4 ms·
I don't think so. I consider computer network traffic a lot different from the "unlocked door" analogy of physical property. Sure, you don't have permission to
by baddox 16y ago
I don't think so. I consider computer network traffic a lot different from the "unlocked door" analogy of physical property. Sure, you don't have permission to enter someone's home just because their door was unlocked or you found a clever way in. However, when you make a request to a web server and it returns a bunch of text that your browser renders as text/graphics, I think it's perfectly okay to change the way that rendering works.
- IgorPartola 16y agoRight. This is like someone parking an unlocked car with a blank title and a full tank of gas on your front lawn and leaving it there for a week.
- baddox 16y agoI don't like any analogy involving actual property, because actual physical property has natural scarcity. When you make a web request to the NYT servers, they are willfully distributing a copy of that content to you. Obviously, you're not allowed to do anything you want with the content (like sell or otherwise redistribute it), but I certainly think you can manipulate it and view it any way you want.
- alphaoverlord 16y agoBut in this case, they are actively trying to "lock" their door. Speaking abstractly, this misalignment of interests has nothing to do with the mechanisms of action. That's like saying the cops can use heat-sensors to look at houses, because thats just electromagnetic signal and you can render it however you want. No invasion of privacy there right?
- baddox 16y agoCops shouldn't use heat sensors without a warrant solely because of the privacy issue. They can certainly look at your house while passing by, which is also just a function of electromagnetic signals. I would argue that since the NYT is willfully delivering you the content of an article and merely instructing your browser to conceal it, that's a far cry from "trying to 'lock' their door." If someone was distributing their username/password or an authorized cookie, or using a server-side exploit to access content, then I think that would constitute a breach of ethics if not law. Basically, my point is that once the NYT willfully transmits data to your computer, you should be able to manipulate it any way you wish, obviously barring any sort of commercial use or redistribution that violates copyright laws. Anyway, it's not that hard to protect data from certain users and make it available to others. That's a design pattern as old as multi-user computer systems/networks.
- tomkarlo 16y agoTrue, but you're consenting to the terms of use of the provider in requesting that content. It's not just "text", it's content you've licensed from them for your use in keeping with a number of legal obligations (part of which, I'm guessing, is to not disable components intended to limit your consumption as a non-subscriber.) So it's not that clear cut. Similarly, you could argue that when someone sends a movie to your home to watch over cable, you could do anything you want with a dvr recording of it. But we know that's not an argument that actually holds any water, legally or ethically.
- baddox 16y agoActually, the US Supreme Court decided in Sony vs. Universal (in 1984) that when someone sends a movie to your home, you do have the right to record it for subsequent (non-commercial) viewings. Merely reading a news article is certainly non-commercial, so by the analogy you proposed I believe this JavaScript workaround is entirely legal.
- tomkarlo 16y agoI'm not sure that would apply here: in that case, you're talking about the right to make a backup copy of an item you've properly licensed, and then retain it only to use under the same terms as that original license. In this case, you're taking content that you haven't paid for, and violating the terms it's distributed under by disabling some portions so you can consume it without paying. I'd argue that's closer to disabling macrovision on a VHS tape so you can make a backup copy of a rental tape to keep for yourself, and I'm pretty sure that's verboten.