5 ms·
This is a genuinely hard problem that capitalism doesn't give any kind of easy answer to. Obviously Apple is allowed to charge a fee. The App Store costs serio
by crazygringo 6y ago
This is a genuinely hard problem that capitalism doesn't give any kind of easy answer to.
Obviously Apple is allowed to charge a fee. The App Store costs serious money to run -- to develop, maintain, support.
But when the App Store is the only place apps can be published for iOS, and more than half of worldwide mobile app revenue is made there, there's no competition.
Nobody else can go and create their own separate iOS App Store with lower commissions. But the kicker is, there is a real consumer benefit to that -- the entire iOS world is built on a premise of security and privacy that only comes from having everything locked down and controlled by Apple, from a secure enclave to approved apps.
There are really only two solutions here:
1) Legislation to define this as a special kind of monopoly situation (a new definition of monopoly, at least in the US) and create some kind of profit cap where Apple isn't allowed to charge more than x% over revenue. But which feels pretty icky -- the government stepping in to tell you you're not allowed to maximize profit like any other business. And what's the legal basis for deciding whether the "allowed profit" is 5% or 50%? 10% or 12%? 0% or 100%? You can invent an argument for any number you want, but ultimately it's entirely arbitrary.
2) Legislation to require Apple, Google, Microsoft, and all OS's generally to allow third-party fully-integrated app stores. But which will obviously do serious damage to the reputation of the iPhone (and mobile devices generally), when people start to associate them with buggy malware apps that drain your battery and use dark UX patterns to trick you into giving them all your location, microphone, etc. permissions.
But both seem pretty gross, totally non-market, government-intervention. But Apple's 30% cut is also pretty gross at this point.
It sucks there's just no obvious, elegant, good solution here.
- tosers4 6y agoHonest question, why is 30% cut gross? what makes 30% gross and 10% not gross?
- crazygringo 6y agoHonest answer, it's the practical knowledge (from experience) that if there were competing app stores, it would be nowhere near that high, because there's no way the costs for Apple are anywhere close to that ($30 for a $100 app). Now that being said, a market-based solution would probably be structured very differently, something like $1 a year per thousand installs, plus $200 per any app update that changes features (isn't just bugfixes/performance), plus a 6% cut of sales. It's highly unlikely that paid apps would be able to subsidize free apps the way they do now. So while there would be winners (like Basecamp), there would also be big losers (hobbyist/independent free apps).
- tosers4 6y agoThe equivalent default stores in other systems charge the same. Google's services is 30% as well, and Steam is 30% as well. So it's "market price" for Native Store.
- ballenf 6y agoI'd argue capitalism has handled these issues in other realms successfully in the past. Before it was railroad monopolies. It took a decade or two, but Washington brought antitrust action against them. I'd argue the delay is a good thing within reason as we see how new industries evolve. Too long and you strangle commerce. Too short and your forced changes strangle innovation or are ineffective. The simplest is forcing Apple to allow 3rd party app stores. That may have the unfortunate side effect of making apple's App Store less secure if the fees charged are forced down below what it costs to do good security reviews. But it's not like any % revenue guarantees 100% perfect app reviews.
- braythwayt 6y agoBut when the App Store is the only place apps can be published for iOS, and more than half of worldwide mobile app revenue is made there, there's no competition. With respect, this feels like a goose-with-the-golden-eggs scenario. If we take away Apple's App Store revenues, won't their investment in iOS suffer? Which means they'll make it less attractive? Next thing you know, Apple has joined the Android market in a race-to-the-bottom. That would be a nice windfall for Google and Samsung, but if their revenue reflects the value users place on their products, all we've done is remove an option from consumers, and the end up with less choice. I'm not sure we can disrupt their business model without taking something away from consumers.
- spott 6y agoI think that there are some half-measures that can help, especially with the in app purchase 30%: 1) Make it required to be transparent about where the pricing goes: All in app purchases must break out Apple's share and the developers share. The idea being that it becomes more difficult for Apple to sell such profiteering to the general public... who actually have the ability to vote with their wallet and move to another platform. 2) Make it illegal for apple to force subscriptions to external services be available using the in app purchase framework. This allows developers to avoid the fee (at the cost of the convenience to their users). 3) Make it illegal for apple to prevent the disclosure of cheaper options elsewhere, perhaps while allowing them to prevent directly linking to such options. (Allow the statement "Go to our website for 30% off!", but actually linking to the website within this statement is ok for apple to prohibit) 4) Require the same fee and enforcement for all developers. The combination of these puts downward pressure on Apple's fees by forcing transparency and putting the cost of high fees on Apple, rather than on the individual developers. It also evens the playing field by preventing sweetheart deals with large companies.
- stock_toaster 6y agoI think #2 would only work if no apps were freemeium, or if dev licenses were more expensive (like playstation sdk licenses). Otherwise, I assume, apps would just skirt all fees as standard practice.
- spott 6y agoI think there is a line that is pretty easy to define there: if the app is an add on to a subscription (the subscription is useful without the app) and someone would actually purchase the subscription without the app, then the app can point to the subscription page. If the subscription isn't useful without the app, then apple deserves their share.
- qppo 6y ago>There are really only two solutions here: The compromise is to let Apple/Google pick their poison. 1) Zero/fixed low commissions but (almost) total control. 2) Any commissions but relaxed control.
- dylan-m 6y ago> the entire iOS world is built on a premise of security and privacy that only comes from having everything locked down and controlled by Apple, from a secure enclave to approved apps. Why is this such a popular opinion? If the security of your system relies on manual curation, your system is _fucked_. Security should be based on the user granting permissions, and the system communicating those permissions in a way that is clear and understandable. Which, fortunately, (as far as I am aware), it is.