4 ms·
So what do you do with people who do things out of malice, say, mobsters, human traffickers? Some people do things because there’s an opening. How do you do r
by mc32 6y ago
So what do you do with people who do things out of malice, say, mobsters, human traffickers? Some people do things because there’s an opening.
How do you do restorative justice with them?
- tonystubblebine 6y agoWhat do I do? Nothing. Did you see that part of my post? I really tried to emphasize that you go piece by piece and that harder pieces get addressed later. I'll be dead before anyone tries to figure out what to do with mobsters. But if you could find a way, almost definitely that way would be preferable to incarceration. That is why it's called abolition. The goal is to find ways to abolish every single category of incarceration.
- mc32 6y agoI guess my point is that I can imagine abolishing some categories, but not all bar some heretofore unavailable alternatives.
- tonystubblebine 6y agoThere is a lot of research that people don't know about. And also a lot of people willing to do more research. So why limit your position here to just the solutions you can personally imagine?
- tuesdayrain 6y ago>you go piece by piece and that harder pieces get addressed later Sounds like diving head-first into something with significant short and long term consequences while refusing to plan for the actual end-game. Frankly the reason people haven't addressed the "harder pieces" of abolition yet is because there is no good alternative to prison. Some people are fundamentally dangerous to society and no amount of "please be nice" therapy or education will change them.
- tonystubblebine 6y agoWhat is the risk here? Break it down for yourself. I think either you are imagining a different process than I'm imagining or you'll find there are no short or long term consequences other than maybe some research money that gets spent verifying a dead end. If 90 years from now a set of experiments to find alternatives to incarceration for mobsters failed, that's not going to make people regret the first step of abolition which is probably decriminalizing drug possession. Or the second step, which is also well supported, which is eliminating cash bail.
- nickff 6y agoIt seems like you're setting a target that you have no actual plan to achieve. Perhaps de-scoping the project would have the twin benefits of appearing more reasonable to your audience, and allowing for the possibility of success.
- tonystubblebine 6y agoThe abolition movement does answer this which is that the reform movement has already been tested and failed. For illustration, can we say the easiest and most straight forward solutions eliminate 50% of incarceration? We've had incarceration rates in the US that were lower than that. When reformers say reform, they have to fight tooth and nail for 1% reduction. Even in New York State some simple bail reform got rolled back almost immediately after heavy PR by the police departments here. How do you go from 1% to saying, no, no, we actually meant 50x more reform than that? It just doesn't work. So, if abolition says 100% and it laters turns out that the theoretical healthy limit for a society is only 80%, well, nobody on the abolition side is going to be all that worked up about it.
- nickff 6y agoIf you were negotiating pricing with a single party, anchoring would work, but I think that's not what's going on here.
- HeroOfAges 6y agoI think they should re-assess their goal. Abolishing every single category of incarceration is as realistic as finding a way to travel faster than light.
- tonystubblebine 6y agoIt's a good exercise to look at who is currently in jail on a given night in the US and decide for yourself how much incarceration could be eliminated. I say the goal should be 100%, but it might take 100 years and might stall out before 100%. That's fine by me. But maybe you see this only as 50%. I'd be surprised if you did your own research though and came up with only 5%. Here's a good starting point of who is in jail and why. https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html
- perfmode 6y agothis wikipedia article has some in depth responses to your line of inquiry. it also presents common positions of those in opposition to abolition: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison_abolition_movement https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison_abolition_movement
- perfmode 6y agoprisons in the united states emerged on the heels of the abolition of slavery it seems we have at some point forgotten the main aim it was put in place for... and even so, we see that extensive without oversight, people running the systems aren’t doing the right thing.
- mc32 6y agoAre you saying that this is only an effort in the US? I’d imagine this kind of movement would want wider reform?
- perfmode 6y ago“While the United States represents about 4.4 percent of the world's population, it houses around 22 percent of the world's prisoners.” The movement begins in the United States, but it is ultimately a global humanitarian concern. Restorative justice ultimately is a paradigm shift in the way we relate to each other as human beings. To realize such a vision, we start where we are, and put one foot in front the other.
- kgin 6y agoI imagine work on that problem will be ongoing long after it’s been figured out for everyone else. Definitely shouldn’t be a prerequisite to starting on the easier situations.
- nickff 6y agoSaying "we'll figure it out as we go" is not very convincing to skeptics. Prisons are not a startup that should rapidly pivot, or 'fail-fast'. Why not just focus on a more limited set of objectives, which can be achieved via currently-known means?
- tonystubblebine 6y agoWasn't I clear about limited early objectives? Piece by piece over the course of a hundred years. It's not fail fast. The early pieces are pretty well known and not particularly controversial.
- nickff 6y agoFraming something as a vague hundred year struggle makes it seem both unrealistic and unachievable. It's usually better to set a more limited target, then after you succeed and garner credibility, you propose a new goal. You might think that I am quibbling about marketing, but there's a real chance you never get off the ground with the grand scheme, or your first step fails. The 'big ideas' are often very popular with adherents, and ignored by everyone else.
- prepend 6y ago“move quickly and murder things” As a fan of iterations in software development it’s irked me as some of the language has been picked up in the “real world.” Moving fast and breaking things and minimum viable products only work if you’re reliably iterating and changing. It’s not a license to suck and procrastinate and only do fun things and assume someone will figure it out afterwards. I worked with a colleague who had this cargo cult mentality to projects where ve would come in, say crazy stuff, promise everything, hire a random contractor and then move on. Ve called verself a “change agent” but never really changed anything other than the air in the room.
- clawedjird 6y agoWhy do you think mobsters or human traffickers are driven by malice? Those occupations, if you can call them that, have clear economic and political incentives supporting their existence. If you want to stop people from becoming mobsters or human traffickers, I think it would make sense to create a political and economic system that reduces or eliminates those incentives. People calling for restorative justice generally aren’t looking to simply reproduce the status quo without prisons.
- jpxw 6y agoSome people are just bad. There’s no economic reason for someone to rape and kill a child.
- shitgoose 6y agoOr torch Wendy's.
- klyrs 6y agoUnfortunately, I'd say that there might be economic incentives to kill children. When people are extremely poor, children are expensive. When a single parent is working multiple minimum-wage jobs, the kids are going to be neglected. Neglected kids act out more. Frustration gets pent up, the impossibility of the situation looms; a hefty medical bill or a high-needs disability... I think it's actually pretty normal for parents to fantasize about killing their children... but when times get extra tough... grim. Healthcare and UBI starting at childbirth would go a long way to reducing that incentive. Economic incentive for rape... I can't think of an argument. On the other hand, trafficking is extremely lucrative. But, tragically, child molesters are frequently victims themselves. I can't help but think that a robust mental health care system could go a long ways towards breaking that cycle.