4 ms·
> If you don't like Apple's platform or business practices, don't use it. This isn't an option! There are no alternatives. Most people do computing on their sm
by echelon 6y ago
> If you don't like Apple's platform or business practices, don't use it.
This isn't an option! There are no alternatives. Most people do computing on their smartphones today. Apple has prevented web from being a first-class native construct on their devices. There's no technical reason web couldn't have a native-like experience with native windowing, sensor access, persistence, multithreading, and WASM speed. Google and Apple just don't like that software distribution idea because the gravy train they have set up is so sweet.
> All the users and developers are there by choice.
I strongly beg to differ.
> Their alternatives were worse.
Thanks largely to Apple.
> Do I want world's governments coming in and imposing more terms on these markets? No.
Thousands of us do.
The answer is a robust web distribution model where web gains native capabilities (and sandboxing). First class web apps would be portable between Apple and Google and there would be zero gatekeeping tax or threat of removal for doing something either company doesn't like.
Mozilla needs to get on this. And we need to harp on our legislators to make it happen. It's how all of this should have evolved in the first place.
Think about all the wasted human and innovation capital it takes to implement the same app twice for two different platforms! It is so incredibly expensive to maintain two wholly different apps. And then they have the gall to take 30% on top. The real cost is far steeper.
I'm not mad. I'm enraged. It's such a waste and we should be building more innovation instead of jumping through hoops.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Their alternatives were worse. Thanks largely to Apple. I don’t recall anyone willing to take on the mobile networks in the US other than Apple. HP/Dell/Microsoft/Palm/Blackberry were all willing to let mobile networks interfere with the device and lock them to various networks.
- jonny_eh 6y ago> Google and Apple just don't like that software distribution idea because the gravy train they have set up is so sweet https://web.dev/using-a-pwa-in-your-android-app/ https://web.dev/using-a-pwa-in-your-android-app/
- millstone 6y agoWeb technologies and software distribution are separate. Heavily-curated app stores may arise on the web and gain market power. Likewise native apps could be loaded directly from URLs. I strongly disagree that "implementing the same app twice" is wasted effort. Write-once-run-everywhere is a recipe for shitty software. But a native app designed for the platform it runs on can be very high quality. This is why the iPhone succeeded: its software was just so much higher quality than the alternatives at the time. And this is also why the iPhone's original web-app plan (the "sweet solution") failed.
- spideymans 6y ago> All the users and developers are there by choice. > I strongly beg to differ. How? Which users are being forced to use an iPhone? This is a bizarre statement when fully eighty five percent of smartphone users are not on the iPhone.
- hamandcheese 6y agoAnyone who cares about privacy, anyone who bought in to the Apple ecosystem long ago so now the switching cost would be huge, anyone who is non-technical and had their children choose an iPhone for them (i.e. my parents). Also, in the US iPhone has >50% market share.
- mrep 6y agoApples market share in the US is 58% [0] which only leaves you with 42% of the market if you are a developer and don't want to follow apples rules. That's not a good choice. [0]: https://gs.statcounter.com/vendor-market-share/mobile/united-states-of-america https://gs.statcounter.com/vendor-market-share/mobile/united...