4 ms·
But you're choosing a definition of the world that's too narrow -- "if you've already decided to go to Walmart then Walmart is the only store that can sell at W
by Spivak 6y ago
But you're choosing a definition of the world that's too narrow -- "if you've already decided to go to Walmart then Walmart is the only store that can sell at Walmart."
Why isn't "the world" the smartphone market where there are plenty of options?
- untog 6y ago> Why isn't "the world" the smartphone market where there are plenty of options? At a certain point in debates like this everyone ends up over-examining analogies to a point where it isn't useful. To be a useful parallel you'd need a world where you can only buy two types of car and each one only lets you go to one type of shopping mall, or something like that. My point is, that isn't how either the real world works or how smartphone app stores work, so it's a debate over nothing.
- MattRix 6y agoBecause an iPhone is not the App Store. This seems fairly obvious? "the definition of world is too narrow" is a pretty weak argument.
- veilrap 6y agoI buy an iPhone, knowing what App Store I'm getting. I don't see the issue, I chose to buy into this ecosystem.
- mortenjorck 6y ago> plenty of options There are two options, and one of them is provided free of charge by the world's largest advertising company. The state of the smartphone OS market is so wildly different from the general-merchandise retail market as to render any comparisons meaningless.
- szhu 6y agoNot only are there only two options, there is a high entry fee to each option, and you can only choose one at a time even if you wanted to pay this entry fee twice. What percent of consumers are willing to carry two phones in their pockets? So you can compare this to if you could only buy things at two different stores, each store has a hefty membership fee, and you were effectively locked into your decision for at least a year at a time.
- shaftway 6y agoI think the underlying sentiment is that you've bought the device, so you should be able to do whatever you want with it. And there's no technical reason that your choice of device should preclude other stores. For a more meatspace example let's say you own a car with full self-driving capabilities. Now, the manufacturer of that car also runs a chain of grocery stores. It would be problematic if the car refused to drive too a different store. "If you've already to decided to buy a Walmart car then Walmart is the only store that you can go to."
- SJetKaran 6y agowell put
- thebean11 6y agoThere are essentially two options for smartphones, for tablets it's closer to one. Remember when Microsoft got in trouble for bundling Internet Explorer in Windows? Seems quaint compared to what Apple is doing now.