4 ms·
> You began Catholic, that is to say you began with a system of values in stark opposition to reality. Well, I agree, but I also have never seen it written so
by simonebrunozzi 6y ago
> You began Catholic, that is to say you began with a system of values in stark opposition to reality.
Well, I agree, but I also have never seen it written so nicely like this.
- perl4ever 6y agoIt sounds like it might be clever, but then I realize I don't know what it means. If you had values not in opposition to reality, then they wouldn't be relevant to reality, would they? Because in not opposing reality, they couldn't guide you in changing it. The most you could really say about values being objectively wrong is if they are inconsistent and could not be fulfilled in reality in any possible universe. But what is a possible universe? And what if all value systems are impossible to completely fulfill?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cousin_it 6y agoYou're overthinking it. Some people have a "fuck this world" attitude, others don't, that's all Wells wanted to say.
- pjc50 6y agoIt's quite clearly a scientism/superstition feud. Remember that Ireland was extremely Catholic at this point, and the guilt/purity psychology of that would pervade everything. Wells is arguing that Joyce is being shocking for the sake of it in an internal struggle with his conservative values, while Wells sees himself as a scientific man "never been shocked to outcries by the existence of water closets and menstrual bandages". (Presumably a reference to Ulysees and the content that got it banned: https://www.bl.uk/20th-century-literature/articles/ulysses-and-obscenity# https://www.bl.uk/20th-century-literature/articles/ulysses-a... )
- bobthechef 6y agoPutting Joyce to one side, I can't really see how that has anything to do with Catholicism. In the first instance, there is no "system of values" only things of greater or lesser value (the fact-value dichotomy is hopelessly wrong). Second, what exactly is in stark opposition to reality? The whole ground of Catholicism/Christianity vis-a-vis who Jesus is (beginning in the Torah) is that the fall of Man had put men in opposition to reality (rebellion, really) and the ultimate source of reality that is God. Here we have the natural law theory of ethics that explains sin as willed act opposed to the good (and thus the true, and the beautiful) which is known through the nature of things, esp. of Man which is absolutely real. And where science is concerned, how about the Logos [0]? Christianity sees reality as utterly intelligible which gives all science (whether empirical or not) its footing and possibility. Any civilization, culture, or religion that stifles this will never produce a sustainable and flourishing scientific culture (Stanley Jaki develops this point in his books). A timely example is Islam where Allah is understood as arbitrary will and not analogically as primarily intellect. The result is that the world is rendered unintelligible and helps explain why the scientific achievements of the Islamic world were exceptions rather than the rule. Wells was probably mechanistic and scientistic in his outlook but likewise parasitically drew from the (warped) Christian heritage of his culture. [0] https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09328a.htm https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09328a.htm