4 ms·
> Well it turns out that if you produce a quantum field theory for gravity, it is not actually possible ... I heard about that. But why would you want to have
by scotty79 6y ago
> Well it turns out that if you produce a quantum field theory for gravity, it is not actually possible ...
I heard about that. But why would you want to have quantum field theory of gravity? Why can't you just consider gravity to be only about the shape of space-time in which everything including quantum field theories of everything else happen?
> Well general relativity (GR) and QFT both describe fundamental interactions ..
Does GR really describe fundamental interactions? For me it seem that it only describes shape of space-time where all the fundamental interactions take place.
> In cases where gravity is very strong though we do have these issues as we just don't know what happens due to lacking a proven theory of quantum gravity.
Isn't it just because we lack data from systems where gravity is extremely strong and systems are small/isolated enough to show any quantum effects? How can we be sure that we need quantum gravity? Why it's not enough to calculate QFT in curved spacetime instead of flat spacetime?
> One example is how the matter behaves in the super-dense core of a neutron star, known as the neutron star "equation of state", which is currently unknown, as in these cases both quantum and gravitational effects are very strong.
I see.
> Yes that is completely correct to our understanding, but we could maybe model it as a "real force" by writing a quantum field theory for it
Apparently we can't due to problems with renormalization. And I argue we shouldn't be able to because I believe it's completely different thing from a real force and if same math worked for two dissimilar things I'd be worried. :-)
I'm happy to hear that Pauli principle is unsettling not only to grumpy weirdo like me. :-)
- joeberon 6y ago>I heard about that. But why would you want to have quantum field theory of gravity? Why can't you just consider gravity to be only about the shape of space-time in which everything including quantum field theories of everything else happen? No, because it turns out that curved space-time is actually incompatible with quantum field theory in certain extreme parameter regimes, in a way that it actually makes it impossible to make predictions on scales where both gravitational and quantum effects are very strong (e.g. neutron stars). We want a quantum field theory of gravity as then it will "play nice" with other quantum field theories. >Does GR really describe fundamental interactions? For me it seem that it only describes shape of space-time where all the fundamental interactions take place. I think it is quite fundamental that energy curves space-time and that it affects the paths of objects (even light), but yes maybe I wouldn't call it a fundamental interaction in the same sense as quantum field theories, particularly because it isn't quantised so it isn't really a single "thing" being exchanged (like a gauge boson). Most physicists do call it an interaction or a force though. I mean that it describes nature on a fundamental and indivisible level (at least so far as our current/most popular understanding) >Isn't it just because we lack data from systems where gravity is extremely strong and systems are small/isolated enough to show any quantum effects? How can we be sure that we need quantum gravity? Why it's not enough to calculate QFT in curved spacetime instead of flat spacetime? Of course we lack this data, which is why measurements of, for example, the aforementioned neutron star equation of state will give us more understanding. We can't be sure that we need a quantum theory of gravity, it could be that it is actually just impossible to describe both gravity and QFT at the same time. QFT in a curved spacetime is only a first approximation of general relativity and doesn't capture all of the effects of GR (see here for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory_in_curved_spacetime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory_in_curved...). I don't really know much about quantum gravity, but I don't believe that QFT in curved space-time is sufficient, at the very least it doesn't solve the cosmological constant problem (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant_problem) > And I argue we shouldn't be able to because I believe it's completely different thing from a real force It's worth considering that what we call a force in quantum field theory is very different from what Newton would have considered a force! Probably in fact the gravitational "force" due to curved space-time would seem more like a force to him, certainly QFT is much weirder than GR after all...
- scotty79 6y ago> I think it is quite fundamental that energy curves space-time ... Most physicists do call it an interaction or a force though. Isn't it sort of 'legacy' way of thinking and naming things? > QFT in a curved spacetime is only a first approximation of general relativity and doesn't capture all of the effects of GR (see here for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory_in_curved... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory_in_curved...). Oh. Thank you. This looks way more promising. But I see that it has few very hard to accept results like lack of objective vacuum or particles loosing meaning (which I'm ok with :-)). And I see how it still fails to include influence of particles generated by gravity. But it makes interesting predictions already. I really think that's the way forward.