7 ms·
Dark Matter Experiment Finds Unexplained Signal
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- __m 6y agoThey uploaded the signal https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tech-historian 6y ago"Researchers say there are three possible explanations for the anomalous data. One is mundane. Two would revolutionize physics." The "mundane explanation" is contamination from inside the experiment. Hopefully it's not that!
- enkid 6y agoBut realistically it's probably the mundane explanation, just like the faster than light travel a few years ago.
- lisper 6y agoYep. You almost don't even have to look at the details. Any time you see a headline that says some experimental result "could revolutionize physics" the odds will be very much with you if bet against.
- _jal 6y agoTo be fair, the line works much better than "is probably noise".
- lou1306 6y agoQuasars, pulsars, and the Cosmic Microwave Background all started as unexplainable experimental data: I know the most likely explaination is the mundane one, but what if it is not?
- HPsquared 6y agoThose famous cases are the exception that proves the rule.
- margalabargala 6y agoIn what way do they prove the rule? They fact that these exceptions exist prove the rule is no rule, but just a guideline.
- HPsquared 6y agoThe "rule" being that the vast majority of unexplained results are due to experimental error or noise. The existence of a few famous examples that were indeed new science, narrows the statement from "all unexplained results" to just "the vast majority".
- lisper 6y agoYes, that's true. The problem is that the more our knowledge converges on the actual truth, the less likely new discoveries become. It has been 50 years or so since the last really new thing was discovered in particle physics despite heroic efforts. The more time goes by, the more likely it is that this is because the next breakthrough is simply beyond our reach.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoUm, Higgs Boson? Now, true, it was expected rather than a surprise. But it was still a discovery.
- at_a_remove 6y ago
- BurningFrog 6y agoYeah, if it was almost any other branch of science, I'd half expect new revolutionary findings. But in physics, mundanity wins.
- lisper 6y agoThere's a reason for this, and it reveals a very deep truth about our universe: at root, the laws of nature are simple. All of the interesting complexity is emergent. That's the reason that, in terms of the potential for producing an endless stream of new discoveries, physics is a drier well than other fields of science.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ma8ee 6y agoWe don’t know that. It might as well be that the laws we know just are good simple approximations to something much more complex.
- BurningFrog 6y agoOne way to think about it is that elementary particles are so extremely small that they can't have that much complexity. Entirely unprovable intuitive reasoning, I know. But I think there is something to it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- RhysU 6y agoIf it is complex but can be described simply, Ockham's Razor says it is simple.
- Ma8ee 6y agoNo, that is a misunderstanding of Ockham’s razor. If a simpler explanation explains all known phenomena, then of course, choose the simpler explanation. But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t any unknown phenomena that the simpler explanation can’t explain that forces us to choose a more complicated explanation later. Ockham’s razor doesn’t say anything about reality. It only says anything about which model of reality we should choose given a set of known phenomena.
- detritus 6y agoExactly what I thought when I read that it was in Italy. I mentally rolled my eyes and thought "here we go again". - (My partner's from Italy and I spend at least a month there each year, so I hope I don't come across as being entirely needlessly snarky saying the above! :) )
- sgdpk 6y agoOr even the Digamma [1] signal that appeared independently at the same time in two experiments at CERN. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/750_GeV_diphoton_excess https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/750_GeV_diphoton_excess
- credit_guy 6y agoAnd the faster than light travel was "discovered" at the same lab, Grand Sasso National Laboratory.
- elfchief 6y agoTo be fair, they didn't actually think they'd discovered faster than light travel. They basically went "uhhhh, we double-checked everything and our numbers work out but we're pretty sure this isn't faster than light; here's our paper, can someone please point out wtf we screwed up?
- simcop2387 6y agoAnd the fun part of that one is that all the math, data, etc. all lined up to say that. Their analysis of the data was correct, and it turned out to be an equipment issue. A single incorrectly installed fiber optic cable, and an out of spec clock. It wasn't even a bad cable, just not inserted completely correctly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster-than-light_neutrino_anomaly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster-than-light_neutrino_ano... EDIT: A much better detailed analysis of the failure including pictures of the cable, https://profmattstrassler.com/articles-and-posts/particle-physics-basics/neutrinos/neutrinos-faster-than-light/opera-what-went-wrong/ https://profmattstrassler.com/articles-and-posts/particle-ph...
- credit_guy 6y agoThis is a bit of revisionist history. The way the "discovery" was announced was slightly subdued, they called it an "anomaly", and added the caveats that it could be due to some errors, but they also stated that the "deviation of the neutrino velocity from c would be a striking result pointing to new physics in the neutrino sector". So pretty much, we are not 100% sure, but if this is correct, this is revolutionary. That's not exactly the tone of someone who asks the larger community to assist with a debugging exercise. And the recent announcement repeats the same pattern. "This could be due to some equipment malfunction, but if not, then this is big".
- raverbashing 6y agoThe XENON experiment is located at Grand Sasso but it is a collaboration between multiple laboratories It wasn't a single group looking at those results
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ISL 6y agoWhen you're in this game long enough, you realize that the thing you want most is not to be wrong. Experimental physics (and every experimental/field branch of science) is a search for what is true. If the dark matter is axions, that's great. If it isn't, that is okay, too. The key problem is that we don't know what gives rise to the phenomena that have led us to believe that dark matter exists. The thing we should hope for and aspire to, from every experimental endeavor, is a complete and accurate assessment of uncertainties. A complete assessment is only ever a goal, as the "unknown unknowns" are intrinsically difficult to discover; barring that, one can always list and accurately assess all of the known uncertainties. It is exciting every time a new or unexpected signal appears in a precision experiment -- perhaps today is the day a great truth is exposed -- but the thing we should always hope for is not an exciting result but, rather, a reliable one.
- tech-historian 6y agoAbsolutely. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> When you're in this game long enough, you realize that the thing you want most is not to be wrong. I suppose most of us are commenting from the outside perspective, where the thing you want most is a warp drive - so any revolution in understanding of the universe gives hope that we'll be able to do things we now consider impossible.
- 7thaccount 6y agoI think you've nailed it. All we really want is to find out we can do warp drive or build a Stargate. I'm only partly joking.
- pacala 6y agoResearchers say there are three possible explanations for the anomalous data. One is mundane, 99.98%. Two would revolutionize physics, 0.01% and 0.01%.
- snarfy 6y agoWith tritium's short half-life, it seems like it could be ruled out by simply waiting.
- SaberTail 6y agoTritium is actually being continuously produced by cosmic rays smashing up atoms in the detector. That's why these experiments are buried deep in mines, but even the small amount that get through the earth can cause problems in a sensitive detector. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0927650517301895 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09276...
- ISL 6y agoTritium's half-life is 12.5 yr. While I haven't looked up the statistical significance of the 53 excess events, it would take at most six half-lives to hammer that to below one. Sometimes waiting works (in the absence of any cosmogenics or radionuclide support for the background), but a good assay and background model is generally much faster.
- jovial_cavalier 6y agoVery cool. Another nothing burger anomaly being reported on by a journalist who desperately wants to push the narrative that it will change the entire field so you will click on the article. I've gotta set up filters for "new particle", "unexplained signal," and "potential breakthrough."
- ojnabieoot 6y agoWolchover is a great scientific journalist and I can't think of a less clickbait-y headline than the one provided. Please set up the filters and take your ignorant bitterness elsewhere.
- jovial_cavalier 6y agoGreat X Journalist is an oxymoron. Journalism has no art to it. It's a simple algorithm > find a story you can contort into something interesting > interview an "expert" for two hours so you can quote mine one sentence about how remarkable the story is > Publish bullshit article, wait for ad revenue Maybe this story isn't bullshit, but when your only quote is from a guy who -- by your own admission -- was uninvolved with the research, and all he has to say is "this could maybe be significant," you don't really have a story, do you? It's not Wolchover that I object to, it's the incentives that are set up to make her subtly overstate the importance of anything she has to cover (disclaimer: I don't know any of her other work). 95% of journalism should be book-keeping. Dryly reporting the quantitative results of research. The fact that she has a quote like that suggests to me that she was digging to make it something more. I don't think that's her fault; it's just her job. But I have to call it out when I perceive it.
- vdersar1 6y agoyou do know that quanta is run by a non-profit. if you want book-keeping go to arXiv. pretty pathetic that you're this upset
- praveen9920 6y agoExperimental physicists journey is similar to startup founder They have to figure out which "idea" they want to commit for a very long time. They have to convince a rich person/org to fund their expensive experiment. Work hard to get things right. Have patience until you get it right. Success will give you recognition and money and in some cases probably Nobel (being a unicorn). Failure will get you lot of learnings and probably some recognition too ( for proving something wrong). Unfortunately, there is one more state, being in limbo and not going anywhere. As long as you are having fun in what you do, it is worth it. Note: I am not an experimental physicist.
- Herrin 6y agoI was an experimental physicist, and I'd say that's a reasonable comparison to make. The time scales are much longer, unfortunately. Instead of taking one or two years to get a company off the ground, it can be more like five for an experiment[1]. I'd attribute this to slower iteration. You end up throwing away or rebuilding a lot of physical things, many of them bespoke, on the way to a working apparatus. Also, the compensation is much worse for experimental physics. For he first decade of your career, you work as a grad student, then a post-doc, for slightly above poverty wages. This does have the advantage of meaning you work with very motivated people, but you're giving up a lot for that. [1] The XENON experiments from the article (10, 100, and now 1 Tonne) have been developed over about 15 years, for example
- torbjorn 6y agoAm I the only one left with a befuddled feeling of missing context when it comes to particle physics? Like what does it mean for dark matter to be axions? "What's a quark?", Etc. I feel like I have a context for understanding electrons and protons. I have read A Brief History of Time. What do I read next in order to have this article not sound like mumbo jumbo?
- waterhouse 6y agoThe first four paragraphs of the Wikipedia page on quarks seem decent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quark I hadn't heard of axions before, but https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axion and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peccei%E2%80%93Quinn_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peccei%E2%80%93Quinn_theory seem to be a starting point.
- zarmin 6y agoSean Carroll's Great Course on Particle Physics (and his other ones) is a really great introduction. edit: Higgs Boson, Dark Matter/Energy, Time https://www.thegreatcourses.com/professors/sean-carroll/ https://www.thegreatcourses.com/professors/sean-carroll/
- vl 6y agoI can’t recommend Feynman’s “QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter” highly enough. It gives description of Quantum Mechanics in simple terms (while math is oversimplified for my taste, still better than other books, where math is too hard). https://www.amazon.com/QED-Strange-Princeton-Science-Library/dp/0691164096 https://www.amazon.com/QED-Strange-Princeton-Science-Library...