools, and not be this big resovour of public money being sucked dry by parasitic consultants who smelled the billions of dollars of chum we put in the water and convinced us explicitly not to try this in house (2).
Another example of compromised by design infrastructure is the expo line in LA. It takes 15 minutes for the train to travel two miles from USC to downtown LA, because the train runs at grade and is only this year being given signal priority at traffic lights, despite the line opening 8 years ago. Embarrassing to spend millions on a vehicle that can be beaten by someone in decent shape sprinting those two miles along the train tracks.
1.
https://transdef.org/wp-content/uploads/High-speed-rail-officials-rebuffed-proposal-from-French-railway.pdf https://transdef.org/wp-content/uploads/High-speed-rail-offi...
2.
https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-california-high-speed-rail-consultants-20190426-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-california-hi...
- m-ee 6y agoThe N Judah in SF is actually slower than it was 100 years ago. I lived on 12th ave and if I missed it I could usually beat it to the 9th and Irving stop and get on there.