3 ms·
This may sound positive (less ads, less disinformation) at first glance, but I think it's actually a terrible and dangerous development. Zuck has seen that he'
by crazygringo 6y ago
This may sound positive (less ads, less disinformation) at first glance, but I think it's actually a terrible and dangerous development.
Zuck has seen that he's going to get hate no matter what his political content moderation policy is, so he thinks he can escape that by literally escaping from it: letting users just turn it off.
But while he has the legal right to, in the larger societal sense it's dangerously and profoundly antidemocratic. One of the most famous quotes regarding political speech is:
> "If there be time to expose through discussion the falsehood and fallacies, to avert the evil by the process of education, the remedy to be applied is more speech, not enforced silence." — Justice Louis Brandeis (emphasis added)
Enforced silence is the antithesis of a healthy democratic society. The ability to close yourself off in a bubble where you can't be reached by opposing viewpoints is relinquishing your duties as a democratic citizen.
The true downside of this is that people will continue to get toxic, false political speech from their crazy uncles, friends and family members -- and truth-minded political groups will be unable to place ads to counter that influence.
This is why it's a a terrible, dangerous development. Again -- Zuck has every legal right to do it since Facebook is a private (not governmental) entity. But as Facebook these days is essentially half of our national "town square" of citizens (the other half being Twitter), this is not a good direction for America (or the world broadly) to head in.
- mgbmtl 6y agoAds give more power to those with more money. It's not a leveled playing field, at least in the US. Many countries limit spending on adverts (or campaigns in general) for this reason.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 6y agoI'm not making any claims about how level the playing field is, or whether there ought to be limits to political ad spending in order to create a more balanced conversation. I'm arguing that being able to choose to eliminate political advertising entirely is antidemocratic. That's not balance -- it's deeply unbalanced.
- mgbmtl 6y agoYet advertising isn't necessarily speech, and nothing says it should be part of democracy. For example: https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/supreme-court-refuses-to-hear-appeal-of-plateau-mont-royal-billboard-ban-1.4928917 https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/supreme-court-refuses-to-hear-ap... Billboards advocated that they had the right to free speech. A provincial court agreed that they were visual pollution and subject to restrictions. The judgment was upheld. Advertisers abused their privileges and people are fighting back.
- minikites 6y ago>The ability to close yourself off in a bubble where you can't be reached by opposing viewpoints is relinquishing your duties as a democratic citizen. This is only true if each side has a valid and reasonable difference of opinion. This is not true for hate speech and other propaganda. For example, it's not an "opposing viewpoint" to say that people with dark skin are subhuman. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_(book)
- crazygringo 6y agoYes, which is why many European countries have laws against hate speech, although the US doesn't. But political advertising doesn't equal hate speech. Many people currently support the idea of Facebook and Twitter prohibiting hate speech, political or not. That has nothing to do with being able to turn off political speech in general. It's a totally separate issue. As for propaganda, that's in the eye of the beholder. Which is why we generally frown on censorship, because one person's propaganda is another person's deeply felt, legitimate political viewpoint.
- minikites 6y ago>But political advertising doesn't equal hate speech. It often does: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy#Evolution_(1970s_and_1980s) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy#Evolution_(1... >another person's deeply felt, legitimate political viewpoint I don't think "people with dark skin are subhuman" should be treated as a legitimate political viewpoint.
- crazygringo 6y agoBoth of your examples are hate speech. You can ban hate speech and leave political advertising unbanned. Obviously any political advertising that is also hate speech remains banned.
- at_a_remove 6y agoWould you apply this "hate speech" label to Yakub and such such ideas? I need to know how seriously to take you.
- dorkwood 6y agoTo test the strength of this argument, I'm imagining a world in which ads have invaded our homes even further, and can now be found on the refrigerator door, the bathroom mirror, and the bedroom ceiling. Would you consider switching off political ads in those places to be relinquishing your duties as a democratic citizen?
- crazygringo 6y agoThat's not the argument I made. A healthy democracy needs to have places for democratic discussion. Not all places need to be for it -- that would be terrible. But some places. Today, those places are mainly TV news/commentary, newspaper/magazine reporting and analysis, and Facebook+Twitter. Each of them have different strengths and weaknesses. Eliminating any of them for political speech would be a huge loss. To expand beyond them (into your home and refrigerator), you'd have to make an argument that it served a purpose that wasn't already served by the three domains I already mentioned. Which I don't see an argument for. You're posing a "slippery slope" argument here, but I don't think that applies.
- dorkwood 6y agoOh, I see. I'm not actually a Facebook user, so I didn't consider it to be a place for political discussion. I suppose that's the source of our differences. Edit: Just to clarify, I used it many years ago, but it was really just for sharing photos with family and friends.
- rattray 6y agoHuh? This isn't a toggle to turn off political _speech_ on fb, just ads. Or do you believe that Justice Louis Brandeis would have also demanded the societal remedy of "more ads"?
- catalogia 6y agoIt is not the duty of democratic citizens to subject themselves to advertisements. It is possible, and indeed preferable, to engage in bidirectional political discourse with other humans. e.g. Actually talk to people and have conversations.
- DenisM 6y ago>Enforced silence is the antithesis of a healthy democratic society. Your right to free speech goes hand-in-hand with my right to ignore your speech, for I which nowadays I need the earplugs. Do you not think I have that right?