4 ms·
It looks like that's already been done, and there are tightly packed groups where the infection rate was 70-100%, as mentioned above. So, no existing immunity a
by Animats 6y ago
It looks like that's already been done, and there are tightly packed groups where the infection rate was 70-100%, as mentioned above. So, no existing immunity at all, probably. That was the claim in the original article, but the data does not bear it out.
- mlyle 6y agoFinding densely connected subgroups in special populations (prisons, cruise ships) with high infection rates doesn't mean that that specifies the equilibrium herd immunity threshold in other populations.
- guscost 6y agoSimilarly, the plural of anecdote is not data. You are completely right, and nobody has a good rebuttal.
- hcknwscommenter 6y ago70% infection Suggests a LOT of pre-existing immunity. Moreover, even if 100% antibody + rates does not rule out a lot of pre-existing immunity. If I am naturally resistant to coronavirus (e.g., COVID patient sneezes in my face and I get a mild fever 10 days later), I'll probably develop antibodies from an exposure and otherwise be fine, I'd call that pretty damn good pre-existing immunity. According to your logic, that would be "no [pre-]existing immunity at all."