4 ms·
I enjoyed this read. It reminds me of a few things I've observed recently: * If you give a little, you will be subject to increased disapproval and if you don'
by renewiltord 6y ago
I enjoyed this read. It reminds me of a few things I've observed recently:
* If you give a little, you will be subject to increased disapproval and if you don't care at all, you'll be subject to distant tut-tutting. Examples: the tech industry faces widespread condemnation for its gender ratio while hedge funds face little - only 1 in every 9 senior hedgies is female[0]. I'm not complaining about the gender ratio condemnation, merely commenting on the difference. Another example is that Bernie Sanders's speech was interrupted by Black Lives Matter protestors. Donald Trump's wasn't.[1]
* Internet commenters frequently remark on how they would pay for good news, yet they prefer reading free low-quality news sources over paid high-quality news sources. Similarly with clickbait vs. informative writing. They share the former, they comment on the former, and they enjoy the former. Effectively, they only pay the former.
* Voters and plans (brought up in the article) are my favourite. You cannot attack someone without a plan but every plan has flaws. Therefore, offering a plan is disincentivized while offering mere ideas is incentivized by people who claim the opposite. I'm glad this was example 1 in the article.
* Internet commenters will frequently be unforgiving of errors corrected. They reward hiding errors and punish honest corrections. No apology is sufficient. Often this manifests as upvotes or likes for those who stick brutishly to their positions while merely abandoning to indifference those honestly convinced. Strictly this is not really only Internet commenters. The fact that Red Cross having to not give away free doughnuts resulted in animosity towards them is a lesson for future players: do not give away anything.
* YC's ill-fated attempt at crowd-sourcing a funding target was another amusing result. They intended to support something that they wouldn't have heard of, but they rewarded popularity, which resulted in their having to fund something they'd heard of a million times.
0: https://docs.preqin.com/reports/Preqin-Special-Report-Women-in-Alternative-Assets-October-2017.pdf https://docs.preqin.com/reports/Preqin-Special-Report-Women-...
1: https://time.com/3989917/black-lives-matter-protest-bernie-sanders-seattle/ https://time.com/3989917/black-lives-matter-protest-bernie-s...
- artsyca 6y agoYou know, everyone's favorite stalinist republic in eastasia also operates under similar meritocratic auspices. You'll probably feel like downvoting this because you have no idea what I'm talking about.
- confuseshrink 6y agoSince you are right that I have no idea what you are talking about, could you explain what you are talking about?
- jerrre 6y agoIs there an article somewhere describing the last point (YC crowd sourcing)? Sounds like an interesting read, but can't find any thing with just these terms.
- bonoboTP 6y agoA related blog post calls this the Copenhagen interpretation of ethics (your ethical burden increases by interacting with the problem in any way, even positively): https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethics/ https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-eth... There are also other analogies: At work, if you touch something, you are now eternally responsible for maintaining it. Be it code or process or equipment. Changed the toner in the printer? Great, you can now do it all the time. "But you already know how to do it, it will just take a minute for you". The best tactic at work is to be really competent in the main job and push all energy into furthering the skills and experience and recognition in that and dodging all the crap work by appearing badly suited to them. You want your colleagues to say "ah he's a good guy, really competent, but this type of work is really not his kind, he'd forget it, mess it up or something". Basically the goofy distracted professor meme. Great at focusing on his specialty we pay him for but cannot be tasked with these everyday mundane shit tasks. On a larger scale, big tribal feuds are often among groups with small differences, like Christian denominations and wars over dogmatic debates on the details.
- fennecfoxen 6y ago> On a larger scale, big tribal feuds are often among groups with small differences, like Christian denominations and wars over dogmatic debates on the details. Did you have a big Christian war in mind which was specifically about dogmatic differences, and not primarily about monarchs exerting their power over some group or another?
- C1sc0cat 6y agoSome that come to mind The Byzantine iconoclastic controversy 8-9 centuries weakened the Empire. Some bits of the ECW (bishops wars) where religious. The northern Crusades (much more savage that the eastern ones) The Hussite Wars
- mrkstu 6y agoI think the modern version is Islamic- you see many Sunni nations more willing to work with Israel than Shia Iran. Christianity is not an explicit part of any modern state outside of the Vatican that I'm aware of (with a small technical exception for Britain's monarchy.)
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> Internet commenters frequently remark on how they would pay for good news... This is a classic observation in the real word, and well-known to marketers. What people tell you they would buy and what they actually buy are two different things, and we observe that everywhere in the marketplace. Actions speak louder than words. Measure actions.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoThis is precisely the problem I have with how one is supposed to approach looking for product-market fit in a startup: contact customers and ask "would you pay for this? how much? if not, what would make it so you'd pay for it?" I don't feel like that's a good way to find things for customers to buy, but it's the advice from the VCs.
- CuriousSkeptic 6y agoPerhaps this can inspire https://www.pretotyping.org/ https://www.pretotyping.org/
- dgb23 6y agoSide node: I like how you use the term "Internet commenters". It is a much better and neutral term than most I've seen. Like "XY-crowd", "hivemind", "the Internet" and so on.