4 ms·
If you were right, science would be limited to designed experiments. The scope of science is broader, and collecting information about rare cases and studying t
by tsimionescu 6y ago
If you were right, science would be limited to designed experiments. The scope of science is broader, and collecting information about rare cases and studying them, even when they can't be predicted ahead of time or artificially induced, is absolutely a part of science.
By the logic you stated, seismology or volcanology would not be real sciences either, as earthquakes and volcanic erruptions can't be repeated with the same outcome each time.
Now, the article does seem to light on clinical details, and has a few personal flourishes that detract a lot from its use as a basis for a future study of similar cases, so I don't disagree that it's not really a scientific article, but the reasons are more nuanced. Well-written case studies are absolutely a valid scientific tool. This one reads more like an anecdote than a case study, though.
- pygy_ 6y agoScience is the process that makes our cultural representations of the world match the world as it can be observed and measured. Provided the author is otherwise trusted, even anecdotes add to the scientific corpus. "Hey, I saw this" is IMO valid science, even if a more thorough examination would have been better.