4 ms·
Cash is already going away in some countries. Almost nobody pays for anything with cash in the UK anymore.
by chrisseaton 6y ago
Cash is already going away in some countries.
Almost nobody pays for anything with cash in the UK anymore.
- duncanawoods 6y agoSmall shops with card fees is the last remaining hold out for me. Payment systems should be nationalised and run by a country's central bank. It's a very boring infrastructure equivalent to roads. There shouldn't be a private company taxing every single transaction someone makes. Do that and the small stores can drop the fees.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoI’m not sure I see your logic here. Do you think the payment networks will be cheaper to operate if they’re run by the government? Or would you prefer an actual tax to the fees you’re comparing to taxes? Do you expect banks would drop their transaction fees? Do you think payment gateways would drop their fees? Do you think payment terminals would become free, and their networks free to use?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- artifact_44 6y agoYeah, that is the purpose of a functional government.
- mcv 6y agoBanks have already dropped their transaction fees. Simple bank transactions in the EU are free. iDeal payment is either free or costs about 25 cents.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoIn the EU it’s illegal for a merchant to charge a different price based on payment method (iirc), but merchants are most certainly still charged transaction fees for card payments. SEPA transfers still incur fees too. There is a huge number of service providers involved in every single card payment, and that service infrastructure only exists because people pay to use it. It absolutely wouldn’t be strange for the 2-3% fee a merchant is charged for processing a transaction to be divided up between more than 10 service providers.
- mcv 6y ago> "In the EU it’s illegal for a merchant to charge a different price based on payment method" I really don't think that's true; there are plenty of merchants who do still charge different prices based on payment method. But there are also many who voluntarily don't, because the actual cost is negligible and better than the alternatives. Regular bank transfers of various kinds between consumers, including iDeal internet payments, as far as I can tell, have no fees at all. Cash withdrawals across different currencies may incur fees, but I've never seen fees in regular Euro cash withdrawals. Nobody here is charging 2-3% except when credit cards are involved.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoTurns out it is true. https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/shopping/pricing-payments/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/shopping/pri... > Traders in the EU are not allowed to charge you extra for using your credit or debit card. Regarding this: > Nobody here is charging 2-3% except when credit cards are involved. The service provider that provides the payment terminals merchants use will be charging the merchants between 1-2%, often with a per transaction fee on top of that. I’m not 100% sure how service providers in the EU bundle things, but intercharge fees are usually charged on top of that again. Even though the EU caps interchange fees, merchants will very easily be incurring above 2% in fees even for non-credit card transactions. The EU’s cap on interchange fees for card not present transactions is barely below standard market rates, so EU merchants will be paying about the same as everybody else for those.
- netsharc 6y agoNot OP, but I'd dislike it if everything is run by private corporations. Already our communication methods are like that (FB Messenger, WhatsApp, Zoom, Google Hangduomeetout, Twitter), and these companies can just say "You violated our TOS, get out!", or they censor things depending on who's friends with them (for example you can't send piratebay links on FB Messenger because "this website is a security risk to your computer", but the real reason is probably Hollywood lobbying). Imagine if you write bad stuff about China, and the banks in your country who have a commercial interest to expand to China gets a memo "AmericanChopper is in our embargo list, if a bank does business with him they will be embargoed from China". (I say China, but the US does this, and no bank worldwide would dare touch anyone in the US's embargo list, for example Putin's friends. At least when the US does it, they have good reasoning, imagine if China does it and makes up some bullshit against you, and the banks would just follow because... money). Sweden has a pilot project for a digtal currency: https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/02/20/906146/sweden-riksbank-ekrona-blockchain/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/02/20/906146/sweden-ri... , I wonder how it's going.
- chrisseaton 6y agoThey aren't 'taxing' it - they're charging for a service rendered, which is a valuable service to me so I'm fine with it.
- CydeWeys 6y agoAre you sure that applies generally, and not just to you and people like you?
- chrisseaton 6y agoI don't live in the South East and I'm not in a tech bubble, if that's what you mean.
- rutthenut 6y agoI am in the South and use cash quite frequently, as do many other people I see or know. I think your definition of 'almost nobody' may be more than you appreciate. >> Almost nobody pays for anything with cash in the UK anymore
- reaperducer 6y agoI think he's talking about his own bubble. I see people in the UK using cash all the time. Granted, I haven't been there in six months because of the virus, but I watch current British television every couple of days, and I still see people using cash.
- mcv 6y agoThe only people I pay with cash are my cleaner and my son's allowance. And even for the allowance I'm thinking of just getting him a bank account instead. My favourite cheese shop used to only accept cash, but the owner retired. Beyond that, the only thing I need cash for is to give to homeless people. I think they're the main group losing out due to the switch to electronic payment; the can't afford the equipment for it.
- ddalex 6y agoThe pan handlers in London have touch oay machines connected to their phone, you can just contact less ly give money. The upside is that the excuse "I have no change" , no longer works.
- Silhouette 6y agoAlmost nobody pays for anything with cash in the UK anymore. I think this is an illusion. Sure, if you're going into almost any shop it will accept other payment methods and most people will use them, particularly at the moment. Similarly, ordering anything online isn't likely to be cash-on-delivery. However, there are still reasons people might need or prefer to pay or be paid in cash, only one of which is "I'm a dodgy tradesman evading tax". For example, we've used a few local services for things like cleaning or gardening. They often like to be paid in cash, at least for the first visit or two, so everyone immediately knows it's all above board. This is common IME even if they might be happy to be paid (or even prefer to be paid) electronically once they get to know you. Is the use of cash declining here? Certainly. Is it negligible? Not even close. Is it still useful or even essential? Sometimes, yes.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> They often like to be paid in cash, at least for the first visit or two, so everyone immediately knows it's all above board. Paying people in cash seems like the exact opposite of an indicator of everything being above board.
- Silhouette 6y agoNot really. It's in your hand, right now. It can't be disputed later and retrospectively yanked back out of your bank account, or not paid out to you in the first place if you use an intermediary payment service. These are not hypothetical problems. It's also a traditional sign of honesty, and a convenient way for someone who has provided very good service to be tipped without making a big deal of it ("Keep the change"), and both of those things can be important in these kinds of situations.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> It's also a traditional sign of honesty Well I accept your experience, but in my experience asking for cash is a traditional sign of dishonesty and tax evasion. Why do you think they always offer a hushed discount for cash? A professional tradesman invoices after and then accepts a bank transfer. Asking for a wad of banknotes is grubby.