5 ms·
Congress: "Does Apple restrict, in any way, the ability of competing web browsers to deploy their own web browsing engines when running on Apple’s operating sys
by fsflover 6y ago
Congress: "Does Apple restrict, in any way, the ability of competing web browsers to deploy their own web browsing engines when running on Apple’s operating system?"
Apple: "The purpose of this rule is to protect user privacy and security."
https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU05/20190716/109793/HHRG-116-JU05-20190716-SD036.pdf https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU05/20190716/109793/HHRG... via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21587191 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21587191
Upd: Giving the freedom to users is not the goal of Apple. Quite the opposite.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoAllow a browser engine to be used if it meets strong privacy restrictions.
- _ph_ 6y agoA browser engine is a very security relevant part. Especially considering the ability to execute generated code, if you consider a JIT for Javascript code. This means, allowing arbitrary engines can have a significant security impact. As much as I resent most restrictions set up by Apple, this has at least some justification. However, it should be possibly to set up a proper sandbox for a browser app, so that security issues are contained to it and consequentially, it should be possible to run other browser engines on your devide.
- realusername 6y ago> A browser engine is a very security relevant part. Especially considering the ability to execute generated code, if you consider a JIT for Javascript code. This means, allowing arbitrary engines can have a significant security impact. As much as I resent most restrictions set up by Apple, this has at least some justification. That argument would work a little bit better if Apple wasn't shipping their products with the most outdated browser engine of all the current browser market in the first place...
- threeseed 6y agoIt's also the browser that by far uses the least memory, battery life etc. Apple has made it quite clear that they are more deliberate when adding new features than Google or Microsoft.
- realusername 6y agoI do agree with that, you can say it uses less memory and less battery but you really can't call it more secure in any way.
- grishka 6y agoAnd it also takes ages to implement new and more efficient standards. As of 2020, Safari is literally the only web browser with a significant market share that doesn't support webp images and opus audio.
- simonh 6y agoAlternate Apple: "Yes, so what?" Creating an obligation on companies to support competitors products on their own products, and dictating the commercial and technical terms of how they must implement that access seems a pretty extreme step. Many vendors sell devices that allow limited customisation via apps. Cars allow some software client options and not others. Games consoles allow some software such as games and entertainment apps and not others. Feature phones had limited curated app download options in their 'stores' long before the iPhone. If we can require Apple to accept apps we dictate onto their store using their infrastructure on terms they don't get to determine, why can't we also require Nintendo to accept non-game apps or even a third party browser on the Switch? Why can't Spotify, or hundreds of streaming media or podcast companies require car companies to provide access to them to install their client app on car infotainment systems? Where does this principle of imposing design features and commercial obligations, and technical implementation details on companies to benefit their competitors end?
- virtue3 6y agoI think you should re-read everything about the Microsoft antitrust cases and apply that to Apple. It's pretty obvious to me what accounts to antitrust here and it's been very obvious for years. I think you should ask yourself really deeply "if this was the case on OSX would I be ok with it?" And use that lens.
- ratww 6y agoIt's not the same case. The allegation back then was that Microsoft was abusing monopoly power on Intel PCs in order to achieve victory in the browser wars. Also, an Intel executive even testified that the intent of Microsoft was indeed to kill Netscape. Neither of those things have happened here: Apple doesn't have monopoly power on cell phones, nor has achieved victory in a new browser wars due to bundling Safari. Whether new browsers (or browser engines, to be more precise) can be installed in iOS or not is a different matter altogether. Remember that back in the day it was possible to install Netscape on Windows, and Microsoft still got fire for it.
- simonh 6y ago
- theandrewbailey 6y agoI seem to recall that one of their competitors got into very hot water about 20 years ago for almost the same reason, but I can't remember more details. \s