3 ms·
I can only speak for myself, but I have had a number of interactions with the review team, and I have always ended up communicating with a human; although they
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
I can only speak for myself, but I have had a number of interactions with the review team, and I have always ended up communicating with a human; although they would often paste “talking points” into their replies.
Because of the nature of a couple of my apps, I’ve had them bounced for “providing commonly available services” (i.e. competing with OS tools). In each instance, I have appealed, citing some unique features, and have prevailed.
I think that reviewers have a number of “1-button” responses, provided by some kind of dashboard, in order to ensure a narrative is maintained. This is actually common for many customer interaction scenarios. I don’t like it, but understand why it happens.
I’ll bet that the more heated an exchange gets, the more “canned” these responses become, because...lawyers. He may, in fact, be communicating with a human, who keeps hitting canned response buttons (not much different from ‘bots).
I’ve wondered whether or not folks might use TestFlight for “shadow release.” I have seen app makers use Enterprise in that fashion. I have no idea (or opinion) on whether or not that was the case, here.
I’m not sure I would want to pursue my case in the court of public opinion. It’s a risky gambit, but this chap may feel he has nothing to lose.
EDIT: One thing that I should mention, is that I never have a release in TestFlight for more than a few days. It has a "time bomb"; I think, maybe 60 or 90 days. That means, in order to maintain an app in TF for three years, he'd need to keep re-releasing every couple of months. That speaks to some kind of intent.
- kalleboo 6y agoYeah app review have been surprisingly reasonable to deal with, from the "they seem like humans" point of view. It sounds like OP is dealing with the account fraud department instead
- mrtksn 6y agoYep, I had rejections too and I have always managed come to an understanding with the review team. I even had the reviewer call me to explain why he would reject the app and give me an idea to fix the issue. He even gave me his phone number and working hours so I can call him if I had further questions. It wasn’t a fun process but I like having a human contact on the other side of the things. Sometimes I think, people having issues must be omitting some part of the story because I am not a big-time publisher, I have no privilege but at the same time, I don’t have these problems of ”evil Apple destroying the little guy” sort. "Apple threatens to close my developer account" is a very different situation from Hey's disagreement with the business practices of Apple.
- dgb23 6y agoOne of the nicest interactions I had with customer support was with Apple. It was a younger, very patient and helpful support. At the start I also got canned responses, which was a bit frustrating (because I knew that these won’t help me in the slightest) but then I got real help and it also felt like the support actually wanted to help, which is often not the case in such scenarios. I guess what I wanted to say is that this is what brings value to interacting in any business. You need to be able to listen and talk.
- dbuder 6y agoThey flat out lie and say that a decision was automated when it wasn't, how can you trust these hucksters.
- reaperducer 6y agoI’ve wondered whether or not folks might use TestFlight for “shadow release.” They are. I know a real estate company that distributes its app to its customers that way. I don't know why they do it, but it's annoying not to be able to just download it from the App Store like a normal app.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> I know a real estate company that distributes its app to its customers that way. That's insane. Their brand must be in the toilet. This guy has a "niche" product that is probably only of interest to a few geeks. A real estate company, on the other hand, has a brand that it needs to protect and project. Also, I'll bet they will get to interact with the account fraud department, sooner or later.