3 ms·
Alternate Apple: "Yes, so what?" Creating an obligation on companies to support competitors products on their own products, and dictating the commercial and te
by simonh 6y ago
Alternate Apple: "Yes, so what?"
Creating an obligation on companies to support competitors products on their own products, and dictating the commercial and technical terms of how they must implement that access seems a pretty extreme step.
Many vendors sell devices that allow limited customisation via apps. Cars allow some software client options and not others. Games consoles allow some software such as games and entertainment apps and not others. Feature phones had limited curated app download options in their 'stores' long before the iPhone. If we can require Apple to accept apps we dictate onto their store using their infrastructure on terms they don't get to determine, why can't we also require Nintendo to accept non-game apps or even a third party browser on the Switch? Why can't Spotify, or hundreds of streaming media or podcast companies require car companies to provide access to them to install their client app on car infotainment systems?
Where does this principle of imposing design features and commercial obligations, and technical implementation details on companies to benefit their competitors end?
- virtue3 6y agoI think you should re-read everything about the Microsoft antitrust cases and apply that to Apple. It's pretty obvious to me what accounts to antitrust here and it's been very obvious for years. I think you should ask yourself really deeply "if this was the case on OSX would I be ok with it?" And use that lens.
- ratww 6y agoIt's not the same case. The allegation back then was that Microsoft was abusing monopoly power on Intel PCs in order to achieve victory in the browser wars. Also, an Intel executive even testified that the intent of Microsoft was indeed to kill Netscape. Neither of those things have happened here: Apple doesn't have monopoly power on cell phones, nor has achieved victory in a new browser wars due to bundling Safari. Whether new browsers (or browser engines, to be more precise) can be installed in iOS or not is a different matter altogether. Remember that back in the day it was possible to install Netscape on Windows, and Microsoft still got fire for it.
- simonh 6y agoI thought the browser finding against Microsoft was misconceived. The decision that including a browser in the operating system was anti-competitive bundling seems, from a modern perspective, utterly absurd. >It's pretty obvious to me what accounts to antitrust here and it's been very obvious for years. It's not obvious to me. >I think you should ask yourself really deeply "if this was the case on OSX would I be ok with it?" And use that lens. OSX is marketed as an OS that can run whatever software you like, and on which you can develop whatever software you like. Sure if they changed that I wouldn't be happy about it and I would move to another desktop OS. I would complain about it and fight it, but I wouldn't claim that Apple didn't have the right to do it. I don't have the right to dictate to Apple what products they design. OSX is a different tool for a different purpose. Not all tools, or even all screwdrivers have to be multi-bit screwdriver sets.
- ubermonkey 6y agoI really don't think you understand the material, enormous difference in positions here between MSFT during the antitrust/consent decree period, and Apple now. Microsoft controlled personal computing, full stop. The Mac was a rounding error in sales and desktops. They had a monopoly on an entire market, and as such were justifiably limited in their actions by the decrees and whatnot. iOS is a minority player. It's not even clear that they'd be a "monopoly" at 60% of the market, because Android provides such a strong alternative. Seeking to compel Apple to follow the rules set out for Microsoft at their most predatory is utter lunacy, and suggests a deep misunderstanding of the legal definition of "monopoly."