4 ms·
My first reaction was "but there's no way Fukushima even gets close to Chernobyl", but then I realized I sound like a nuclear apologist. So I looked up the most
by potatolicious 16y ago
My first reaction was "but there's no way Fukushima even gets close to Chernobyl", but then I realized I sound like a nuclear apologist. So I looked up the most recent news about the plant.
The evacuation zone only covers 20km - and the IAEA just recorded levels of 161 uSv/h in a town that far away. That's 1410 mSv/y, compared to 2.4 mSv/y normal from background radiation. These are levels high enough to cause health effects, and one has to wonder why the government has not extended the evacuation radius if there's proof that health-affecting levels of radiation has gotten that far into the general environment. It seems like the US NRC's recommendations are wiser than the Japanese government's. That's a disturbing thought.
I really wonder how history will look back upon this - a well-executed response to a unforeseen disaster in the most difficult of circumstances, or an example of governmental coverup exposing civilians to unnecessary danger?
- lispm 16y agoThe US embassy in Tokyo gives the advice to leave the area of 80km around Fukushima or at least stay indoors. One has to understand that Chernobyl is different. Only one of four running reactors had problems: a core meltdown, an explosion and the burning graphite moderator. Fukushima is different, but possibly worse: four running reactors are involved. Two non-running reactors have cooling problems, too. Full electricity blackout over several days for ALL reactors. Spent fuel stored in seven pools and one dry storage: 1760 tons of spent fuel. The pools without adequate cooling were running dry. The spent fuel is damaged. Smoke escaping. Buildings exploding. Cooling water just sprayed over the buildings... More than one partial meltdown highly likely. Much higher population density. MOX fuel with Plutonium involved. The Ukraine was actually running some of the Chernobyl reactors years after the accident there. I won't expect that any of the Fukushima reactors will run again. Several of them will need some kind of primitive containment to prevent that radiation or radioactive material will escape. Working on that site will be very dangerous for several years... Chernobyl needed several hundred thousand 'liquidators' to work on the single damaged reactor and to clean the surrounding cities and streets. In the hot zone of Chernobyl the liquidators went in with a lead protection and got the radiation dose of a life in a few minutes. In the Fukushima plant there will be several areas with extremely high radiation. From the spent fuel pools to the reactor core areas. This is one huge fucking catastrophe.
- listrophy 16y agoI'm guessing 161 uSv/h is a local maximum, and that over the course of the upcoming year, that number is expected to dramatically fall. I suggest multiplying 161 uSv/h by 24h to see the daily effect: 3.86 mSv/day. That's not too bad, as long as it starts dropping.
- lispm 16y agoThis would be 1408 mSv/year. In Germany it is requested that people have to leave areas with radiation above 100mSv/year for at least a year. See 4.4.5 at: http://www.verwaltungsvorschriften-im-internet.de/bsvwvbund_27102008_RSII51593013.htm#ivz15 http://www.verwaltungsvorschriften-im-internet.de/bsvwvbund_...
- potatolicious 16y agoNo doubt the 161 uSv/h figure will drop as the plant becomes more contained, and it's unlikely sticking around for a full year will net you the full 1400 mSv. That being said, right now we're looking at 3.86 mSv/d, which in and of itself is not a number to scoff at, and is well above dose limits, conservative as they are. This is considerably different than when people were panicking over 50 uSv/d. When you are in an area that exceeds the yearly dose limit in a single day, it seems like evacuation is prudent. The fact that the government hasn't widened the evacuation area despite rising ambient radiation is concerning.
- hallmark 16y agoThe radiation levels are getting a lot of public scrutiny - because the information is public. I don't see how this compares to a Chernobyl-style government coverup.
- potatolicious 16y agoThe numbers are IAEA numbers - not released by TEPCO or the Japanese government. Certainly this isn't on the order of a Soviet-era coverup, but from the appearance right now information is as open as it perhaps ought to be, and preventative/remedial action not as aggressive as might be justified. It's hard to say in this giant void of information, which is why I wonder how this will be viewed in time.
- OpieCunningham 16y agoI really wonder how history will look back upon this - a well-executed response to a unforeseen disaster in the most difficult of circumstances, or an example of governmental coverup exposing civilians to unnecessary danger? There's a lot of gray area between those two outcomes: - a well-executed, but ultimately human error prone response - an unforeseen, but foreseeable disaster - a universal example of government/large organization incompetence - normal and continuously shifting, dangerous conditions To me these are the underlying issues with the march towards more nuclear energy facilities: unavoidable human error, mechanical error, electrical error, design error, environmental events, etc. The safest plant in the world could easily turn into a situation worse than Chernobyl when concurrent unforeseeable situations manifest. That's the problem with manipulating extraordinarily dangerous material. Ultimately, Fukushima will likely be viewed through the lens of history in the way most things are: as a construct of those who are holding the lens.
- PaulHoule 16y agoThe #1 route that populations get exposed to I-131 is through the food supply. Grass plants soak up I-131 from the soil, and cows concentrate the I-131 in milk. Drink the milk, and you can get a very high concentration of I-131. The half-life of I-131 is 9 days, so you don't even need to throw the milk away. Just make cheese out of it and let it sit for a few months. Because I-131 is the most immediate radiological threat, the 1410 mSv/y number is incredibly pessimistic... That exposure is definitely going to go down. Note the I-131 is decaying in both the environment and in the fuel rods, so the danger of any kind of further releases is dropping over time. Note that parts of the area have been devastated by the Tsunami... Some people might not have any shelter for "shelter in place" to work. Over longer periods of time, radio-cesium is going to be more of a concern, but the first point of order is to protect people from I-131. Another interesting thing about her story, BTW, is the mention of cardiovascular problems. Based on anecdotal accounts I've seen of people who get large radiation doses, the danger of cardiovascular damage may be worse than the danger of cancer.