4 ms·
> I'm saying that if a country is going to try to hold you back by limiting your access to technology, you just develop your own. Yes but this would take a ver
by zozbot234 6y ago
> I'm saying that if a country is going to try to hold you back by limiting your access to technology, you just develop your own.
Yes but this would take a very long time, so from the OP's "strategic" POV it's just not relevant in the short-to-medium term. The supply chain for reasonably "advanced" electronics (the sorts you'll need if you want a usable 4G/5G mobile network, etc.) is extremely complex and any single country would be at a disadvantage if they tried to develop every part of it domestically. Plus China would also have plenty of catch up to reach state-of-the-art tech.
- tartoran 6y agoPlus China went all in with this, Im thinking a lot of western countries would now be a lot more vigilent about copyright theft. China has been good at making imitations and improving on them due to their low labor cost and high production capacity. Once left on their own devices they’d inevitably screw up somewhere and being how top down they’re being governed they would be a lot less nimble IMO. But let’s see
- staycoolboy 6y ago> Yes but this would take a very long time, I don't think this argument works in 2020. There are dozens of fabs in China on line and coming on line. Sure, fabs are expensive: $5B for 7nm fab, plus what, a billion more for talent? China is throwing trillions at this. The other claim implicit in this argument is that China isn't smart enough, like there's a monopoly of fab engineers: only the smart ones live in the US and work for Intel and AMD. That is nonsense bordering on racism (chinese are too dumb to compete). The rest of the supply chain: sort, test, packaging, assembly... is trivial by comparison. And Singapore does almost all of this for Intel due to lax environmental regulations: die are shipped from the US fabs in Oregon, Santa Clara and Arizona to Singapore for the final steps before being shipped back for sale. Guess where all of that post-manufacturing machinery comes from? Yup: China. Even the test equipment. It's almost like most of the people on this thread don't realize china makes their own CPUs, chipsets, and motherboards that we never even see or hear about unless you go to ISSCC, HotChips, or Embedded World. Stroll through here looking at wafer size and technology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabrication_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabricat... EDIT: edited for snark and clarity.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWe've been outsourcing all kinds of low and high tech manufacturing to China for decades. Is it a surprise that there are two or three generations of people there who learned the ins and outs of advanced technologies, some of who eventually moved from building to designing their own?
- NonEUCitizen 6y agoWe've seen from the past few years of AMD vs Intel that the smart fab engineers don't live in the US and don't work for AMD or Intel. They live in Hsinchu (and have AMD as a customer). "The other claim implicit in this argument is that China isn't smart enough, like there's a monopoly of fab engineers: only the smart ones live in the US and work for Intel and AMD. That is nonsense bordering on racism (chinese are too dumb to compete)."
- ladyanita22 6y agoThe GDP of China is 15.27 trillion dollars. I'm pretty sure they're not throwing as much money as you think they are.