4 ms·
Post-hoc "evolutionary just-so story" of the day: animals evolved under conditions of predation, where they'd tend to lose blood regularly, either in the proces
by derefr 6y ago
Post-hoc "evolutionary just-so story" of the day: animals evolved under conditions of predation, where they'd tend to lose blood regularly, either in the process of fighting off/getting away from predators, or in the process of attacking prey with violent defenses. A species that goes years without losing any blood, is effectively operating its body in an evolutionary out-of-spec configuration. It might work, for a while; but it wasn't heavily optimized for.
A testable hypothesis for this: if you count only the animals that survive long-enough to die by degenerative disease, then animals that get regularly bloodied by their predators or prey species should have longer average lifespans; while animals who don't (e.g. because they have no natural predators; because they're herbivores; because they prey only upon species with no violent defenses) should have shorter average lifespans. This shouldn't be purely a per-species effect, but should also be seen in a lifespan difference between e.g. wild and zoo animals, if the wild animals engage in bloody conflict that the zoo animals don't.
Does anyone know if that hypothesis holds up at all? (Maybe/especially if the question is phrased in terms of heartbeats† rather than years?)
† http://robdunnlab.com/projects/beats-per-life/ http://robdunnlab.com/projects/beats-per-life/
- cjones26 6y agoMake bloodletting trendy again!
- jmpman 6y agoBlood donors?
- bbojan 6y agohttps://sciencenordic.com/body-death-denmark/frequent-blood-donors-live-longer/1425568 https://sciencenordic.com/body-death-denmark/frequent-blood-...
- simonsarris 6y agoI don't know but since I was young it always seemed intuitive that blood-letting ought to have some good effects. If xyz bad things buildup (say, heavy metals) exist in the blood stream, and you remove a few % of your blood stream to make new blood, haven't you removed some xyz bad buildup?
- musingsole 6y agoYeah, but you've weakened your body's ability to manage whatever xyz bad buildup and are now asking it to produce more blood as well. IANAD, but I'm pretty sure the medical consensus is that it's a net negative stress on the body.
- firethief 6y agoThat sounds more like an argument in favor of having kidneys than anything else...
- simonsarris 6y agoYeah definitely. It's good to have an oil filter. But what if you also change the oil?
- firethief 6y agoTouché!
- throwaway_jobs 6y ago> A species that goes years without losing any blood, is effectively operating its body in an evolutionary out-of-spec configuration. It might work, for a while; but it wasn't heavily optimized for. I think your/the hypothesis fails...take certain species of jellyfish that are biologically immortal, they don’t have blood at all. Coincidentally they are considered top of the food chain, so another knock to the hypothesis.
- peterwoerner 6y agoI think she/he/it was referring more specifically to mammals and other animals with blood.
- throwaway_jobs 6y agoWhy would you think they were referring specifically to mammals? Mammals isn’t mentioned once whereas species/animals is used very broadly In the context of very broad ideas of evolution. In either case, the hypothesis suggests animals should live longer in the wild than in captivity. So let’s take the only mammal that isn’t more likely to die from age/don’t die from old age, the naked mole rat. We don’t understand why they die and any given day there is a 1 in 10,000 chance they die at any age. In captivity they should have the same lifespan as lab rats (6 years); however, in the wild the have an average lifespan of 17 years and in captivity that expands to 30 years (again in contrast to the hypothesis where wild animals of the same species should live longer than those in captivity).
- derefr 6y ago> they don't have blood at all Then that would be an evolutionary in-spec configuration, since Cnidaria-phylum species have evolved under selection pressure for hundreds of millions of years in that "never losing blood, because it doesn't have any" configuration. For a similar reason, you wouldn't expect most plants to be troubled/benefited by the loss of solutes (= sap); a maple tree should probably live about the same lifetime whether it's tapped or not, because maple trees evolved mostly without predation. But for plants that have evolved over eons entirely under conditions of predation (e.g. where they're a primary ecological water source, like cacti in the desert—observable by the fact that they possess defenses to predation), you would expect a difference in longevity between those that lose transported solutes to predation, vs. those who don't.
- bloaf 6y agoA testable hypothesis for your idea: do women age slower than men.
- spiritplumber 6y agoThey certainly live longer
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- James_Henry 6y agoGood luck getting rid of all the confounders involved in testing that hypothesis. Men and women are much more different than in that one sex may lose more blood throughout their lifetime.
- Balgair 6y agoHere's a good-ish article on bloodletting in the modern age: https://www.artofmanliness.com/articles/the-potential-benefits-of-bloodletting-yes-bloodletting/ https://www.artofmanliness.com/articles/the-potential-benefi... TLDR: There are correlations that it reduces circulating iron, circulating cancer cells, arterial hardening, decrease insulin sensitivity, and it increased metabolism. Not a lot of super firm evidence though
- WheelsAtLarge 6y agoThe way to test this is to follow all people that donate blood.
- elmolino89 6y agoThere is another than menstruating women group of people losing blood: blood donors. If I remember correctly, it is beneficial for your health to donate blood if you have some predisposition for Fe accumulation (hemochromatosis in the severe form.