6 ms·
It sounds like they're just taking existing bounty money for themselves. Only if your bounty is from before 2018, you can only redeploy it, and not get your mon
by mcv 6y ago
It sounds like they're just taking existing bounty money for themselves. Only if your bounty is from before 2018, you can only redeploy it, and not get your money back. Any bounty from between 2018 and today is just lost if it doesn't get claimed within 2 years. Future bounties probably won't be on this platform.
Sounds like a quick money grab while destroying your brand. Were they recently bought by a hedge fund or something?
- at-fates-hands 6y agoThey were acquired by CanYa in 2017. Looks like CanYa is a crypto startup? https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/canya#section-overview https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/canya#section-overvi...
- vorpalhex 6y agoA crypto startup doing shady things that are flirting with fraud? Why never... Maybe it's time for a browser extension that just tracks a list of crypto companies and warns you anytime their name appears on a page.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoIt makes sense to have some expiry. Else you can be left holding hundreds of thousands of dollars of people's money that will never return, forever, which really complicates your finances. Your own bank has clauses like this btw. I had to fight for my funds in a bank account I hadn't touched in seven years. And I once used a pay-as-you-go phone service that would consume your balance if you went 6 months without depositing. But two years seems way too aggressive for this sort of project.
- troydavis 6y ago> It makes sense to have some expiry. Else you can be left holding hundreds of thousands of dollars of people's money that will never return, forever, which really complicates your finances. There's a pretty simple answer here: return it to the person who posted the bounty. Other options could be letting them donate it (minus standard fees) to the maintainer(s) of the project that their bounty applied to or to an OSS organization. The choices aren't just "Hold on to it forever" and "Take it for Bountysource." It's on the books as a liability for a reason, namely, it's not Bountysource's money. (There's also an entire ecosystem for unclaimed property, which is where banks distribute money from customers they can't locate: https://unclaimed.org/ https://unclaimed.org/)
- rkangel 6y agoReturning it to the person who posted it may not be possible - card expired, can't get in touch with them etc.
- josephcsible 6y agoThat's a reasonable point, but they could have addressed it without keeping everyone's money. People would be a lot less upset if you had a 30-day grace period to claim a refund whenever a bounty expired, and only forfeit it if you ignored that. But they didn't do that, and are keeping everyone's money even when returning it is possible.
- 013a 6y agoSo, because it may not be possible in what is legitimately a small minority of cases, it should never be done in any case?
- tedivm 6y agoPlus there's actually a way to deal with that- California operates an unclaimed funds/property division that companies are supposed to hand money over to if they don't have the right to it. My wife actually found out that she was owed money from a previous medical provider who overcharged her- just had to fill out some forms. You can't just steal people's money because it's inconvenient to return it to them. https://www.sco.ca.gov/upd_msg.html https://www.sco.ca.gov/upd_msg.html
- ViViDboarder 6y agoEvery state does this. It’s called escheatment.
- coderintherye 6y agoEven in that case, in certain jurisdictions you are required to send the money to the government in a process called 'escheatment'. If the person comes back looking for their money after that point then they have to go to the state and prove that it is theirs in order to get it returned.
- henriquez 6y agoThis is an interesting problem that ruined a side project I worked on. I wanted to avoid forcing people to pay monthly subscription fees so instead I let them buy "credits" and pay as they go. Unfortunately many people bought credits and then disappeared after using the product a couple of times, leaving my company with thousands of dollars we were actually holding on behalf of our customers. My accountants informed me that even though we have that money in the bank it's not really "ours," and we can't even find a lot of these people in order to refund them. I'm not saying that what BountySource is doing is justified. In my case I need to just wind down the company because I think it would be unethical to pull this shit.
- csunbird 6y agoThat is why you should "sell" the credits, so the money belongs to you, I think.
- captainmuon 6y agoThe money belongs to you, but the credits belong to the customer. If you were selling cakes, and customers hold 1000 credits, you must hold on to enough money to buy the flour for those cakes, so to speak.
- renewiltord 6y agoCalifornia banks must follow escheatment to pass this to the state where it will be kept for you. So as a California resident this is what I'd want. I used BountySource to help out Neovim. I won't use it again. Thanks, guys, for bringing this to my attention.
- NikolaTACC 6y agoSome expiry yes but 2 years sounds to aggressive. Either 3 years or only for bounties where there has been really no activity at all after 2 years.
- mcv 6y agoTwo years could even be acceptable, but these are terms you need to specify up front. It's changing the terms on money that they already hold, that's the dirty part about this.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Else you can be left holding hundreds of thousands of dollars of people's money that will never return, forever, which really complicates your finances. An entire legal framework already exists for just this scenario, and it doesn't involve pocketing the money. Money and other assets are supposed to be relinquished to the state so that owner or intended recipient can collect it.
- rkangel 6y agoMy partner is the Grants Manager for a UK charity. It is a large ongoing hassle for them having funds marked for specific purposes with no expiry that they can't spend. There is a mechanism there where they can apply to the Charity Commission but it's a painful process (this is on purpose). There is no such recourse in this case so the idea makes perfect sense to me. Two years is the only bit I have an issue with - 5 would be a bit more reasonable.
- Nextgrid 6y agoIf the problem is truly to avoid holding a liability then donating the money to a charity, tech-related non-profit such as the EFF, or even redistributing it across all of the other active bounties (that are actually likely to be paid out) would be much better. What they're doing here is just a scummy cash-grab, and I am not sure how legal it is considering it applies retroactively.
- askjdlkasdjsd 6y agoThey were actually acquired by a crypto startup: https://coscout.com/organization/canya.io https://coscout.com/organization/canya.io Seems a bit shady if you ask me. Looks like the founder has also moved on (as per linkedin). So yeah, this just looks like a cash grab.
- JustAnotherVC 6y agoSource on linkedin? I can't seem to find the company listing.
- askjdlkasdjsd 6y agoWelp, looks like it was removed? I'm not sure what's going on here.. The plot thickens.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- seph-reed 6y agoI really wish there was a non-black-mirror way to throw a couple bucks towards putting a bounty on someones head. Doesn't have to be murder or anything. Maybe just wreck their cars and break a wrist or something. Literally just any repercussions at all for being like this would be a nice change of pace.
- quesera 6y agoThat's the most nonsensical idea I've heard from a non-politician in recent memory (apologies if I have made an incorrect assumption about your employment). What we have instead of terrible ideas like this, are laws. Unfortunately these are often designed by the same nonsensemongers mentioned above, but they are the only reasonable recourse.
- seph-reed 6y ago> the only reasonable recourse Good ideas don't start off fully formed. I'm talking about the desire to have a bottom up justice system. The fact that anger is the impetus means there is a lot of potential for a slippery slope, and I cede that. But the point stands: there are many people who've reaped nothing but benefits from being horrible, and I would gladly pitch a couple bucks to make their life miserable for a while.
- NikolaTACC 6y agoHm strange, A bit unlike Bountysource. It would make more sense if it was before 2018 and there has been no activity on the bounty/issue and even then they should offer redeploy or refund