2 ms·
The author asks some questions which can be answered by gathering some data. This suggests going back and re-testing for antibodies some populations from tight
by Animats 6y ago
The author asks some questions which can be answered by gathering some data.
This suggests going back and re-testing for antibodies some populations from tightly packed groups - the cruise ship passengers, warship crew, and nursing home residents. The antibody tests are more accurate than they were two months ago. The key here is to find out how many people, definitely exposed to the virus, not only did not show any symptoms, but did not develop antibodies. That group presumably had some form of pre-existing immunity.
Is anybody doing something like that?
- Animats 6y agoIt looks like that's already been done, and there are tightly packed groups where the infection rate was 70-100%, as mentioned above. So, no existing immunity at all, probably. That was the claim in the original article, but the data does not bear it out.
- mlyle 6y agoFinding densely connected subgroups in special populations (prisons, cruise ships) with high infection rates doesn't mean that that specifies the equilibrium herd immunity threshold in other populations.
- guscost 6y agoSimilarly, the plural of anecdote is not data. You are completely right, and nobody has a good rebuttal.
- hcknwscommenter 6y ago70% infection Suggests a LOT of pre-existing immunity. Moreover, even if 100% antibody + rates does not rule out a lot of pre-existing immunity. If I am naturally resistant to coronavirus (e.g., COVID patient sneezes in my face and I get a mild fever 10 days later), I'll probably develop antibodies from an exposure and otherwise be fine, I'd call that pretty damn good pre-existing immunity. According to your logic, that would be "no [pre-]existing immunity at all."
- jacobush 6y agoThe article specifically points out that there could be herd immunity in a certain population without any antibodies.
- hcknwscommenter 6y agoYes, but that doesn't mean those people won't go on to develop antibodies if exposed to a significant dose, e.g., in a tightly packed community. It means they don't need to already have the antibodies to have a pre-existing level of resistance. It takes weeks to develop an antibody response from scratch.