5 ms·
This is a great example of why this is a tricky area to legislate. On the one hand it seems crazy that Basecamp’s business model should be significantly impede
by zepto 6y ago
This is a great example of why this is a tricky area to legislate.
On the one hand it seems crazy that Basecamp’s business model should be significantly impeded by Apple’s rules.
On the other hand, we need some way to prevent people from just installing their own platforms.
Given their track record, I don’t expect a gaming platform from Facebook to be benign.
But let’s assume it is.
If Facebook can install its own gaming App Store, so can anyone else.
And that opens the door to all manner of bad actors who distribute gaming platforms aimed at addicting kids, extracting personal information, etc.
- fsociety 6y agoIsn’t the point of the application store to allow people to install their own platforms? It sounds like you are arguing that Apple shouldn’t allow apps which compete with their own offerings.
- zepto 6y agoNo - I’m arguing that Apple is a platform which is sold as a safe and curated environment. They therefore should be allowed to prevent stores which seek to circumvent that curation. Many customers want a closed, managed platform. For those who want an open platform, one is available in the form of Android. Let’s stop trying to take that choice away.
- happymellon 6y agoAndroid isn't an open environment. There are many restrictions imposed on software installed outside of their Play Store.
- zepto 6y agoThen why are the complaints only about Apple? If we want openness then we need to say exactly what it means. Does it mean all platforms that allow software installation must not prevent arbitrary code from being installed? Does it mean all hardware must permit alternative operating systems to be installed. This is my preferred option because it would open the door for a genuinely open platform to be developed by the community rather than maintaining the power of the giant corporations.
- happymellon 6y agoI would assume because Facebook was rejected by Apple, not Google. But it's also not even at the same scale, as far as I understand Google Android limits background activity of side loaded apps. Android is open source and so handset makes can code exceptions in such as Samsung and the Samsung store, Amazon and the Amazon store or Huawei and the Huawei store. If you wanted to replace the preloaded Android with a custom ROM for your own store, you can (based on bootloader locking). Apple says fuck you.
- zepto 6y agoWhy don’t we see an open Android ecosystem then with a superior environment for developers then? If it’s so easy to make a better store, you’d think someone would have made it for Android.
- happymellon 6y agoWe are. Check out the Pinephone.
- zepto 6y agoVery cool. I wasn’t aware of this. I wish more energy went into ‘Support projects like PinePhone’ rather than legislate against Apple.
- rydre 6y agoPeople should be allowed to install other installation platforms. This needs to be made into the law. Consoles are a different thing, in their case, they must be made to allow cross play/communication between other consoles if the game developer wishes to integrate the functionality. If consoles turn into a general purpose compute thing, then they must be made mandatory like that too. Remove the network effects that ruin innovation and keep society behind. Compete on merit. If Apple is so sure that they are providing consumers with the best experience, why do they not allow competitors and make it fair? Make it mandatory that a developer has to support Apple payment method, fine, but don't add anti competitive clauses like you shouldn't tell the consumer that you can get the app 30% if you pay with PayPal/Stripe etc instead of paying with Apple. Then look at what the consumer picks. Is Apple's quality assurance really worth that much? Give free markets a chance, and we'll find out. 10 years are enough to make a profit, innovate and open up. Stop using network effects/lock in as your moat, use your innovation to stay ahead.
- zepto 6y agoWhat’s wrong with Android? Another good option would be to force vendors to allow consumer to install any operating system they chose, so people could install Android or Facebook os on Apple hardware. Essentially boot camp for iPhone. This would be great for software freedom since it would have to apply across the board to Android vendors too. Forcing Apple to make their operating system work the way you want them to is like forced speech or forced labor, and is taking away a choice consumers clearly want. It also simply doesn’t open the door for real innovation in the space. If we are going to solve this problem, let’s do it for real. It’s also worth pointing out that if you force Apple to allow alternate stores, those stores will be owned by Google and Amazon. They will not compete on ‘innovation’. They will compete on advertising reach. Let’s be real. If you are advocating for alternate stores to be forced on iOS, you simply arguing for Amazon and Google and Facebook‘s competitive interests while doing nothing to constrain their various anticompetitive tendencies.
- gamblor956 6y agoForcing Apple to make their operating system work the way you want them to is like forced speech or forced labor, Legally, it's nothing even remotely like forced speech or forced labor. It's simply the application of neutral laws intended to foster commercial activity by prohibiting anticompetitive activity, such as that engaged in by Apple in running its app store.
- lacker 6y agoIf operating systems never let other platforms be built on top of them, we would never have had the web browser.
- zepto 6y agoSure, but if operating systems were really that stifling, someone would have built one that was open. Which is exactly what happened. There is no need to force Apple to build what you want when we have alternatives.
- Jyaif 6y agoThere is no way this 30% tax will last forever, so might as well make the future happen a little faster by forcing Apple to open up the platform.
- zepto 6y agoForcing them to open the platform is just a way to damage Apple and give Google a competitive advantage. It has nothing to do with the 30%, which for some reason nobody complains about on the Play store, and also for some reason Google doesn’t compete by reducing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Jyaif 6y agoFirst of all, it could be argued that it would actually be beneficial for Apple to give up on their 30% because it would make iOS much harder to dethrone, which in the long run is much more valuable than cash. Secondly, nobody complains on the 30% Play store tax because you can easily dodge it, see for instance... Apple Music.
- zepto 6y agoNetflix dodged the Apple 30% tax in the same way Apple dodges the Google play tax. This clearly cannot be the reason nobody complains about it. And of course a lot of people are not complaining about the commission on subscriptions, but the commission on purchases.
- take_a_breath 6y ago==On the other hand, we need some way to prevent people from just installing their own platforms.== Is this inherently true? Isn't it just another form of market competition?
- zepto 6y agoWe need both competition, and the ability to install platforms where we delegate trust to the platform owner. Forcing platforms to allow other platforms on top means we can no longer delegate trust. We might be able to solve this by preventing hardware to be locked to a specific OS. That way we can enable platform completion without removing the ability to delegate trust.
- gowld 6y agoDoes apple ban addictive games? Nope https://apps.apple.com/us/app/fortnite/id1261357853 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/fortnite/id1261357853
- DeonPenny 6y agoThat shouldn't be up to Apple. Imagine if oogle said that about Apple ads and apple's websites.
- zepto 6y agoI don’t have to imagine it. Google actually does decide on whose ads they accept and what websites show up in search. If you don’t play by their rules they won’t publish your ads.
- ytpete 6y agoGoogle doesn't block ads for competing products though. Nor does it prevent competing products from being listed in its search engine. That's the analogy here - no one is saying Apple's app store shouldn't be allowed to have _any_ standards, just that their rules shouldn't be anticompetitive.
- happymellon 6y agoThat's strange, I was pretty sure that I could use Duck Duck Go in Chrome.